THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: June 11, 1997 09:33 AM Wednesday;
Rod Welch
Meeting Bill Benkavitch status COE contract.
1...Summary/Objective
2...Throw a Match on It Enlighten the World
3...New Ideas Require Dedicated Time for Consideration and Trial
4...Willfully Blind Experts Inoculated Against Innovation Paradigm Paradox
5...Experts Inoculated Against Innovation Willfully Blind Paradigm Paradox
6...Paradigm Paradox Experts Inoculated Against Innovation Willfully Blind
7...Too Much Time Causes Stress
8...Not Enough Time to Think Deeply Enough to Discover Better Ideas
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
SUBJECTS
Throw Match SDS Ready to Explode Frustrated Bill Benkavich SDS Diffi
2003 -
2003 - ..
2004 - Summary/Objective
2005 -
200501 - Follow up ref SDS 20 0000, ref SDS 19 0000.
200502 -
200503 - Bill picked up the SDS record that he was unable to download from the
200504 - Internet. He was complimentary about Communication Metrics and the
200505 - writing on managmenet and technology. Bill asked for assessment of
200506 - why the market has been slow to accept Communication Metrics. We the
200507 - discussed affect of limited time people have on the job. Now that
200508 - Bill has retired from the Navy, understanding SDS flows from extra
200509 - time he has had to think about the writing. People still employed are
200510 - unable to provide this level of consideration.
200511 -
200512 -
200513 -
200515 - ..
2006 -
2007 -
2008 - Discussion
2009 -
200901 - Bill wanted a copy of the notes for Intel, because he was unable to
200902 - download them from the email I sent.
200904 - ..
200905 - Bill feels there are a lot of good ideas in the Communication Metrics
200906 - procurement memo for Tom Keesling to submit to CESPN DE, ref OF 16 He
200907 - indicated that the San Francisco District Operation Plan, ref DRP 4,
200908 - submitted to him at ref DIP 5, has a strong foundation for improving
200909 - District operations.
200911 - ..
200912 - I advised of understandings that this plan has not yet been approved.
200913 - ref SDS 17 07559
200915 - ..
200916 - Bill recalled his experience at PERA in the Navy entailed several
200917 - major organization changes. He feels his experience could be applied
200918 - to support CESPN's Operation Planning.
200920 - ..
200921 - Bill cited some possible improvements, including review of assignment
200922 - to Public Affairs as the District proponent of using the Internet and
200923 - Intranets for improving communication in the District. ref DRP 4 9066
200925 - ..
200926 - Bill asked if I am frustrated about the inability to secure work with
200927 - the Corps of Engineers and others in light of the Communication
200928 - Metrics report, which seems to be a strong endorsement?
200930 - ..
200931 - I explained that experience working with the Corps of Engineers, PG&E
200932 - and other executives over many years shows that busy people need an
200933 - "intellectual" bridge for transformation from current work practice of
200934 - continual bumbling, explained in POIMS, ref OF 3 IE6L, to use a new
200935 - way of working, which is described in POIMS as "intelligence,"
200936 - ref OF 5 6649, and which a friend calls the "Welch Management Method,"
200937 - reported on 911123. ref SDS 1 0477
200938 -
200939 - [On 970624 Commander, San Francisco District USACE rejected
200940 - request by his team to use SDS, because the Commander did not
200941 - believe adding intelligence to management is cost effective.
200942 - ref SDS 24 7388
200944 - ..
200945 - POIMS technology automates and integrates critical, common practices I
200946 - learned over many years performing construction management. So it is
200947 - a little frustrating to hear people refuse help because they feel the
200948 - methods are "visionary," "futuristic," and "incredible," as occurred
200949 - at Intel on 960315.
200951 - ..
200952 - I have found it is difficult for people working day-to-day without
200953 - Communication Metrics to give these ideas the time required to
200954 - understand them, ref SDS 6 7404, absent actual experience, as occurred
200955 - at the Corps of Engineers.
200957 - ..
200958 - Managers and executives feel they are doing their best.
200960 - ..
200961 - Because they are working hard and feel they are intelligent, they are
200962 - unable to contemplate that technology and a new work role can improve
200963 - their work by an order of magnitude sufficient to justify the cost.
200964 - It is beyond comprehension, because it is outside their experience.
200966 - ..
200967 - Their daily business activity diminishes time needed to think about
200968 - new ideas and recognize that a different way of working can bring
200969 - improvement.
200971 - ..
200972 - Managers feel they have to expedite, and so believe there isn't enough
200973 - time for Communication Metrics. ref SDS 5 5002
200974 -
200976 - ..
200977 - Throw a Match on It Enlighten the World
200978 -
200979 - Bill seems very frustrated by slow acceptance of SDS, despite rational
200980 - explanations, per above. ref SDS 0 0007,
200982 - ..
200983 - Bill was adament today noting that the SDS 8-steps for Communication
200984 - Metrics (see POIMS, ref OF 5 685K) correlates with his efforts to use
200985 - good management in the Navy. He was kind and effusive complimenting
200986 - POIMS and NWO explaining SDS supports a better partnership between
200987 - leadership and technology. He said this is precisely what is missing
200988 - in executive management that exercises command and control with orders
200989 - that mostly arise from spontaneous, first impressions of complex
200990 - issues.
200992 - ..
200993 - Bill said that SDS is just waiting for someone to throw a match on it.
200995 - ..
200996 - He feels the underlying concept of integrating time and context with
200997 - an intelligence process to generate the power of knowledge (see POIMS,
200998 - ref OF 5 6649, provides a new fundamental force that cannot be denied.
200999 -
201000 - [On 990305 Max Wideman also frustrated. ref SDS 28 0001
201002 - ..
201003 - [On 990602 Bill comments on Communication Metrics on the
201004 - Internet. ref SDS 29 0001]
201006 - ..
201007 - [On 070126 Jack cites potentially explosive market acceptance of
201008 - SDS, which fits the Benkavich model of "throw a match on it."
201009 - ref SDS 34 JH4U
201010 -
201011 -
201013 - ..
201014 - New Ideas Require Dedicated Time for Consideration and Trial
201015 - Willfully Blind Experts Inoculated Against Innovation Paradigm Paradox
201016 - Experts Inoculated Against Innovation Willfully Blind Paradigm Paradox
201017 - Paradigm Paradox Experts Inoculated Against Innovation Willfully Blind
201018 -
201019 - Bill asked why people are so blind to the opportunity of using SDS?
201021 - ..
201022 - We took a moment and reviewed background above. ref SDS 0 0007
201024 - ..
201025 - Bill's sense of clarity today is heightened by additional time he has
201026 - now to think about complex, counterintuitive ideas. Further, as a
201027 - result of taking early-retirement from the Navy reported on 960821,
201028 - ref SDS 8 4483, similar to Bill DeHart a year so ago with PG&E, he is
201029 - no longer inoculated by cultural imperatives of prevailing paradigms
201030 - that prevent careful consideration of innovation.
201032 - ..
201033 - An example is Atanosoff's experience in 1941 presenting his design for
201034 - a digital computer to IBM, reported on 960304. ref SDS 7 VY4N
201035 - Mauchley was also ignored at Moore College in 1941. ref SDS 7 SX4H
201037 - ..
201038 - Example is the letter from Uncle Jim on 970522, who reported having
201039 - time to spend a lot of time reading and thinking about SDS, because he
201040 - is retired. ref SDS 16 0001 and ref SDS 16 FM6O He explains that
201041 - people on the job only have time for cursory review, which leads to
201042 - poor choices that cause problems, which creates limited time to
201043 - consider good ideas. It's a knowledge management dilemma. ref SDS 16
201044 - FZ4N
201045 -
201046 - [On 970911, see example from Caltrans. ref SDS 27 7774
201048 - ..
201049 - [On 000716 Professor Ransdell cautioned not to get discouraged by
201050 - slow acceptance of SDS. ref SDS 30 7838
201052 - ..
201053 - [On 020131 improvement at DOD resisted by culture of
201054 - denial. ref SDS 31 G15V Rumsfeld says to be persistant,
201055 - build circle of advocates. ref SDS 31 6L5K
201057 - ..
201058 - [On 030808 research organizations cannot support research that
201059 - conflicts with prevailing paradigm. ref SDS 32 S67H
201061 - ..
201062 - [On 040203 bureaucracy promotes conformity for order,
201063 - command and control for predictability to sustain
201064 - continuity, ref SDS 33 MB7K, which necessarily resists
201065 - innovation to improve communication. ref SDS 33 8Y5I
201067 - ..
201068 - The mind automatically harkens back constantly when not confronted
201069 - with new input, so ideas that underly Communication Metrics now seem
201070 - more intuitive and make "common sense" to him.
201072 - ..
201073 - People confronting constant "crisis" on the job do not have enough
201074 - time to recognize these same commonalities which are clear to Bill, as
201075 - seen for example on 960205. ref SDS 6 7404.
201077 - ..
201078 - People are blocked by ignorance, fear and denial, as reported for
201079 - example on 950223. ref SDS 4 3855
201081 - ..
201082 - We touched briefly on Bill's reaction to the SDS program in 1992...
201083 - ref SDS 2 0980 and at ref SDS 3 5592. At that time he felt there
201084 - wasn't enough time to use Communication Metrics. He was too busy to
201085 - give it the level of consideration he has since had the opportunity to
201086 - apply by virtue of early retirement.
201087 -
201088 - [On 970818 discussed "crisis management." ref SDS 25 1897]
201090 - ..
201091 - Bill asked if I have written about these ideas?
201093 - ..
201094 - Solutions for problems of traditional management are set out in the
201095 - New World Order... paper, e.g.,...
201096 -
201097 - Talking replaces analysis, causing mistakes. ref OF 10 5827
201098 -
201099 - Handwritten notes are inadequate. ref OF 10 3118
201101 - ..
201102 - Poor management is called "expediting." ref OF 10 7490
201104 - ..
201105 - Poor results are excused as Murphy's Law. ref OF 10 5203
201107 - ..
201108 - We considered the need to bring these ideas forward over and over
201109 - again and again in order to overcome the limitations of focus by
201110 - executives due to limited time. I tried to do this last year at
201111 - Asilomar, but it did not work out. We need an evalgelist movement,
201112 - but it is difficult to promote with limited funding.
201113 -
201114 - [On 970619 used this for an article reviewing the PMI Asilomar.
201115 - conference. ref SDS 23 7588]
201116 -
201118 - ..
201119 - Too Much Time Causes Stress
201120 -
201121 - Bill indicated his interim assignment as a chauffer is not a good
201122 - experience. He got a notice on his beeper during our meeting and
201123 - called his office. He received an assignmenet at 1230 today. Bill
201124 - said there is a lot of time during these assignments when there is
201125 - nothing to do. I suggested he get a dictation unit and capture his
201126 - thoughts for further consideration later.
201127 -
201128 -
201130 - ..
2012 -
2013 -
2014 - 1205 called Bill DeHart
2015 - ..
201501 - Got the name of the software program Bill DeHart is using which
201502 - enabled him to read the Word document I attached in an email
201503 - transmission which Bill Benkevitch reported above he was unable to
201504 - read. I will recommend this to Bill Benkevitch as a way to improve
201505 - his email system.
201506 -
201508 - ..
201509 - Not Enough Time to Think Deeply Enough to Discover Better Ideas
201510 -
201511 - I related Bill Benkavitch's puzzelment about the slowness in public
201512 - acceptance of Communication Metrics. ref SDS 0 3956
201513 -
201514 - Bill voiced similar frustration in concurring with the analysis,
201515 - above, that Bill Benkevitch has had time to think about Communication
201516 - Metrics, ref SDS 0 2870, but those who are employed and on call every
201517 - day do not have enough time for the reflection needed to grasp the
201518 - correlation between Communication Metrics and their daily work, ref
201519 - SDS 0 3596, per discussion with Morris last Saturday, ref SDS 21 4491
201520 - and ref SDS 21 0012.
201521 -
201522 - [On 970910 professional event reported that executives do not have
201523 - enough time to think. ref SDS 26 2139]
201524 -
201526 - ..
2016 -
2017 -
2018 - 1338 submitted Bill's Resume
2019 - ..
201901 - I decided to submit Bill's resume to Tom Keesling for
201902 - consideration separate and apart from using Welch for Communication
201903 - Metrics. His outstanding credentials would be helpful to the Corps of
201904 - Engineers, even if they don't use the Welch Company.
201906 - ..
201907 - Did this at ref SDS 22 8562.
201908 -
201909 -
201910 -
2020 -