THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: May 22, 1997 02:30 PM Thursday;
Rod Welch
Received response from Uncle Jim on COE Communication Metrics report.
1...Summary/Objective
2...Experts Assigned Review New Ideas Rarely Recognize Good Ideas
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
SUBJECTS
Get It Not Everybody at Same Time Senior People Think About Fundamen
0603 -
0603 - ..
0604 - Summary/Objective
0605 -
060501 - Follow up ref SDS 19 0000, ref SDS 17 0000.
060502 -
060503 - Received ref DRT 1 0001 from Uncle Jim dated 970515 and commenting
060504 - about the report issued by USACE on Com Metrics, ref DRP 1 6172, which
060505 - was sent to him with a letter, ref DIP 3 0001, on 970425 answering his
060506 - request for an explanation on distinguishing information from
060507 - knowledge. ref SDS 19 0001 He says....
060508 -
060509 - Thanks for sending over a copy of your Contract on the Corps of
060510 - Engineer project for the Richmond Harbor. I hadn't meant to delay
060511 - writing to you but it grabbed my interest and I spent quite a bit
060512 - of time going thru it.
060514 - ..
060515 - It pleases very much that, after long effort and study you seem to
060516 - have a very useful product. Like Newton said to the apple, "it is
060517 - now! fall!" ref DRT 1 JI5G
060518 -
060519 - [On 070226 Letter to Uncle Jim thanking him for ideas and
060520 - encouragement over the years. ref SDS 31 OT6F
060521 -
060522 -
060524 - ..
0606 -
0607 -
0608 - 1745
0609 -
060901 - Called Uncle Jim and thanked him for taking time to comment. During
060902 - the call, we discussed that USACE has not awarded a contract to
060903 - continue Communication Metrics. The management people put together a
060904 - procurement that requires approval by the commander of the San
060905 - Francisco District, and he has so far resisted the effort.
060906 -
060907 - [On 970624 met with Chief Engineer who gave reasons for
060908 - rejecting recommendations of senior staff on using
060909 - Communication Metrics to save lives, time, and money.
060910 - ref SDS 21 0001
060912 - ..
060913 - Uncle Jim related further perspective on helping people advance the
060914 - practice of management....
060915 -
060916 - Getting senior people to think about fundamentals and issue a
060917 - report shows progress.
060918 -
060920 - ..
060921 - Experts Assigned Review New Ideas Rarely Recognize Good Ideas
060922 -
060923 -
060924 - Uncle Jim continues...
060925 -
060926 - Keep in mind that everyone does not "get it" at the same time.
060927 - Part of my time in the Pentagon was working to improve management,
060928 - work processes, communication, efficiency -- that kind of thing,
060929 - including assignments on the C5 procurement program in the 60s and
060930 - 70s. So, apart from our family relationship, Com Metrics and SDS
060931 - caught my eye.
060933 - ..
060934 - [On 980307 Andy Grove describing difficulty improving work at
060935 - Intel described challenge that success blinds people to new
060936 - realities; some people just don't "get it." ref SDS 22 2648
060938 - ..
060939 - [On 011210 50 years to change attitudes on improving
060940 - established culture. ref SDS 26 R66K
060942 - ..
060943 - [On 020131 Secretary of Defense Don Rumsfeld explained why
060944 - culture resists change, ref SDS 27 KW9N, and how persistance
060945 - can grow a new culture to overcome resistance and enable
060946 - improvement. ref SDS 27 6L5K
060948 - ..
060949 - [On 070226 Letter to Uncle Jim thanking him for ideas and
060950 - encouragement over the years. ref SDS 31 OT6F
060952 - ..
060953 - You should know that we got lots of ideas at the Pentagon from
060954 - everybody, but less than 10% were worth anything, at least that
060955 - was my take. People get skeptical and cynnical, what-have-you, on
060956 - anything submitted from outside, so review is cursory. Time is
060957 - limited for careful analysis, because everybody is busy in
060958 - meetings, calls and shuffeling paper, often to solve problems
060959 - caused by using a hair-brained idea or method that somebody
060960 - way-back-when thought would work. If there is a ton of evidence
060961 - on benefits, we pay attention; but, then review is just a fait
060962 - accompli, endorsing what people are already doing. Bottom line:
060963 - even when you have something special, like Com Metrics might be,
060964 - it is largely luck getting through channels to effect improvement.
060966 - ..
060967 - On 950930 Uncle Jim talked about experience as a contracting officer
060968 - for the C5 military transport plane. ref SDS 3 X686
060970 - ..
060971 - Research on 960304 indicates that approving funding to develop digital
060972 - computer technology in 1943, which is the prevailing design today, was
060973 - lucky because experts at the time said digital computers would never
060974 - work, and was for the birds. ref SDS 5 YF6O
060975 -
060976 - [On 970611 Bill Benkavitch had a similar experience; after
060977 - retirement he was able to grasp merit in SDS, ref SDS 20
060978 - 0900, which, as a communications and managment "expert" he
060979 - previously overlooked while busy on the job using methods
060980 - that cause problems which SDS solves. ref SDS 20 2870
060982 - ..
060983 - [On 000716 Professor Ransdell noted SDS support for
060984 - Communication Metrics provides a theory that escaped
060985 - discovery since the 17th century, and cautioned not to get
060986 - discouraged by slow acceptance. ref SDS 24 7838
060988 - ..
060989 - [On 990713 Morris effort getting SDS evaluated at Intel
060990 - illustrates cursory analysis due to limited time, people
060991 - are discouraged, skeptical, cynnical about achieving
060992 - meaningful improvement. ref SDS 23 5R6N
060994 - ..
060995 - [On 011006 engineer frustrated why big projects get so
060996 - fouled up so quickly. ref SDS 25 O99K
060998 - ..
060999 - [On 020131 improvement at DOD resisted by culture of
061000 - denial. ref SDS 27 G15V Rumsfeld says to be persistant,
061001 - build circle of advocates. ref SDS 27 6L5K
061003 - ..
061004 - [On 030808 Pat Lincoln advised that "experts" are busy on
061005 - their projects; they do not have time to study and learn
061006 - how SDS can advance their work. ref SDS 28 S67H
061008 - ..
061009 - [On 040203 bureaucracy promotes conformity for order,
061010 - command and control for predictability to sustain
061011 - continuity, ref SDS 29 MB7K, which necessarily resists
061012 - innovation to improve communication. ref SDS 29 8Y5I
061014 - ..
061015 - [On 040721 Pat trying again to explain SDS opportunity,
061016 - busy scientists and engineers do not have time to consider
061017 - new ideas. ref SDS 30 UA9N
061018 -
061019 -
061020 -
061021 -
061022 -
0611 -
SUBJECTS
Get It Not Everybody at Same Time Senior People Think About Fundamen
0803 -
080401 - ..
080402 - Uncle Jim continues...
080403 -
080404 - Persistence is the key ingredient to give "luck" a chance to
080405 - bubble up in the right set of circumstances that gives people
080406 - experience, which is the only way to "learn" whether a new idea is
080407 - a better idea. Now that I have looked carefully at a number of
080408 - your SDS records, a common structure seems evident that improves
080409 - literacy for "documentation" required for military procurement.
080410 - In effect, you have integrated benefits of creativity in narrative
080411 - with the order of forms management. Combining time, subjects, and
080412 - linking makes a powerful new way of working to communicate
080413 - clearly, verify accuracy, and discover correlations in daily work
080414 - that otherwise get overlooked until mistakes occur.
080416 - ..
080417 - So, you have a "tiger by the tail," as we used to say.
080419 - ..
080420 - I think in this case that reading and writing are so fundamental
080421 - in culture, learned mostly in grades 1-3, that the prospect of
080422 - improving this basic system, which is never questioned throughout
080423 - adult life, seems impossible to busy people working without SDS on
080424 - solving problems that SDS avoids. You can see how difficult that
080425 - is to accept, shown by my problem last year getting into your
080426 - point about the difference between information and knowlede.
080427 - [Uncle Jim's letter on 961006. ref SDS 10 0001]
080429 - ..
080430 - Persistence, persistence. Hang in there.
080432 - ..
080433 - [On 010131 Secretary Donald Rumsfeld cited persistance as a key
080434 - ingredient for transformation to improve the Defense
080435 - Department. ref SDS 27 6L5K
080437 - ..
080438 - On 950930, Uncle Jim encouraged persistance to overcome resistance to
080439 - improving the work. ref SDS 3 H66K
080441 - ..
080442 - Uncle Jim's explanation about not enough time to think causing cursory
080443 - understanding reflects the article he submitted a few years ago that
080444 - reported information overload makes people spend 80% of the time
080445 - looking for information. ref SDS 1 CR6L
080447 - ..
080448 - Since he is retired, Uncle Jim had time to recognize on 961006 that
080449 - General Hatch read NWO three (3) times, ref SDS 10 0001, and so Uncle
080450 - Jim decided to invest time to grasp the core concept that knowledge is
080451 - different from information, and requested follow up. ref SDS 10 JW8O
080452 -
080453 - [On 970611 Bill Benkavitch had a similar experience; after
080454 - retirement he recognized merit in SDS, ref SDS 20 0900,
080455 - which he previously overlooked while busy on the job using
080456 - methods that cause problems which SDS solves. ref SDS 20
080457 - 2870
080459 - ..
080460 - An example of people unable to improve the work because they are too
080461 - busy on the job fixing problems to recognize the solution occurred on
080462 - 960406 when Millie reported difficulty finding documents, which SDS
080463 - avoids. ref SDS 6 5922 At that time, Morris noted this is a universal
080464 - problem, which means people are sketpical of new solutions.
080465 - ref SDS 6 4249
080467 - ..
080468 - Morris mention, also, at a later time that so few new ideas turn out
080469 - to be good ideas that people hired to evaluate new ideas do not have
080470 - enough time for anlaysis to recognize the good ideas.
080472 - ..
080473 - The basic challenge is presented in the homily that good ideas are
080474 - usually "hidden in plain sight, " because "Improvement comes dressed
080475 - in coveralls and look like work."
080476 -
080477 -
080478 -
080479 -
080480 -
080481 -
080482 -
080483 -
080484 -
0805 -