THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: September 1, 1994 10:53 AM Thursday;
Rod Welch
Reviewed PG&E pay estimate with CDWR; notes of Aug 18 meeting.
1...Summary/Objective
2...Follow Up
3...Welch Introduced to State Staff for Supporting CDWR Project Management
4...SDS Enables POIMS Technology and Communication Metrics
.....Scheduling
.....POIMS Technology
.........Personal and Organizational Integrated Management Support
5...SDS Design Improves Management
.....Line Numbers
.....Diary Report
.....Contacts
.....References
............SDS records
............Documents
............Other Files
........On-Line Access
........Citations & Knowledge
.....Control Fields Segment Information into Organic Subject Structure
6...Attendance at Aug 18 Meeting
7...Record of Communication and Worked Performed Enable Effective Planning
8...Lori said it was shocking to see her comments in SDS, because while
9...Transfer Trip Equipment Requirements
10...Information Management - Action Items
11...Next Progress Meeting
12...Clarify Understandings on Induction
13...Study, from Aug 18, Meeting
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
0201 - Calif. Dep Water Resources O-00000557 0201
020101 - Ms. Lori Brown, E.E.
020102 - Project Manager PG&E Contract, Coastal Branch, Phase II
020103 - Power Contracts
020104 - Mr. Ed Hills;
020105 - Mr. Om Lakhotia;
020106 - Mr. Bon Nu;
0202 - PG&E Transm Sys Contracts O-00000558 0201
020201 - Mr. Kevin Coffee O-00000557 0901
020202 - Electrical Engineer, Rm 2334 Mail Code B23A
020203 - Transmission Contracts
0203 - PG&E Proj Mngmnt Transm Sys O-00000329 0201
020301 - Mr. Bill DeHart, PMP
020302 - Senior Project Manager, Room 1183B-V11C
020303 - Project Management Department O-00000557 0901
0204 - The Welch Company O-00000040 0101
020401 - Mr. Rod Welch
SUBJECTS
Central Coast Aqueduct, PG&E
Meetings, 940901 Stockton with CDWR
Follow Up - Pay, Information Management
0505 -
0505 - ..
0506 - Summary/Objective
0507 -
050701 - Follow up ref SDS 7 0000.
050702 -
050703 - PG&E reported on adjustments to Pay Estimate valuations and
050704 - procedures. Understandings and Action Items were reviewed from the
050705 - progress meeting in Sacramento on Aug 18, 1994. PG&E explained
050706 - procedures for managing project information and Action Items using the
050707 - Schedule Diary System (SDS).
050708 -
050710 - ..
050711 - Follow Up
050712 -
050713 - 1. PG&E will revise Cost Plan and first Pay Estimate to reflect
050714 - internal accounting adjustment for feasibility study.
050715 -
050716 - [This was done on Sep 22, at ref SDS 13 line 411.]
050717 - ..
050718 - 2. PG&E will submit to CDWR the notes of understandings from
050719 - progress meeting with CDWR on Aug 18, 1994.
050721 - ..
050722 - [This was done at ref SDS 12 line 41.]
050724 - ..
050725 - 3. PG&E and CDWR will hold another progress meeting later in
050726 - September; PG&E will submit understandings from these meetings
050727 - to CDWR.
050728 -
050729 -
050730 -
050731 -
0508 -
SUBJECTS
Payment Procedures
Payment for August, 1994
Cost Plan for CDWR/Billing Estimate
1005 -
100601 - ..
100602 - Bill submitted a Cost Plan showing the estimated amounts PG&E expects
100603 - to bill each month. ref DIT 1 0000
100604 -
100605 - Bill plans to tie the monthly planned amounts to actuals, as the
100606 - project progresses.
100608 - ..
100609 - Reviewed PG&E's 1st pay estimate for the contract, ref DIT 2 0000.
100610 - Bill noted that CDWR has reimbursed PG&E $176K for project feasibility
100611 - study which is included in the todate actuals of $541K.
100613 - ..
100614 - The Cost Plan will be revised to reflect this adjustment.
100616 - ..
100617 - Bill indicated that the first billing will cover PG&E work through
100618 - July 1994. The $541K amount will be reduced by $176K to reflect prior
100619 - payments for the study.
100620 -
100621 - [This was done on Sep 22, at ref SDS 13 line 411.]
100622 -
100623 -
100624 -
1007 -
SUBJECTS
Control, Information, Meeting
Policy & Procedures, Meetings, Confirm Understandings
Objectives/scope
Meeting Notes, confirm understandings
Learning period/difficulty
2107 -
210801 - ..
210802 - Welch Introduced to State Staff for Supporting CDWR Project Management
210803 -
210804 - Bill advised that PG&E is evaluating SDS and the Welch Company
210805 - for management support. Some cost is being allocated to the CDWR
210806 - project within currently defined budgeting.
210807 -
210808 - Bill asked Rod Welch to explain SDS.
210809 -
210811 - ..
210812 - SDS Enables POIMS Technology and Communication Metrics
210813 -
210814 - Communication Metrics is a management science that uses a new work
210815 - role and the SDS program to improve daily management, as explained on
210816 - the web....
210817 -
210818 - http://www.welchco.com/00302.HTM
210820 - ..
210821 - The need for this new role set out in the NWO paper. ref OF 4 6369
210823 - ..
210824 - SDS is a software program that implements a technology called POIMS in
210825 - the same way that MS Word implements wordprocessing technology.
210827 - ..
210828 - SDS means the...
210829 -
210830 - Schedule Diary System
210831 -
210832 - ...software program that combines a Schedule for planning with a
210833 - related Diary that is organized by subject, people, organizations,
210834 - documents, cost and schedule to enable capture of daily work in a
210835 - record of organizational memory, explained in POIMS. ref OF 1 2300
210836 - Continual synergy between planning to take action and reporting on
210837 - what action to take improves management.
210839 - ..
210840 - Schematic of SDS listing features and benefits. see ref OF 2 3385
210842 - ..
210843 - Diagram of SDS record structure is also shown. ref OF 2 8558
210845 - ..
210846 - SDS enables a new way of working that produces "intelligence," as
210847 - defined in POIMS, ref OF 1 0561, to improve traditional work
210848 - practices, as explained on 930726. ref SDS 2 0001
210850 - ..
210851 - This record is an example of how the diary is used to capture the
210852 - record and analyse results of meetings and other events. The SDS
210853 - typical day scenario provides other examples of daily uses for the
210854 - SDS program. ref OF 3 0001
210856 - ..
210857 - Intelligence can be retrieved on particular subjects, people,
210858 - documents, and other objects quickly, so that organizational
210859 - memory can be used routinely to support action, with less reliance
210860 - on personal recall.
210861 -
210862 - [On 990202 showed Subject Index to USACE. ref SDS 24 5325]
210864 - ..
210865 - [On 970107 example. ref SDS 20 4953]
210867 - ..
210868 - [On 010730 "bridge concepts" help understand SDS. ref SDS 27
210869 - LC5O
210871 - ..
210872 - [On 011011 explained SDS and Com Metrics. ref SDS 28 VF4K
210874 - ..
210875 - Scheduling
210876 -
210877 - After a Diary report is prepared, it can be used to schedule
210878 - follow up actions. Scheduled tasks are linked to the diary
210879 - records that preceeded them, resulting in ordered chains of
210880 - related events, emulating human memory.
210882 - ..
210883 - SDS is a micro "scheduling" process for individual tasks to create
210884 - and carry out traditional macro planning using CPM and other
210885 - workflow management methodologies. The diary yields an audit
210886 - trail showing what was done, why and planning follow up to ensure
210887 - objectives for time and cost are met.
210889 - ..
210890 - Integration of the Schedule and Diary (time and information),
210891 - leads to the program name: Schedule Diary System.
210892 -
210894 - ..
210895 - POIMS Technology
210896 -
210897 - SDS emanated from Rod's experience in General Contracting.
210898 -
210899 - [On 000723 history of SDS was reviewed. ref SDS 26 0001
210901 - ..
210902 - SDS enables people to consistently use good management by reducing
210903 - the time required to perform POIMS....
210904 -
210905 -
210906 - Plan, Organize, Integrate & Measure
210907 -
210909 - ..
210910 - SDS architecture enables collaboration to build shared meaning
210911 - that leverages personal talent and organizational resources
210912 - through complementary efforts that improve productivity, so POIMS
210913 - also means...
210914 -
210915 - Personal and Organizational Integrated Management Support
210916 -
210917 - ...that integrates people, process and time. ref OF 1 015M
210918 -
210919 - The basic concept is to "Plan the work; and work the plan" using a
210920 - simple management cycle:
210921 -
210923 - ..
210924 - Plan Perform
210925 -
210926 -
210927 -
210928 - Report
210929 -
210930 - ..
210931 - See POIMS on the power of integration. ref OF 1 8951
210933 - ..
210934 - The "plan" for the meeting with CDWR on Aug 18, was the agenda
210935 - prepared by CDWR and the issues raised by PG&E. CDWR and PG&E
210936 - "performed" the meeting. Rod did a "report." Today, we "measure" and
210937 - correct understanding by reviewing the notes, which will then be
210938 - rolled over into "Controllable Action Items" for follow up.
210939 -
210941 - ..
210942 - SDS Design Improves Management
210943 -
210944 - Lori ask for an explanation of the SDS "Diary" format.
210945 -
210946 - The Diary provides a chronological organizing scheme that shows cause
210947 - and effect of events and decisions segmented according to objectives,
210948 - requirements and commitments. ref SDS 0 2929 Automated and custom
210949 - links let people get information quickly, and alert to issues that
210950 - need attention. The unique integration of Diary with Schedule helps
210951 - managers plan and be prepared in less time because Schedule tasks have
210952 - instant access to relevant background in the Diary
210953 -
210955 - ..
210956 - Line Numbers
210957 -
210958 - Line numbers in the left margin have two related functions:
210959 -
210960 - 1. Provide a flexible structure for identifying information,
210961 - explained on 890523, ref SDS 1 P13O, that is segmented by
210962 - context based on objectives, requirements and commitements so
210963 - that citations and references can be specific and enduring,
210964 - essential for an effective Knowledge Space, explained in
210965 - POIMS. ref OF 1 034J
210966 -
210967 - [On 020504 SDS strengthens guidance for drafting Federal
210968 - Acquisition Regulations using a numbering system for all
210969 - paragraphs. ref SDS 30 FA6N
210971 - ..
210972 - 2. The numbering scheme identifies the kind of information that
210973 - is on the line:
210975 - ..
210976 - 01 - Description of record, i.e., its "subject"
210977 - 02 - Contacts are people and organizations involved in event.
210978 - 03 - References to external information (see below)
210979 - 04+ Narrative description of what happened.
210981 - ..
210982 - An SDS record is a "chunk" of human memory that provides a
210983 - place to organize information with links showing cause and
210984 - effect (analysis). Line numbering facilitates this objective
210985 - to convert information into useful knowledge.
210986 -
210987 - [On 990303 work in cognitive science supports SDS design
210988 - for Knowledge Space. ref SDS 25 2838
210989 -
210991 - ..
210992 - Diary Report
210993 -
210994 - This is the DATE of the event being reported, as opposed to the
210995 - date of the document. The former is constant, whereas the
210996 - document date is whenever a diary is printed.
210997 -
210998 - "Subject" is a short explanation of the event.
210999 -
211000 - An "event" can be a meeting, phone call, inspection, analysing
211001 - a report, writing a letter, designing a circuit, scheduling a
211002 - job, reviewing a legal opinion, a heart operation, baking a
211003 - cake, --- anything the user wishes to think about and track.
211005 - ..
211006 - Contacts
211007 -
211008 - This is a list of organizations and people involved in an event.
211009 -
211011 - ..
211012 - References
211013 -
211014 - These are chronological lists of related information referred to
211015 - or used during the event. There are three types of References:
211017 - ..
211018 - SDS records
211019 -
211020 - These are diaries of prior related events that led up to
211021 - the current diary. The number preceeding the diary de-
211022 - scription is its date, thus: 940818 means Aug 18, 1994.
211023 -
211025 - ..
211026 - Documents
211027 -
211028 - Formal correspondence (e.g. E-mail) that relates to the
211029 - event, segmented according to Received or Issued.
211031 - ..
211032 - Other Files
211033 -
211034 - These are computer files like a Schedule, budget, a
211035 - contract, specification, magazine article, book, or other
211036 - publication that might be referred to during the event.
211037 -
211039 - ..
211040 - On-Line Access
211041 -
211042 - The program opens collateral sources by clicking the mouse or
211043 - pressing Enter on a listed reference.
211044 -
211046 - ..
211047 - Citations & Knowledge
211048 -
211049 - Links can be created between written analysis in SDS records
211050 - (THIS is an an SDS record), and external material listed under
211051 - References. This reduces the amount of writing and time needed
211052 - to apply information, since everything can be entered and
211053 - opened by pressing Enter or clicking the mouse (as on the
211054 - underlined portion of the next line).
211055 - ..
211056 - A citation can appear as ref SDS 6 8865.
211057 - ---------------
211058 -
211059 - ...which means the 4th line below the line "SDS
211060 - References," and to a line within that record that has the
211061 - unique anchor "8865."
211062 - ..
211063 - Similarly we could cite ref DIT 2 0000 which is the 2nd
211064 - entry under Documents Issued Today shown above on line 030402.
211065 - Clicking on that entry opens the document at the top because
211066 - "0000" is a default value that identifies the top of a file.
211068 - ..
211069 - SDS linking, citation and organizing features accomplish the
211070 - POIMS objective to convert information (meetings, calls,
211071 - documents, etc.) into "knowledge."
211072 -
211074 - ..
211075 - Control Fields Segment Information into Organic Subject Structure
211076 -
211077 - Narrative can be segmented according to context based on an
211078 - organic subject structure for objects and functions.
211079 -
211080 - Objects are both phyical, such as a truck, an employee, a project,
211081 - etc., and classifications of objectives like marketing, meetings,
211082 - CPM schedule activities, etc.
211084 - ..
211085 - Functions are usually cost accounts for tracking activity on the
211086 - objects of subject classification.
211088 - ..
211089 - Time and cost can assigned to a control field, so the process
211090 - comprises a giant time card that associates cost and schedule with
211091 - an explanation of what happened.
211092 -
211093 -
211094 -
211095 -
211096 -
211097 -
2111 -
SUBJECTS
Report on Meetings/Understandings
940818 CDWR in Sacramento, Progress Meeting
Policy & Procedures, Meetings, Confirm Understandings
Action Items, SDS Meeting Notes
Meeting Notes, Formal Events Omit Analysis
Shocking to Observe Complexity of
70% of Day Wasted in Meetings, Only 10% of
CDWR PG&E Project SDS Com Metrics Needed to Make Meetings Productiv
New Way of Working SDS Technology Applies Practices in Legal Analysis
4511 -
451201 - ..
451202 - Followed up PG&E internal review at ref SDS 6 0000.
451204 - ..
451205 - Reviewed with CDWR notes of meeting in Sacramento on Aug 18.
451206 - ref SDS 4 0000 PG&E will submit notes to CDWR per action plan on
451207 - 940829. ref SDS 6 9G6F Discussed scheduling next general progress
451208 - meeting.
451209 -
451211 - ..
451212 - Attendance at Aug 18 Meeting
451213 -
451214 - Bill requested a copy of the attendance list from the meeting, per the
451215 - record at ref SDS 6 0000.
451216 -
451217 - Lori will submit this to PG&E.
451218 -
451219 - [This was received at ref SDS 9 7777 - still have questions]
451220 -
451222 - ..
451223 - Record of Communication and Worked Performed Enable Effective Planning
451224 -
451225 - After Rod explained SDS methodology, above, ref SDS 0 9009, Lori
451226 - provided feedback to correct several understandings in the notes for
451227 - the Aug 18 meeting, ref SDS 4 RZ8G, and she requested a copy for CDWR.
451229 - ..
451230 - Bill said that he does not fully understand SDS design and use, but
451231 - work product accomplishes communication and documentation requirements
451232 - for project management, which other methods can't meet without hiring
451233 - a lot more people. With SDS one person tracks things and "connects
451234 - the dots" for effective coordination to get things done on time and
451235 - within budget.
451237 - ..
451238 - Lori said this is exactly what the Department needs.
451239 -
451240 - [On 950123 Lori explains why SDS works better than standard
451241 - management methods. ref SDS 18 7XFC
451243 - ..
451244 - [On 970908 PG&E management wants to improve communication.
451245 - ref SDS 22 8572
451247 - ..
451248 - Lori said it was shocking to see her comments in SDS, because while
451249 - she feels pretty confident of remembering what other people say during
451250 - long meetings, she cannot remember what she says. Lori explained that
451251 - the State does not have any business proceedures nor people assigned
451252 - to help everyone understand the story that unfolds day-to-day based on
451253 - the context of objectives, requirements and commitments. as set out in
451254 - the SDS reports. She feels the combination of history and analysis
451255 - showing correlations and implications between what is said during
451256 - meetings and occurs on the job, in calls and correspondence, email,
451257 - fax etc., helps everyone take timely action to avoid misunderstanding,
451258 - which otherwise causes mistakes, delay and extra cost.
451259 -
451260 - [On 941005 Lori reported CDWR distributes SDS notes of meetings to
451261 - create common understanding among CDWR staff, has found it saves
451262 - time. ref SDS 14 0001
451264 - ..
451265 - [On 941010 Bill advised Chris Snyder about progress using SDS.
451266 - ref SDS 16 7777]
451268 - ..
451269 - [On 941208 Lori requested PG&E continue using SDS for the CDWR
451270 - project even after PG&E cancelled Welch contract. ref SDS 17 1183
451272 - ..
451273 - [On 950123 Lori proposed that SDS be presented for colleagues at
451274 - CDWR during meeting with PG&E; management at PG&E rejected this
451275 - proposal. ref SDS 18 7XFC
451277 - ..
451278 - [On 960920 Tom Keesling at USACE made similar point about need for
451279 - better meeting management, ref SDS 19 4261.]
451281 - ..
451282 - [On 970418 USACE issued scope of services, deliverables for using
451283 - SDS to support Communication Metrics. ref SDS 21 958L
451285 - ..
451286 - [On 980307 Andy Grove's book "Only the Paranoid Survive" describes
451287 - how writing copious notes improves management and earnings at
451288 - Intel. ref SDS 23 2189]
451290 - ..
451291 - [On 011210 about 50 years are needed for established culture to
451292 - adopt a new way of working to save time and money. ref SDS 29 R66K
451293 -
451294 -
451296 - ..
451297 - Transfer Trip Equipment Requirements
451298 -
451299 - Om said that CDWR has received from Jivat the dimensions,
451300 - drawings and power requirements for PG&E's transfer trip rack,
451301 - reported on 940824, ref SDS 5 HM8G, and which were requested during
451302 - the progress meeting last week on 940818. ref SDS 4 YQ8K
451303 -
451304 - This accomplishes Follow Up item 14 from the progress meeting on
451305 - 940818. ref SDS 4 JQ5I
451306 -
451308 - ..
451309 - Information Management - Action Items
451310 -
451311 - Lori said it would help CDWR to receive SDS notes on the meeting today
451312 - and on future meetings with PG&E.
451313 -
451314 - [This was followed up at ref SDS 16 line 135, and at ref SDS 15
451315 - line 61, where SDS became standard practice for CDWR.]
451316 -
451317 -
451319 - ..
451321 - ..
451322 - Next Progress Meeting
451323 -
451324 - Bill said PG&E wants to schedule another progress meeting with CDWR,
451325 - after PG&E has an internal team meeting, per understandings at the Aug
451326 - 18, meeting, ref SDS 4 line 733. Lori indicated this can occur near
451327 - the end of the month. They will coordinate on specific date/time.
451328 -
451329 - [This was done at ref SDS 10 line 48.]
451330 -
451332 - ..
451333 - Clarify Understandings on Induction
451334 - Study, from Aug 18, Meeting
451335 -
451336 - Need to check with Maria Ly on the induction for touch potential under
451337 - fault conditions. There was not a good recollection today of the
451338 - values she presented at the meeting, ref SDS 4 line 818.
451339 -
451340 - [Got answer from Maria at ref SDS 8 line 60, and posted to the
451341 - meeting notes for Aug 18, 1994 at ref SDS 9 line 108, and more
451342 - detail at ref SDS 11 line 62.]
451343 -
451344 -
451345 -
451346 -
451347 -
4514 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"