THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: June 27, 1994 10:00 AM Monday;
Rod Welch
Visited Sherrill at Moffett Field to demonstrate SDS.
1...Summary/Objective
2...Follow Up
3...Status of Moffett Field Project
4...Sherrill asked how long it takes to learn SDS?
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
0201 - ICF Kaiser Engineers 415 965 8486 fax 962 9056
020101 - Mr. Sherrill McDonald; Project Manager
020102 - Mr. William J. O'Hair, P.E.; Contract Coordinator
020103 - Mr. Kelvin Yu; Project Controls Manager
SUBJECTS
SDS Marketing, Sales, Contacts with Customers
Demonstrations
0404 - ..
0405 - Summary/Objective
0406 -
040601 - Followed up discussion at ref SDS 10 line 43, and at ref SDS 11 line
040602 - 44. Sherrill appreciated the objectives of SDS explained in the paper
040603 - on POIMS submitted at ref SDS 9 line 93 via ref DIP 1 line 30; he
040604 - recognized how SDS implements it. He feels SDS might be useful on a
040605 - mining project Kaiser is starting in Nevada.
040606 -
040607 - Follow Up
040608 -
040609 - Sherrill will call Wayne Wetzel about the level of effort needed to
040610 - learn SDS. He will discuss SDS with a colleague involved with the
040611 - Nevada project for further consideration.
040612 -
040613 - Submitted ref DIT 1 line 20 confirming these understandings.
040614 -
040615 - [This was followed up at ref SDS 12 line 65, and again at ref SDS
040616 - 13 line 55.]
040617 -
040618 -
0407 -
0408 -
0409 - Discussion
0410 - ..
041001 - Sherrill and Bill recently took the PMP examination. They feel
041002 - it does not reflect the training materials and classes offered by PMI
041003 - to prepare for the exam (mainly true and false questions). It is based
041004 - on the PMBOK, but requires knowledge of sources referenced in the
041005 - PMBOK.
041006 -
041007 - Bill said the PMBOK at this time is more subjective than tests for
041008 - engineering and contracting. He thinks there should be more
041009 - objective questions on CPM, calculating and distinguishing types of
041010 - float. Those who pass an engineering exam can pretty much hire out
041011 - to perform the work covered by the exam, like designing a beam or a
041012 - foundation.
041013 -
041014 - My feeling is that management is an "art" of balancing competing
041015 - subsidiary objectives with limited resources including talents and
041016 - egos. I am concerned that many who get a PMP certificate are quite
041017 - likely not qualified to manage a project, while someone who cannot
041018 - calculate "float," make a WBS, or write a scope management, etc.,
041019 - can still perform project management because they know how to
041020 - "read" contracts and people. I am a strong advocate of CPM. We
041021 - need a "map" to see how to get from here to there, the various
041022 - routes and resources needed along the way.
041023 -
041024 - But we also need experience to recognize when relationships and
041025 - float are real, when they are volatile; and we need skill to work
041026 - the language of the contract, the CPM, the budget and anything else
041027 - that is necessary to insure that we spend less than is received.
041028 - So where an engineer can say "Look, I passed the test on how to
041029 - design a beam, so let me design one for you;" the PMP does not
041030 - impart the same level of competence in managing projects.
041031 -
041032 -
041033 -
041034 -
041035 - Status of Moffett Field Project
041036 -
041037 - Kaiser's job at Moffett is closing in a month. It was successful,
041038 - finishing within budget and on schedule. Kaiser provided CM services
041039 - for NASA's PM team.
041040 -
041041 - Bill's next assignment is on a mine in Ely NV. His experience and
041042 - perspective indicates he would make a good SDS person on the job.
041043 -
041044 -
041045 -
041046 -
0411 -
SUBJECTS
Correlation to accepted practice and
Executive Challenge, Self Dialog
Thinking Through Writing
Executive Work Practices
0807 - ..
080701 - Sherrill keeps a daily list of major tasks, and writes a diary
080702 - once a week of what gets done. I showed how SDS automates his
080703 - practice using "Controlled Visibility" to step deeper into details of
080704 - schedule tasks, and records of performed work, called the Diary.
080705 -
080706 -
0808 -
SUBJECTS
SDS Marketing, Sales, Contacts with Customers
Linking & Citations
Capturing the Record
1006 - Summary/Objective
1007 -
100701 - We discussed briefly the concept of "automated religion" in the paper
100702 - on the "New World Order...," ref OF 2 line 10, which I delivered to
100703 - Sherrill today. I used the record of the meeting today to step back
100704 - to the events leading to our meeting, including the Asilomar confer-
100705 - ence.
100706 -
100707 - We considered the TQM ideas presented and the ramifications of
100708 - Murphy's Law, per ref SDS 6 line 84. [Murphy is discussed further
100709 - in the papers on POIMS and "The New World Order,,," ref OF 1 line
100710 - 14 and ref OF 2 line 64.
100711 -
100712 -
100713 -
100714 - Sherrill asked how citations are embedded into narrative?
100715 -
100716 - I showed how to click to open a particular record, then click again
100717 - to cite a particular line in that record. Whether it occurred
100718 - yesterday or two years, ago, links are instantly created, including
100719 - necessary punctuation.
100720 -
100721 -
1008 -
SUBJECTS
SDS Marketing, Sales, Contacts with Customers
Subject Index
1205 - Summary/Objective
1206 -
120601 - Kelvin asked how information is identified?
120602 -
120603 - I demonstrated the primary organization structure of a straight
120604 - chronology, called the "diary," that mirrors the practice of
120605 - keeping a Schedule, except it goes backward in time.
120606 -
120607 - We looked at the Control Field that identifies a record by code and
120608 - conventional language according to organizational objectives. For
120609 - most public works projects the best way to define "objectives" is
120610 - to use the specifications, since they represent the scope of con-
120611 - tract obligation and have a natural structure.
120612 -
120613 -
120614 - Kelvin asked if the User has to remember all the codes and enter them
120615 - for each new task?
120616 -
120617 - The codes are looked up in the Subject Index to prompt the User to
120618 - consider alternative objectives at each level of detail. The User
120619 - then presses <Enter> or clicks the mouse, to assign a subject.
120620 -
120621 - Generally this process is only necessary the first time a new
120622 - sequence of events is started. Since performed tasks are used to
120623 - schedule follow up, there is a link between past and present
120624 - activity. This process copies the subjects, prior related events,
120625 - contacts, and documents, to the new task, so it is not necessary to
120626 - re-enter subjects each time a follow up task is created.
120627 -
120628 - Since every event has peculiar nuances, SDS enables the user
120629 - to assign multiple subjects to an event, so it can be found
120630 - and/or assembled in alternate ways. A piece of information
120631 - about a submittal approval, can in another context pertain to
120632 - schedule status, and in another context be relevant evidence
120633 - in a claim. Managers have the experience to recognize this
120634 - complexity. SDS provides the tools to apply a managers
120635 - experience, by assigning multiple subjects in seconds.
120636 -
120637 -
1207 -
SUBJECTS
Documents
1404 - Summary/Objective
1405 -
140501 - Bill asked how documents are identified to the system?
140502 -
140503 - Prepared a test letter to show how the data entry for the
140504 - document log is necessary in order to write a letter. This takes
140505 - 5 seconds, and is essential in order to maintain a viable
140506 - document log.
140507 -
140508 - We then ran a report on documents issued for which responses are
140509 - due. The letter just created was already in the doc log. The log
140510 - shows document chronology for each project. Reports can be
140511 - assembled by subject and contact within a project. The letter
140512 - itself can be opened by clicking on the entry in the log, and the
140513 - SDS record where the document was created can also be opened by
140514 - clicking in the log. This gives access to all of the related
140515 - context, analysis and links to other sources under which the
140516 - document was issued.
140517 -
140518 -
1406 -
SUBJECTS
Learning
Management Professionals
Design Professionals
Contractors
Learning period/difficulty
1908 -
190801 - ..
190802 - Sherrill asked how long it takes to learn SDS?
190803 -
190804 -
190805 - I explained that SDS requires on-site training and support gen-
190806 - erally for a few months to transition users. The most economical
190807 - way to acquire this training is to use Welch for special manage-
190808 - ment support (e.g. project start-up services like CPM, contract
190809 - development, communications management; or things like claims and
190810 - change order support, fixing a "sick" project.)
190811 -
190812 - SDS has to be learned during the normal work day, so you can bump
190813 - into the various situations that require all of the SDS tools.
190814 - Managers are hired to turn out work. Welch supports the manager
190815 - so the regular work gets done, but through SDS. Initially, the
190816 - manager starts by using only the results of the data base begun by
190817 - Welch. Welch sets up the SDS Contacts data base and the Subject
190818 - Index in consultation with project staff. Welch shows how SDS is
190819 - used to control the record and project agenda; prepares and
190820 - analyses correspondence to tie everything together. Gradually the
190821 - manager begins creating the data base. Over time, the SDS data
190822 - base becomes "sugar," as the power of knowledge is experienced in
190823 - a new and more dynamic way.
190824 -
190825 - I asked Sherrill to call Wayne Wetzel (Deputy Director of DNRC in
190826 - State of Montana) who went through this process. Wayne can
190827 - explain the results an executive can expect to attain. I will
190828 - submit some of the dialog with Wayne on this matter, as follows:
190829 -
190830 - Report (from Mike Sims, plant manager for Broadwater Dam), on
190831 - learning SDS, ref SDS 2 line 22.
190832 -
190833 - Record of discussions with Wayne Wetzel that combine SDS
190834 - training and compensable project support, ref SDS 3 line 44.
190835 -
190836 - Sample of Welch expertise in fixing "sick" projects, ref SDS 1
190837 - line 58.
190838 -
190839 -
190840 -
1909 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"