THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rod@welchco.com
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: July 31, 2012 04:30 PM Tuesday;
Rod Welch
Robin meeting Doctor Lawler recover knee disorders MRI tests.
1...Summary/Objective
2...Case Management Performed without Patient Assistance
3...Medical Records No Evidence Ordered from Lawler for 2nd Opinions
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
SUBJECTS
Knee Pain Worse Complications Surgery 120322 Evidence MRI Radiology
1003 -
1003 - ..
1004 - Summary/Objective
1005 -
100501 - Follow up ref SDS 22 0000. ref SDS 21 0000.
100502 -
100503 -
100504 -
100505 -
100507 - ..
1006 -
1007 -
1008 - Progress
1009 -
100901 - Case Management Performed without Patient Assistance
100902 - Medical Records No Evidence Ordered from Lawler for 2nd Opinions
100903 -
100904 - Follow up ref SDS 22 MI5I, ref SDS 21 MI5I.
100905 -
100906 - Received letter from Robin saying...
100907 -
100908 - 1. Subject: Re: Driving Directions to SLDC
100909 - Date: Tue, 31 Jul 2012 20:01:48 -0700 (PDT)
100916 - ..
100917 - 2. Thank you again for your suggestions in confronting the doctors
100918 - about my knees. [...responding to the letter yesterday on
100919 - 120730 1420. ref SDS 22 UN4Y...]. My girlfriend, Carol picked
100920 - me up from work today and took me to my appt with Dr Lawler. I
100921 - was Dr Lawler' last patient, an advantage because I got to ask
100922 - him the "list" of questions I had prepared and he was very
100923 - patient and thorough in answering my questions.
100925 - ..
100926 - 3. Bottom line, I have arthritis in both my knees and wear & tear
100927 - of the soft tissue. Dr Lawler said that I didn't need surgery
100928 - on either knee.
100930 - ..
100931 - 4. There isn't a way of gauging from 1 to 10 what level or degree
100932 - my knees are in at present other than ALL people at some point
100933 - will get arthritis at varying degrees.
100935 - ..
100936 - Question for Doctor Lawler is "degree" of degenerative arthritis in
100937 - Robin's knees compared to other patients her age, presented in the
100938 - letter to Robin yesterday on 120730 1420. ref SDS 22 UN4Y
100940 - ..
100941 - Letter from Robin continues...
100942 -
100943 - 5. Dr Lawler said at some point in the distant future I may need
100944 - arthritis medication or arthroplasty.
100945 -
100946 - 6. He said that I MAY need knee replacement in the distant future
100947 - but not way to tell at this point nor do I need it now.
100949 - ..
100950 - What is "arthroplasty?
100952 - ..
100953 - Research on Internet says...
100954 -
100955 - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthroplasty
100956 -
100957 - Arthroplasty (literally "surgical repair of joint") is an
100958 - operative procedure of orthopedic surgery performed, in
100959 - which the arthritic or dysfunctional joint surface is
100960 - replaced with something better or by remodeling or
100961 - realigning the joint by osteotomy or some other procedure.
100963 - ..
100964 - Arthroplasty seems to be another term for knee replacement.
100966 - ..
100967 - Letter from Robin continues...
100969 - ..
100970 - 7. He emphasized the importance of exercise to strengthen the
100971 - muscles around the knee, thigh muscles to support and take
100972 - stress off the knees. Of course no impact exercises.
100974 - ..
100975 - Robin does not mention discussion with Doctor Lawler about getting
100976 - more physical therapy planned in the letter to Robin yesterday and
100977 - including increased exercise to strengthen muscles that protect the
100978 - knee, reported on 120730 1420. ref SDS 22 UN6W
100980 - ..
100981 - Letter from Robin continues...
100982 -
100983 - 8. Dr Lawler is familiar with prolotherapy but doesn't believe it
100984 - works or would not endorse it, not recognized by the FDA, an
100985 - alternative treatment with no proof that it really works. Dr
100986 - Lawler said there are risks such as infection, solution side
100987 - effects and injecting in areas to where an adverse effect could
100988 - result.
100990 - ..
100991 - References issue in letter to Robin yesterday, and does not address
100992 - question of Doctor Lawler having treated patients who have received
100993 - prolotherapy, reported in the record on 120730 1420. ref SDS 22 UN5U
100995 - ..
100996 - Letter from Robin continues...
100997 -
100998 - 9. Dr Lawler did say that the burning I felt alongside the outside
100999 - of my knee very well could be the nerve that runs along that
101000 - area, sciatica nerve.
101002 - ..
101003 - Robin does not report that Doctor Lawler attributed continuing pain in
101004 - the right knee since surgery on 120322, due to neck and spine
101005 - disorders that cause pain in the leg and knee, called sciatica; nor
101006 - that Doctor Lawler made referral for care, planned for meeting with
101007 - Doctor Lawler in the letter to Robin on 120730 1420. ref SDS 22 UN7P
101009 - ..
101010 - Letter from Robin continues...
101011 -
101012 - 10. Also, told me that there are NOT new tears in my right knee,
101013 - that the post op MRI shows more clearly the edges of the soft
101014 - tissue and those are frayed edges NOT tears.
101016 - ..
101017 - This repeats prior reporting on Doctor Lawler disagreeing with
101018 - radiology interpretation of findings from MRI on 120717, as reported
101019 - by Robin on
101021 - ..
101022 - 11. Dr Lawler said the radiologist just READS and is not
101023 - experienced in the field of orthopedics, surgical procedures,
101024 - pre-op, post-op changes etc, shouldn't be giving his opinion
101025 - and scare the patient, being "me", yours truly.
101027 - ..
101028 - Letter to Robin recommended not mentioning discussions with Doctor
101029 - Vernacchia, the radiologist, reported on 120730 1420, ref SDS 22 UN6T;
101030 - so hopefully, Doctor Lawler is saying that radiology analysis reported
101031 - incorrectly finding 2 new "tears" in MRI test for the right knee on
101032 - 120717, as shown in the record on 120726 0753. ref SDS 18 PB3M
101033 -
101034 - [On 120802 1545 Doctor Schueckler, orthopedic surgeon,
101035 - 2nd opinion post-op examination finding bulging cyst on
101036 - patients right knee, ref SDS 23 MS38, and relates
101037 - causation from build up of fluid likely generated by the
101038 - body to protect against 2 tears in the right knee,
101039 - reported in follow up MRI on 120717. ref SDS 23 4T5N
101041 - ..
101042 - Letter from Robin continues...
101043 -
101044 - 12. Dr Lawler said too, that symptoms of arthritis, swelling etc
101045 - doesn't contribute to the tissue deteriorating, just a symptom.
101047 - ..
101048 - This representation seems conflicting with diagnosis of degenerative
101049 - arthritis.
101051 - ..
101052 - 13. Also, encouraged me to not worry that my knees are going to
101053 - burst, break but to strengthen the muscles.
101055 - ..
101056 - 14. In regard to taking gluclosimine he said no problem but there
101057 - isn't any proof that it makes a difference. He said to take it
101058 - for three months and go off of it and see if I feel a
101059 - difference.
101061 - ..
101062 - 15. Dr Lawler himself said he has arthritis in his knees and has
101063 - ceased being a runner, said it is the bodies sign of wear and
101064 - tear, aging.
101066 - ..
101067 - 16. I am relieved by all that Dr Lawler said, told me. I was very
101068 - worried that he was going to tell me that I would soon be a
101069 - candidate for knee replacement and he did my co-worker. I too
101070 - am very encouraged by your experience that you have overcome
101071 - the weakness in your knee with exercise and have avoided knee
101072 - replacement surgery, yay!!
101074 - ..
101075 - 17. I did get my MRI films from Lawler to take to the appointment
101076 - with Dr Schueckler this Thurs. Basically, I just want to go
101077 - to Dr Schueckler to get his opinion, what he says when he
101078 - looks at the MRI and reads my reports.
101080 - ..
101081 - 18. I'm not going to obtain progress notes, operative report etc
101082 - because if Dr Schueckler wants them he may obtain them after I
101083 - see him Thursday. There isn't time for him to review/look at
101084 - them before Thursday anyway.
101086 - ..
101087 - 19. I will appreciate your support in being there with me so I can
101088 - handle hearing, listening to what Dr Schueckler has to say.
101090 - ..
101091 - 20. I'm not expecting a completely opposite opinion but then I've
101092 - never met Dr Schueckler and depending on his take and how he
101093 - expresses what he thinks I may have difficulty hearing it more
101094 - so if I was alone.
101096 - ..
101097 - 21. I canceled my appointment with Dr Fow. After speaking with Dr
101098 - Vernacchia and a couple other people in the medical field, I
101099 - was advised that a second opinion is customary, not a 3rd, 4th
101100 - etc.. Too, my insurance only covers a 2nd opinion.
101102 - ..
101103 - 22. Dr Lawler is a highly esteemed orthopedic. Two people I work
101104 - with have had knee surgery by Dr Lawler and rave about him in
101105 - addition to others because of his reputation.
101107 - ..
101108 - 23. I'm uncertain about the prolotherapy, southern cal doctor so
101109 - will research further before I decide that I want to see Dr.
101110 - Darrow.
101112 - ..
101113 - 24. Oh, yes, there is parking where I work, ground level. San Luis
101114 - Diagnostic Center is on the corner of Monterey and Santa Rosa,
101115 - Shell gas station is across the street. I will come down, meet
101116 - you in the parking area 3ish ok:)
101118 - ..
101119 - 25. I hope you aren't disappointed in my lack of readiness for the
101120 - Schueckler appointment but I just want to get a second opinion
101121 - about what he sees on the MRI' and reports.
101123 - ..
101124 - 26. After the appointment, should Dr Schueckler decide to obtain
101125 - additional records, he may do so and I will follow up at a
101126 - later date. All of this is stressful and zaps my energy so
101127 - basically I just want to see how Dr Schueckler approaches my
101128 - condition.
101130 - ..
101131 - 27. I realize your time is valuable too and don't want you to feel
101132 - like you may be wasting a trip if I'm not prepared well. I do
101133 - appreciate your time and your sincere intentions in helping me
101134 - make the most of this appointment.
101136 - ..
101137 - 28. Yikes! its almost 8, gotta go to the gym, ride the bike!
101138 -
101154 -
101155 -
101156 -
101157 -
101158 -
101159 -
101160 -
101161 -
101162 -
101163 -
101164 -
101165 -
101166 -
101167 -
101168 -
101169 -
1012 -