THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: October 18, 2007 08:00 AM Thursday;
Rod Welch
Millie meeting at UCSF 10th cycle 1st treatment cetuximab for IBC.
1...Summary/Objective
2...Lab Blood Test Report
3...CT Test 070930 Reviewed at UCSF Shows Stable NED Condition
........Test History No Evidence Distant Metastasis
........Distant Metastasis No Evidence 5 Years Imaging Tests
4...Arm Right Slight Rash Similar Appearance IBC Not Diagnosed IBC
5...Cut Loose by Kaiser Patient Independent Contractor with UCSF
6...California Supplemental Support Clinical Trials Medicare Patients
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
SUBJECTS
UCSF Examination Medical Team Approve Start Next Cycle Treatment Cet
Arm Right Rash Slight Similar IBC Appearance on Left Arm Not Diagnos
0404 -
0404 - ..
0405 - Summary/Objective
0406 -
040601 - Follow up ref SDS 41 0000. ref SDS 40 0000.
040602 -
040603 -
040604 -
040605 -
040607 - ..
0407 -
0408 -
0409 - Progress
0410 -
041001 - Millie met with the medical team. Condition appears stable,
041002 - consistent with CT test report a few weeks ago on 070930, and reported
041003 - in the record for the meeting today, see below. ref SDS 0 4N7K
041005 - ..
041006 - Blood test results for lab performed at Kaiser yesterday were not
041007 - reported to UCSF in time for the meeting. Jackie is following up her
041008 - letter to Arlette, reported on 071017, ref SDS 46 Q45F, to get the
041009 - report from Kaiser. She proposed patient coordination with Kaiser to
041010 - get test results for Labs done at Kaiser will fit UCSF referral
041011 - coordination model better than reliance on the UCSF clinical trial
041012 - coordinator.
041014 - ..
041015 - The UCSF pharmacy delayed treatment today for an hour or so until
041016 - after Kaiser submitted the report for the blood test yesterday at
041017 - Kaiser in Martinez. ref SDS 46 UW5J This corrects prior quality
041018 - control problems when blood counts were found to be too low for
041019 - treatment after treatment was given.
041020 -
041022 - ..
041023 - Lab Blood Test Report
041024 -
041025 - Follow up
041026 -
041027 - While Millie was in the Infusion Clinic on the 5th floor, after
041028 - meeting with the doctor, Jackie brought a fax she received from
041029 - Arlette for the blood test at Kaiser yesterday. ref SDS 46 OS5K, and
041030 - which Jackie had coordinated with Arlette, ref SDS 46 Q45F, responding
041031 - to Millie's letter on 071015 asking about doing labs at Kaiser in
041032 - order to solve the payment dispute between UCSF and Kaiser.
041033 - ref SDS 45 KH5T
041035 - ..
041036 - The report does not show CA 15-3, ref SDS 48 5K6K, because the cancer
041037 - marker takes a day or so to prepare the diagnostic; nor is the value
041038 - for NEUTS shown, because Kaiser uses an ANC number, and this report
041039 - was done by Kaiser.
041040 -
041041 - [On 071019 Millie letter asks UCSF for CA 15-3 and NEUTS,
041042 - ref SDS 49 UW5J, to support considerations about returning to
041043 - active duty at work. ref SDS 49 JC6X
041045 - ..
041046 - [On 071023 Kaiser submitted CA 15-3 but not ANC, ref SDS 50 HP4L,
041047 - and omitted part of the blood test report. ref SDS 50 JM41
041049 - ..
041050 - Kaiser calculates an ANC composite number to assess safety for
041051 - patients to get treatment. UCSF calls this same calculation NEUTS,
041052 - reported on 070301. ref SDS 28 P560 The blood test eventually received
041053 - from Kaiser today does not list ANC. On 060814 Diana clarified the
041054 - formula at Kaiser for calculating ANC. ref SDS 19 P563
041056 - ..
041057 - WBC = 4.3............ ref SDS 0 UH37
041058 - Neutrophils = 36% .......... ref SDS 0 QK4L
041059 - Bands = 0
041060 -
041061 - 4.3 x 1000 x (.36 + 0) = 1548
041063 - ..
041064 - Kaiser ANC 1548 correlates to UCSF NEUTS 1.54.
041066 - ..
041067 - NEUTS 1.54 for the test on 071017 appears to have dropped slightly
041068 - from 1.69 for the test last month at UCSF on 070920. At UCSF, 1.54 is
041069 - below the level for safe treatment shown as 1.8 - 6.8, but 1548 is
041070 - slightly above Kaiser's standard of 1500.
041071 -
041073 - ..
041074 - CT Test 070930 Reviewed at UCSF Shows Stable NED Condition
041075 -
041076 - Follow up ref SDS 43 0001. ref SDS 40 EH5G.
041077 -
041078 - Prior CT test on 070723 was received on 070802. ref SDS 35 O85M
041080 - ..
041081 - Test History No Evidence Distant Metastasis
041082 - Distant Metastasis No Evidence 5 Years Imaging Tests
041083 -
041084 - Follow up ref SDS 35 LW6M, ref SDS 33 DA8O.
041085 -
041086 - Type Date Received Source
041087 - CT 070930 reported on 071018........... ref SDS 0 VK8L
041088 - CT 070723 reported on 070802........... ref SDS 35 IM6M
041089 - CT 070520 reported on 070524........... ref SDS 33 DA6Q
041090 - CT 070326 reported on 070329........... ref SDS 31 DA6Q
041091 - CT 070131 reported on 070202........... ref SDS 26 1Y8G
041092 - PET/CT 061227 reported on 070102........... ref SDS 22 1Y8G
041093 - CT 060930 reported on 061012........... ref SDS 20 284J
041094 - MRI 060708 reported on 060711........... ref SDS 18 PT4K
041095 - Xray 060623 reported on 060711........... ref SDS 18 WJ6G
041096 - CT 060505 reported on 060523........... ref SDS 17 E355
041097 - PET 060414 reported on 060428........... ref SDS 16 WJ6G
041098 - PET 060120 reported on 060126........... ref SDS 15 WJ6G
041099 - PET/CT 051005 reported on 051007........... ref SDS 14 WJ6G
041100 - CT 050530 reported on 050610........... ref SDS 13 G75L
041101 - CT 050325 reported on 050422........... ref SDS 12 G75L
041102 - CT 041217 reported on 041230........... ref SDS 11 G75L
041103 - CT 041103 reported on 041104........... ref SDS 10 WV7H
041104 - CT 040921 reported on 041005........... ref SDS 9 NL4N
041105 - CT 040710 reported on 040811........... ref SDS 8 H85S
041106 - CT 040410 reported on 040416........... ref SDS 7 LK5L
041107 - CT 040307 reported on 040318........... ref SDS 6 LK5L
041108 - CT 031031 reported on 031205........... ref SDS 5 IG9K
041109 - CT 030626 reported on 030710........... ref SDS 4 AL6N
041110 - CT 030428 reported on 030508........... ref SDS 3 LK5L
041111 - PET 021218 reported on 030109........... ref SDS 2 LK5L
041112 - PET 020529 reported on 020603........... ref SDS 1 0001
041114 - ..
041115 - CT test on 070930 (received from Kaiser on 071002), ref SDS 43 615J...
041117 - ..
041118 - [On 071213 received next CT scan prerformed on 071210.
041119 - ref SDS 51 0J7N
041121 - ..
041122 - 1. Procedure Note 0357370409/30/200708:08:25WCRX0101 10/2/2007
041123 - FISCH, ALLAN EUGENE (M.D.)
041125 - ..
041126 - 2. CT OF THE CHEST, ABDOMEN AND PELVIS
041127 -
041128 - 3. ** HISTORY **:
041129 - Breast CA
041131 - ..
041132 - 4. ** FINDINGS **:
041133 - Compare 7-23-07: Left mastectomy noted. There is no axillary
041134 - adenopathy. The lungs are unchanged, free of infiltrates or
041135 - masses. There are no pleural effusions. There are no hilar or
041136 - mediastinal masses seen. The heart is normal in size.
041137 -
041138 - [On 071213 CT test on 071210 reports findings in the report
041139 - for this test on 070930 show lymph node right axillary 8 x
041140 - 7 mm; increased to 11 x 11 mm; indicating analyst either
041141 - overlooked the 8 x 7 mm node or determined this was too
041142 - small to report. ref SDS 51 SR5P
041144 - ..
041145 - [On 071213 CT test on 071210 reports "stable 1.6 x 0.7 cm
041146 - pretracheal lymph node," ref SDS 51 SR5P; "stable" implies
041147 - this condition was shown in the report today for the test
041148 - on 070930, however, the report makes no such finding.
041149 - ref SDS 0 KK6J
041151 - ..
041152 - The liver, spleen, pancreas and adrenal glands are unchanged.
041153 - The kidneys are unchanged. The aorta is normal in caliber.
041154 - There is no adenopathy and no evidence of free fluid. Scans
041155 - through the pelvis are unchanged.
041157 - ..
041158 - There are stable degenerative skeletal changes.
041159 -
041160 - 5. ** IMPRESSION **:
041161 - Unchanged CT scan of the chest, abdomen and pelvis.
041162 -
041163 - A. FISCH M.D.
041164 -
041166 - ..
041167 - Examination by Brigid and Doctor Rugo shows no progression of IBC
041168 - disease.
041169 -
041170 - [On 071019 Millie notifies UCSF of considerations for returning to
041171 - work. ref SDS 49 4Q3H
041172 -
041173 -
041174 -
041175 -
041176 -
041177 -
041178 -
041179 -
0412 -
SUBJECTS
Arm Right Rash Slight Similar IBC Appearance on Left Arm Not Diagnos
0603 -
060401 - ..
060402 - Arm Right Slight Rash Similar Appearance IBC Not Diagnosed IBC
060403 -
060404 - Millie reported new slight rash on upper, inner right arm extending
060405 - below the elbow on inner arm area, first noticed yesterday. Rash
060406 - presents low intensity dispersed red dots, similar in texture to IBC
060407 - rash on upper left arm.
060409 - ..
060410 - Brigid recalled slight rash on right arm occurred previously, reported
060411 - on 070301. ref SDS 27 H15M At that time, the rash persisted for
060412 - several weeks, reported on 070315. ref SDS 29 FO6H A week later on
060413 - 070322 the nurse in the Infusion Clinic reported no evidence of rash
060414 - on the right arm. ref SDS 30 LI4M
060416 - ..
060417 - Brigid also recalled Cellulitis occurred as slight rash on entire left
060418 - arm observed during meeting on 070607. At that time, Doctor Rugo made
060419 - examination and prescribed home treatment for Cellulitis. ref SDS 34
060420 - ZI35 This progressed rapidly after the meeting, ref SDS 34 TU6J,
060421 - resulting in UCSF treating Millie for Cellulitis in the Infusion
060422 - Clinic. ref SDS 34 8J37
060424 - ..
060425 - Doctor Rugo noted today there is no evident rapid progression that
060426 - occurs with Cellulitis. The condition is closer to what occurred on
060427 - 070301,per above. ref SDS 0 SL8M
060429 - ..
060430 - This may be an example of inflammation side effects from cetuximab
060431 - noted in UCSF documention received on 070116, ref SDS 24 MH4Q, which
060432 - was mistaken for Cellulitis during examination at Kaiser on 070330.
060433 - ref SDS 32 F46F
060434 -
060435 -
060436 -
0605 -
SUBJECTS
Default Null Subject Account for Blank Record
0703 -
070401 - ..
070402 - Cut Loose by Kaiser Patient Independent Contractor with UCSF
070403 -
070404 - Follow up ref SDS 38 XH5H, ref SDS 37 I49K.
070405 -
070406 - Doctor Rugo expanded today on the record of communications arranging
070407 - for Millie's treatment at UCSF last January. She seemed to indicate
070408 - having interpreted communications with Kaiser after 070119 to mean
070409 - that Millie was "cut loose" by Kaiser to be an independent contractor
070410 - managing the transaction between UCSF and the patient, including
070411 - Medicare, and without benefit of her bargain with Kaiser for insurance
070412 - premiums to pay for account management, which Kaiser is obligated to
070413 - perform under Senior Advantage EOC Section 2, reviewed on 070927.
070414 - ref SDS 42 WS6M
070416 - ..
070417 - This condition of being "cut loose" from Kaiser performing contract
070418 - management, including payment of expenses, was not conveyed to Millie
070419 - prior to UCSF performing work on the referral, and has never been
070420 - disclosed by Kaiser nor UCSF.
070422 - ..
070423 - On 070130 Millie met at UCSF for the first time to start work, and
070424 - gathered from the doctor that business arrangements had been resolved
070425 - between Kaiser and UCSF, and that UCSF and Kaiser would work as a team
070426 - collaborating on Millie's care. ref SDS 25 AQ5L There was no
070427 - discussion of costs and payments at that time on 070130, other than
070428 - that the doctor was relieved Millie would not get stuck with a big
070429 - bill, ref SDS 25 LY9H, because Kaiser had previously agreed in
070430 - correspondence with UCSF on 061230 to pay any costs not covered by the
070431 - clinical trial. ref SDS 21 3X6K Kaiser in fact at all times performed
070432 - as retaining responsibility for managing Millie's referral at UCSF by
070433 - making regular examinations providing oversight of UCSF work, shown by
070434 - the meeting at Kaiser on 070202, ref SDS 26 0000, and continuing
070435 - regularly to the present, exactly the same as Kaiser did for prior
070436 - referrals, when Kaiser paid all costs - see case study listed on
070437 - 070830. ref SDS 36 LQ5I
070439 - ..
070440 - The doctor apologized today about complex billings from UCSF, cited in
070441 - Millie's letter to the doctor on 071011, ref SDS 44 UW5J, saying
070442 - payment would be deferred until UCSF clarifies procedures and amounts.
070443 - ref SDS 44 K64Q Doctor Rugo indicated that accounting is "another
070444 - world" far apart from the medical services department, and so she
070445 - cannot get involved in determining who all at UCSF bills patients for
070446 - medical services.
070448 - ..
070449 - California Supplemental Support Clinical Trials Medicare Patients
070450 -
070451 - Doctor Rugo explained today an understanding that California law
070452 - requires HMOs to pay for referrals treating patients with clinical
070453 - trials, including 20% coninsurance called out in Medicare law,
070454 - reviewed on 070917. ref SDS 39 4Q3I
070456 - ..
070457 - The doctor feels Kaiser is fighting this additional requirement in
070458 - California law.
070460 - ..
070461 - Research with...
070462 -
070463 - California law HMO referral "clinical trials" cancer Medicare
070464 -
070465 - ...yields sources that seem to say California HMO's must pay for
070466 - standard of care for referrals to treat cancer...
070468 - ..
070469 - Another source says about half-way through the page...
070470 -
070471 - Health Net
070472 - HMO Plan 52Y
070473 - Summary of benefits and Disclosure Form
070474 -
070475 - http://healthnet.com/static/custom/unprotected/pdfs/ccsf_hmo_benefit_summary.pdf
070477 - ..
070478 - Clinical trials Routine patient care costs for patients
070479 - diagnosed with cancer who are accepted into phase I, II, III,
070480 - or IV clinical trials are covered when medically necessary,
070481 - recommended by the member's treating physician and authorized
070482 - by Health Net. The physician must determine that participation
070483 - has a meaningful potential benefit to the member and the trial
070484 - has the rapeutic intent. For further information, please refer
070485 - to the EOC.
070487 - ..
070488 - This is actually what happened at Kaiser. The doctor reviewed the
070489 - trial and determined it is the best treatment for the patient, and
070490 - prescribed it, reported on 070105. ref SDS 23 PK7L
070492 - ..
070493 - Questions are whether Health Net scope of coverage for clinical trials
070494 - of patients diagnosed with cancer applies to senior folks who have
070495 - Medicare. Kaiesr is hanging its position on Medicare benefits.
070497 - ..
070498 - Presumably Health Net has a legal team comparable to Kaiser, and so if
070499 - they conclude the Health Net clinical trial scope is supported in the
070500 - law, then Kaiser may be reaching too far denying such coverage.
070502 - ..
070503 - May have found a source for federal health law...
070504 -
070505 - Health Administration Responsibility Project
070506 - Relevant WWW Links
070507 -
070508 - http://www.harp.org/links.htm
070509 -
070510 -
070511 -
070512 -
070513 -
0706 -