THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: January 19, 2007 11:00 AM Friday;
Rod Welch
Millie meeting with Jackie at UCSF sign consent, treatment delayed.
1...Summary/Objective
2...Clinical Study Consent Forms Signed
3...Treatment Delayed Not Enough Time Fix Kaiser Policy Conflict Medicare
4...Policy Conflict Kaiser Medicare Treatment Delayed Not Enough Time Fix
5...Medicare Policy Conflict Kaiser Treatment Delayed Not Enough Time Fix
6...Notify Doctor Treatment Delayed at UCSF
7...Primary Care Physician Reports Referral Authorization Signed
8...Authorization Submitted by Doctor for Referral Treatment at UCSF
9...Laboratory Blood Test Report Received from Kaiser Incomplete
10...Notify Arlette about Submitting Blood Test Lab Report to UCSF
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
SUBJECTS
Cetuximab Carboplatin Clinical Study Drug Trial Consent Forms Signed
1903 -
1903 - ..
1904 - Summary/Objective
1905 -
190501 - Follow up ref SDS 14 0000. ref SDS 13 0000.
190502 -
190503 - Mil signed consent forms for the clinical study on Cetuximab and
190504 - Carboplatin drug trial. The primary care physician signed
190505 - authorization for Kaiser to pay for treatment under the insurance
190506 - agreement with Millie. Treatment was delayed because after submitting
190507 - authorization, Kaiser management encountered a policy conflict with
190508 - its Medicare subsidiary. ref SDS 0 AS96 Delayed authorization for two
190509 - weeks until today, resulted in not enough time for Kaiser to resolve
190510 - policy conflicts in time for Millie to get treatment today.
190511 - ref SDS 0 AS9L UCSF is assisting Kaiser in resolving the problem so
190512 - that Millie can get treatment next Tuesday or Wednesday. ref SDS 0
190513 - AS5H Blood work reports submitted by Kaiser to UCSF are incomplete.
190514 - ref SDS 0 AS6M Millie sent a letter asking Arlette to make a review
190515 - and notify Millie about getting another blood test if necessary to
190516 - meet protocol requirements for Millie to get treatment next week.
190517 - ref SDS 0 PK6M
190518 -
190519 - [On 070122 primary care physician reports work resolving
190520 - confusing Medicare regulations, so that Millie's treatment
190521 - can proceed as prescribed. ref SDS 16 LX8B
190523 - ..
190524 - [On 070122 Kaiser ordered additional blood tests; still
190525 - need report from Kaiser on test results, including CA 15-3.
190526 - ref SDS 16 AS6M
190528 - ..
190529 - [On 070123 Margaret notifies Millie that UCSF has not
190530 - received authorization for treating Millie, and invested
190531 - many hours attempting to contact Medicare, but was not
190532 - successful; requests patient to ask her doctor at Kaiser
190533 - for assistance to expedite authorization. ref SDS 17 3S3J
190535 - ..
190536 - [On 070123 Millie notifies primary care physician at Kaiser
190537 - that treatment is delayed because authorization signed by
190538 - the doctor on 070119 has not been submitted by Kaiser to
190539 - UCSF, causing risk of cancer cascading out of control, and
190540 - escalating costs, ref SDS 17 J94L; Kaiser reportes that the
190541 - doctor is on vacation. ref SDS 17 LP4L
190543 - ..
190544 - [On 070123 Jackie advises treatment scheduled for 060124
190545 - delayed until Kaiser submits authorization number for UCSF
190546 - to get paid for treating Millie, ref SDS 17 J43I; asks
190547 - patient to notify Kaiser about detailed history of problem
190548 - in order to resolve impasse. ref SDS 17 FS33
190550 - ..
190551 - [On 070124 Pam reported Kaiser eventually made contact with
190552 - Medicare representative; after 8 hours of discussions
190553 - Kaiser submitted an authorization account number to UCSF.
190554 - ref SDS 18 6K3L
190556 - ..
190557 - [On 070125 Jackie reported that UCSF did not receive an
190558 - authorization from Kaiser, and that Lisa in UCSF's Business
190559 - Office spent 6 hours talking to Medicare for authorization
190560 - that UCSF would be paid for treating Millie. ref SDS 19
190561 - 4Y62
190562 -
190563 -
190564 -
190565 -
190567 - ..
1906 -
1907 -
1908 - Progress
1909 -
190901 - Clinical Study Consent Forms Signed
190902 -
190903 - Follow up ref SDS 13 QM7I, ref SDS 12 RT7K.
190904 -
190905 - Jackie said she finally received Millie's letter, ref DIP 1 0001,
190906 - submitted to UCSF on 070117. ref SDS 13 1G3K, but was not received at
190907 - that time via transmission through the Internet. ref SDS 13 Y25Q
190909 - ..
190910 - During the meeting this morning, Jackie reviewed consent forms for the
190911 - clinical study initially submitted with her letter received on 070116,
190912 - ref SDS 12 RT7K, and discussed with Jackie by telephone the next day
190913 - on 070117. ref SDS 13 QM7I
190915 - ..
190916 - After brief discussion, Millie signed the forms, and initialled
190917 - authorization for UCSF and associated organizations to use tissue and
190918 - diagnostics for study purposes, as called out in the confidentiality
190919 - section of the consent document. ref DRP 1 6O53
190920 -
190921 - [On 070130 Millie signed supplemental authorization for UCSF to
190922 - share biopsy tissue with clinical study personnel. ref SDS 21 2O3L
190923 -
190924 -
190925 -
190926 -
190927 -
1910 -
SUBJECTS
Payment Authorization Kaiser Signed Authorization for Millie's Treat
6403 -
640401 - ..
640402 - Treatment Delayed Not Enough Time Fix Kaiser Policy Conflict Medicare
640403 - Policy Conflict Kaiser Medicare Treatment Delayed Not Enough Time Fix
640404 - Medicare Policy Conflict Kaiser Treatment Delayed Not Enough Time Fix
640405 -
640406 - Follow up ref SDS 14 YF8U.
640407 -
640408 - Jackie commended Arlette's work at Kaiser this morning coordinating
640409 - communications with UCSF on getting the doctor's authorization signed,
640410 - and submitting patient history to UCSF on meeting with the primary
640411 - care physician, and on recent blood work.
640412 -
640413 - [On 070126 Arlette facilitated resoution of problem that delayed
640414 - Kaiser submitting payment authorization for Millie to get
640415 - treatment at UCSF. ref SDS 20 F184
640417 - ..
640418 - Jackie said that Doctor Rugo cannot meet with Millie today, and Millie
640419 - cannot get treatment today, as planned yesterday, ref SDS 14 1B5F,
640420 - because there was not enough time to resolve the mixup getting
640421 - documentation on referral authorization from Kaiser, reported
640422 - yesterday, ref SDS 14 YF8U, to implement agreement on 061230 for
640423 - Kaiser to pay costs for Standard of Care. ref SDS 4 3X6K This delay
640424 - appears to conflict with reports on 070105 that Kaiser ignored other
640425 - issues in order to focus on referral to UCSF. ref SDS 7 794K
640427 - ..
640428 - Jackie advised that Millie's primary care physician at Kaiser signed
640429 - authorization this morning for UCSF to start treatment today,
640430 - following Millie's letter last night notifying Kaiser of the problem.
640431 - ref SDS 14 PK6M Kaiser then encountered another problem resolving
640432 - internal policy and practices between Kaiser insurance obligations and
640433 - Medicare rule changes because Millie has coverage under Medicare that
640434 - is also a business unit of Kaiser, or something like that.
640436 - ..
640437 - [On 070122 primary care physician reports resolving
640438 - authorization policy confusion so that Millie can get
640439 - prescribed treatment. ref SDS 16 LX8B
640441 - ..
640442 - [On 070123 UCSF reports authorization not received from
640443 - Kaiser, treatment deferred. ref SDS 17 4Q54
640445 - ..
640446 - [On 070130 treatment delayed for referral coordination,
640447 - ref SDS 22 2X6L; UCSF schedules new tests so Millie can
640448 - start treatment on 070201. ref SDS 21 N96O
640450 - ..
640451 - [On 081031 Glenna reported the primary care physician at
640452 - Kaiser signed authorization for Millie's treatment with the
640453 - sunitinib clinical study to recover from Millie's 5th
640454 - relapse of IBC. ref SDS 32 J28K
640456 - ..
640457 - Jackie said that Doctor Rugo has encountered this problem previously,
640458 - and is working closely by telephone with Millie's primary care
640459 - physician to resolve the administrative conflict at Kaiser. She
640460 - described a concentrated effort by both doctors, but so far there has
640461 - not been enough time to solve the problem, because work only started
640462 - today rather than on 070101 when Kaiser and UCSF agreed to make
640463 - arrangements for Millie to get treatment at the UCSF Cancer Center.
640464 - ref SDS 5 E23W Proactive case management to avoid delays was
640465 - discussed at Kaiser on 070105.
640467 - ..
640468 - Doctor Rugo wants Millie to come back next Tuesday or Wednesday to
640469 - meet for examination, and then get treatment after authorization
640470 - documentation has been received from Kaiser. Jackie advised that
640471 - 070124 (next Wednesday) is a target date in order to meet standards
640472 - for treatment within 4 weeks of testing. Since Millie had a PET/CT
640473 - test on 061227, the end of 4 weeks occurs on 070124. Delay beyond
640474 - 070124 will cause further delay for Millie to have another CT test.
640475 -
640476 -
640477 -
640479 - ..
6405 -
6406 -
6407 - 1552
6408 -
640801 - Notify Doctor Treatment Delayed at UCSF
640802 - Primary Care Physician Reports Referral Authorization Signed
640803 - Authorization Submitted by Doctor for Referral Treatment at UCSF
640804 -
640805 - Follow up ref SDS 14 PK6M.
640806 -
640807 - Millie received ref DRT 1 0001 from the primary care physician
640808 - responding to Millie's letter, ref DIP 5 0001, yesterday on 070118
640809 - reporting UCSF needs authorization for treatment, ref SDS 14 NR7V, to
640810 - perform work in clinical trial referral made by Kaiser on 070105,
640811 - ref SDS 7 PK68, and implementing arrangements Kaiser made with UCSF in
640812 - correspondence on 061230. ref SDS 4 3X6K
640814 - ..
640815 - The primary care physician at Kaiser says...
640816 -
640817 - Authorization was submitted ...but, new Medicare regulations
640818 - around this are confusing. Dr Rugo and I are working on it
640819 - from both ends. ref DRT 1 0001
640820 -
640821 - [On 070829 Arlette seemed to advise the Millie is the first
640822 - patient referred for treatment under the new Medicare
640823 - regulations, and this is causing confusion about handling
640824 - payments. ref SDS 23 EG4N
640826 - ..
640827 - [On 070906 UCSF Clinical Trial Director confirms Kaiser
640828 - made referral for Millie's treatment, ref SDS 25 UK5M, and
640829 - the patient was not notified of extra charges for
640830 - coinsurance, because nobody knew anything about this issue
640831 - when treatment was started on 070202. ref SDS 25 I49K
640833 - ..
640834 - [On 070917 UCSF reports errors in billings; reduces charges
640835 - from about $10K to only $2K per year for coinsurance,
640836 - ref SDS 26 595P; no evident justification for coinsurance
640837 - charges. ref SDS 26 596Q
640839 - ..
640840 - [On 071002 Mark Manfriede seems to indicate Millie is the
640841 - first patient who has been processed by CMS under new
640842 - Medicare rules for clinical trials. ref SDS 28 GJ6M
640844 - ..
640845 - [On 070927 Kaiser Senior Advantage EOC presents 16 grounds
640846 - for Kaiser liability to pay for Millie's treatment on
640847 - referral to UCSF. ref SDS 27 WU6M
640849 - ..
640850 - [On 071006 Paula in Kaiser's MCRC unit asks why the doctor
640851 - prescribed treatment with cetuximab and carboplatin at
640852 - UCSF. ref SDS 29 Q969
640854 - ..
640855 - [On 071031 Millie receives notice dated 071026 UCSF plans
640856 - referral to collection agency for payment of $202.65 on
640857 - Kaiser referral account 12493370, ref SDS 30 KK4I, revised
640858 - 070830, ref SDS 24 4P8K, and revised again on 070917,
640859 - ref SDS 26 MK4H; no indication of UCSF collection efforts
640860 - against Kaiser; separate notice dated 071027 and also
640861 - received 071031 UCSF says Millie's treatment for cancer
640862 - ordered by Kaiser will be terminated if UCSF does not
640863 - receive payment of $202.65. ref SDS 30 KM8J
640865 - ..
640866 - [On 071128 Kaiser Appeals Committee approved payment for
640867 - Millie's care on referral to UCSF. ref SDS 31 JZ5R
640869 - ..
640870 - Millie submitted ref DIT 2 0001 responding to the primary care
640871 - physician at Kaiser saying...
640872 -
640873 - 1. I met with Jackie at UCSF this morning, and signed the consent
640874 - forms. ref SDS 0 1G3K Jackie said that you and Doctor Rugo are
640875 - working on authorization, but there may not be enough time for
640876 - me to get treatment today, so it was deferred to next week,
640877 - which is still within the window for using the last PET/CT
640878 - test. ref SDS 0 AS96, ref DIT 2 0001
640879 -
640880 - [On 070122 primary care physician reports work resolving
640881 - authorization issues, so that Millie's treatment can
640882 - proceed as prescribed. ref SDS 16 LX8B
640884 - ..
640885 - 2. Jackie said the lab report Kaiser faxed to UCSF was missing
640886 - diagnostics on a "liver panel," and maybe something else. I
640887 - told her that you specified a complete work up for starting
640888 - treatment, so some pages of the report may not have been sent
640889 - over to UCSF. ref SDS 0 AS6M, ref DIT 2 OE6G
640891 - ..
640892 - 3. I wrote to Arlette and asked her to coordinate with Jackie on
640893 - getting the complete lab in time for treatment next week, and
640894 - to let me know if I need to rush over to Martinez for more
640895 - blood work. I requested a copy of the report via email.
640896 - Wondering about CA 15-3? If it has not jumped up again, I
640897 - won't feel so rushed about everything. ref SDS 0 Q95H,
640898 - ref DIT 2 HF6N
640899 -
640900 - [On 070122 primary care physician orders additional blood
640901 - tests; still need report from Kaiser on test results,
640902 - including CA 15-3. ref SDS 16 AS6M
640904 - ..
640905 - 4. Thanks for following up. ref DIT 2 TF7M
640906 -
640907 -
640908 -
640909 -
6410 -
SUBJECTS
Laboratory Blood Test Report Received from Kaiser Incomplete Bumblin
8403 -
840401 - ..
840402 - Laboratory Blood Test Report Received from Kaiser Incomplete
840403 -
840404 - Follow up ref SDS 14 5S6L.
840405 -
840406 - Jackie advised that the report received from Kaiser this morning on
840407 - Millie's blood test from yesterday, ref SDS 14 5S6L, is missing a
840408 - "liver panel," and possibly something else.
840410 - ..
840411 - Millie examined the document Jackie received from Kaiser, and noted
840412 - there is a single page for the blood test report.
840414 - ..
840415 - Millie explained that the scope of the blood test is ordered by the
840416 - primary care physician, and is prescribed to meet requirements for
840417 - establishing a baseline to begin chemotherapy treatments.
840418 -
840419 - [On 070122 Kaiser primary care physician ordered additional
840420 - blood tests; still need report from Kaiser on test results,
840421 - including CA 15-3. ref SDS 16 AS6M
840423 - ..
840424 - [On 070123 Millie went to Kaiser to get blood tests needed
840425 - to start treatment at UCSF. ref SDS 17 AS6M
840427 - ..
840428 - [On 070122 additional blood testing ordered by Kaiser
840429 - primary care physician. ref SDS 16 LX6V
840431 - ..
840432 - [On 070123 Millie went to Kaiser to get blood tests needed
840433 - to start treatment at UCSF. ref SDS 17 AS6M
840435 - ..
840436 - [On 070123 treatment delayed at UCSF need referral
840437 - authorization for payment from Kaiser. ref SDS 17 J43I
840439 - ..
840440 - [On 070130 Millie scheduled for treatment at UCSF on
840441 - 070201. ref SDS 21 MP4H
840443 - ..
840444 - We reviewed patient history showing that often blood test reports are
840445 - printed by Kaiser in multiple pages with different log identification
840446 - numbers, even though everything can be fit on a single page.
840447 - Sometimes multiple logs are printed on the same page, and pages get
840448 - separated by multiple handling. There is no evident pattern. Most
840449 - likely, 1 or 2 pages are missing from the documents transmitted to
840450 - UCSF via FAX this morning.
840452 - ..
840453 - Jackie explained this happens a lot at UCSF using FAX to send test
840454 - reports, because machines breakdown, run out of paper, transmissions
840455 - are fuzzy and have to be done over, papers get separated because the
840456 - bin fills up and spills on the floor. Nobody notices the problem.
840457 - People make mistakes collating documents into the correct order.
840458 - Multiple handling by multiple people gets the documents mixed up and
840459 - separated. Many problems occur, when people have a hectic schedule.
840460 - Hurrying to catch up at the last minute causes more mistakes. Growing
840461 - medical mistakes was reported nationally on 990912. ref SDS 1 QP3N
840463 - ..
840464 - Jackie will contact Arlette at Kaiser to request submission of the
840465 - complete blood test report.
840466 -
840467 -
840469 - ..
8405 -
8406 -
8407 - 1348
8408 -
840801 - Notify Arlette about Submitting Blood Test Lab Report to UCSF
840802 -
840803 - Follow up ref SDS 14 PK6M.
840804 -
840805 - Millie submitted ref DIT 1 0001 to Arlette at Kaiser and with a copy
840806 - to Jackie at UCSF, confirming understandings and requesting notice if
840807 - another blood test is needed to meet UCSF requirements, per above.
840808 - ref SDS 0 AS6M
840810 - ..
840811 - Millie's letter to Kaiser says...
840812 -
840813 - 1. I met with Jackie this morning on starting treatments at UCSF.
840814 - ref SDS 0 1G3K, ref DIT 1 0001
840816 - ..
840817 - 2. She said you were terrific providing documentation and working
840818 - through Kaiser's systems to facilitate my case setup at UCSF.
840819 - ref SDS 0 YF8U, ref DIT 1 HH5L
840821 - ..
840822 - 3. Jackie asked about the scope of blood work received from Kaiser
840823 - this morning. She said a "liver panel" was missing, and
840824 - possibly something else. [My doctor] prescribes the scope of
840825 - lab work. ref SDS 0 AS6M I am pretty sure he ordered
840826 - everything required by UCSF, since it is seems to be same that
840827 - I always get. ref DIT 1 LH6F
840829 - ..
840830 - 4. My treatment has been deferred a few days to give [my doctor]
840831 - and Doctor Rugo time to arrange authorizations, ref SDS 0 AS96,
840832 - discussed initially on 070101, and again on 070105. ref SDS 0
840833 - AS4K Jackie asked me to check on getting the complete lab
840834 - submitted. Typically, I get these from the doctor via email or
840835 - from the nurses in the Chemotherapy clinic on the day of
840836 - treatment. There are usually several pages. Jackie only
840837 - seemed to have a single page in the documents she showed me
840838 - this morning, so I suspect that the complete lab was performed,
840839 - and presented in multiple pages. ref DIT 1 TH6M
840841 - ..
840842 - 5. Please coordinate with Jackie on what she needs (415 353 7857
840843 - page 415 443 2057). ref DIT 1 HI7M
840845 - ..
840846 - 6. Let me know if I have to get more blood work done in time for
840847 - treatment now scheduled for either Tuesday or Wednesday of next
840848 - week. I am off work today, and so can run over to Martinez if
840849 - needed. ref DIT 1 KI8G
840851 - ..
840852 - 7. Please further send me a copy of the lab report. I expect by
840853 - now the CA 15-3 is available. It has been on a roller coaster
840854 - lately, so I am anxious about rates of change with respect to
840855 - urgency starting treatment. ref DIT 1 AJ8L
840856 -
840857 - [On 070122 Kaiser ordered additional blood tests,
840858 - ref SDS 16 AS6M; still need report from Kaiser on test
840859 - results, including CA 15-3. ref SDS 16 Z73H
840861 - ..
840862 - [On 070123 Millie went to Kaiser to get blood tests needed
840863 - to start treatment at UCSF. ref SDS 17 AS6M
840865 - ..
840866 - [On 070130 Millie scheduled for treatment at UCSF on
840867 - 070201. ref SDS 21 MP4H
840869 - ..
840870 - 8. By copy I am pleased to thank you and Jackie for expediting
840871 - these matters. ref DIT 1 KJ9G
840872 -
840873 -
840874 -
840875 -
840876 -
840877 -
840878 -
8409 -