THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: September 22, 2006 08:53 AM Friday;
Rod Welch
Millie notifies doctor of changes in status IBC, lymphedema, BP.
1...Summary/Objective
2...CA 15-3 68 Improvement Rate Seems Less than Previously Using Xeloda
3...Response to Treatment Case Study Indicates Possible Effectiveness
4...Treatment Effectiveness Compares Favorably with Recovery in 2005
5...IBC Rash Improving Below Incision Line Other Rash Improving Slowly
6...Fall Slipped Exiting BART Train Sprained Finger No Evident Effects
7...Treatment Mistake Xeloda Taken Twice 1 Hour Apart No Evident Effects
8...Lymphedema Rises Left Arm Possibly Due to Fall or Treament Error
9...Blood Pressure Falls Dangerously Low Possibly Due to Treatment Error
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
SUBJECTS
CA 15-3 68 Down from 73 IBC Rash Slow Improvement Patient Fell Sprai
0603 -
0603 - ..
0604 - Summary/Objective
0605 -
060501 - Follow up ref SDS 19 0000, ref SDS 18 0000.
060502 -
060503 - Millie notified Kaiser about a number of issues that have occurred
060504 - since meeting with the doctor last month. The most serious is evident
060505 - slow recovery. ref SDS 0 0D4T However, review indicates recovery may
060506 - be better than last year. ref SDS 0 9F35 Low blood pressure seems
060507 - fairly serious, ref SDS 0 0D6V, and may relate to mistake doubling
060508 - treatments Tuesday evening. ref SDS 0 0D5R
060509 -
060510 -
060511 -
060513 - ..
0606 -
0607 -
0608 - Progress
0609 -
060901 - CA 15-3 68 Improvement Rate Seems Less than Previously Using Xeloda
060902 -
060903 - Submitted ref DIT 1 0001 to the primary care physician on recent
060904 - events that may impact decisions on treatment and care.
060905 -
060906 - 1. Thanks for the report CA 15-3 has dropped again to 68, shown in
060907 - your letter on Sep 17. Seems like the rate of decline has
060908 - slowed compared to last year. ref DIT 1 0001
060910 - ..
060911 - Slow recovery was discussed in the record meeting with the doctor on
060912 - 060825 in relation to expectations following mastectomy surgery that
060913 - removed blood vessels that normally deliver treatment and nutrients to
060914 - infectecd tissue, ref SDS 18 G57I, reviewed in analysis below.
060915 - ref SDS 0 KG6H
060917 - ..
060918 - This test was at the end of the 2nd cycle, and beginning the 3rd cycle
060919 - of chemotherapy treatment on 060908. ref SDS 19 407N
060921 - ..
060922 - Rate of recovery from IBC rash presented in the letter to the doctor
060923 - today, is reviewed further below. ref SDS 0 UX8M
060924 -
060925 -
060926 -
060927 -
060928 -
0610 -
SUBJECTS
IBC Rash Improvement Below Incision Line Less Improvement Sternum an
1903 -
190401 - ..
190402 - Response to Treatment Case Study Indicates Possible Effectiveness
190403 - Treatment Effectiveness Compares Favorably with Recovery in 2005
190404 - IBC Rash Improving Below Incision Line Other Rash Improving Slowly
190405 -
190406 - Follow up ref SDS 19 407N, ref SDS 18 025H.
190407 -
190408 - Millie's letter to Kaiser continues...
190410 - ..
190411 - 2. The rash on my chest has improved, especially below the
190412 - surgical incision line. ref DIT 1 0X5N
190414 - ..
190415 - The rash remains prominent though with possibly reduced intensity at
190416 - the sternum and along the area above the surgery line, reported on
190417 - 060825. ref SDS 18 FQ9N Together with slow rate of decline in CA 15-3
190418 - reported above, ref SDS 0 MG6F, the slow rate of recovery from IBC red
190419 - rash, raises concern about effectiveness of treatment.
190420 -
190421 - [On 061020 cancer marker CA 15-3 rise with stable to worse
190422 - IBC rash may indicate pockets of resistance to chemotherapy
190423 - due to removing blood vessels with mastectomy surgery; or
190424 - effectivenss of current treatment with Taxotere and
190425 - capecitabine (Xeloda) may have begun to decline.
190426 - ref SDS 25 725L
190428 - ..
190429 - Response to treatment was reviewed in the record on meeting with the
190430 - doctor on 060825. ref SDS 18 YF5J Study of patient history raises
190431 - further question about effectiveness of treatment...
190432 -
190433 - 1. Treatment begins Taxotere and
190434 - capecitabine (Xeloda) 2 pills
190435 - 500 MG twice a day, after 4
190436 - cycles AC beginning on
190437 - 050105........................... 050415, ref SDS 2 407N
190439 - ..
190440 - 2. CA 15-3 105...................... 050422, ref SDS 3 GJ5M
190442 - ..
190443 - 3. IBC rash big improvement after
190444 - 2 cycles Taxoter and capecitatine
190445 - (Xeloda)......................... 050520, ref SDS 5 0001
190447 - ..
190448 - Reduce dose to 1.5 pills twice
190449 - per day to reduce side
190450 - effects.......................... 050520, ref SDS 5 V43H
190452 - ..
190453 - CA 15-3 67 fall from
190454 - 105.............................. 050520, ref SDS 5 GJ5M
190456 - ..
190457 - 4. Breast IBC rash almost gone skin
190458 - near normal color and softness
190459 - after 3 treatments............... 050610, ref SDS 7 025H
190461 - ..
190462 - CA 15-3 56 fall from
190463 - 67............................... 050610, ref SDS 7 087J
190465 - ..
190466 - Previously, from 050415 to 050610 after 3 cycles to treat the 2nd IBC
190467 - relapse, the red rash, which was spreading on the entire breast and
190468 - toward the neck on 050415, was nearly fulled healed, and CA 15-3 had
190469 - dropped from 105 to 56, about 50 points by 050610. ref SDS 0 GG6H
190471 - ..
190472 - During comparable period, beginning on 060721, ref SDS 14 0001, after
190473 - 3 cycles to treat the 3rd IBC relapse, today the red rash remains
190474 - evident, with only partial recovery of a much smaller area of skin,
190475 - ref SDS 0 0D4T, and CA 15-3 has dropped from 87 to 68, ref SDS 0 MG6F,
190476 - about 19 points. This record presents a substantial difference in
190477 - response to the same treatment in the same amounts and for a nominally
190478 - less severe condition.
190480 - ..
190481 - Is treatment less effective this year than in 2005; is it time to
190482 - consider changing treatments again?
190484 - ..
190485 - Several factors may account for slower recovery this year compared to
190486 - last year...
190487 -
190488 - 1. Last year, in 2005, Millie was treated with 4 cycles of AC
190489 - before starting treatment with Taxotere and capecitabine
190490 - (Xeloda). ref SDS 0 GG6H Even though there was no evident
190491 - recovery with AC, and symptoms increased (case study on
190492 - 050812 and citing patient history on 050329, ref SDS 8
190493 - SK7K), benefits of AC treatment may have been delayed, and
190494 - so substantial recovery after starting Taxotere and
190495 - capecitabine (Xelda), may have been partially due to the
190496 - prior treatment.
190498 - ..
190499 - This year, in 2006, Millie had received no treatment for
190500 - about 9 months, because there were no symptoms of disease,
190501 - with the last treatment on 050916, ref SDS 9 0001, before
190502 - starting treatment for recurrence on 060721. ref SDS 14
190503 - 0001
190505 - ..
190506 - 2. Treatment in 2005 with Taxotere and capecitabine (Xeloda)
190507 - started on 050415 with 2 cycles of high dose strategy;
190508 - Millie took 2 pills twice a day, ref SDS 0 GG6H, until this
190509 - was reduced on 050520 to 1.5 pills twice a day to reduce
190510 - side effects. ref SDS 0 SJ9W
190512 - ..
190513 - Treatment this year in 2006 started without the high dose
190514 - strategy, as shown in the meeting on 060711. ref SDS 13
190515 - PF3O
190517 - ..
190518 - 3. Treatment in 2005 beginning on 050415 was delivered by the
190519 - full complement of blood vessels and capillaries in a
190520 - normal breast. On 0510021 Kaiser performed a very wide
190521 - mastectomy surgery. Doctor Bailey had earlier advised on
190522 - 051011 that this surgery removes blood vessels needed to
190523 - deliver treatment to infected skin tissues. ref SDS 12 G65S
190524 - Doctor Smith in Kaiser's Surgery Department made a similar
190525 - point during a meeting on 050928, ref SDS 10 248I, which
190526 - was reviewed with the primary care physician on 051007.
190527 - ref SDS 11 KO49 Review on 060711 shows replacement breast
190528 - surgery was deferred by Kaiser, which means there may be
190529 - pockets of resistance to treatment, ref SDS 13 X54L, under
190530 - reasoning by Doctors Smith and Bailey, as further set out
190531 - in scenario #2 developed on 060808. ref SDS 15 J458
190532 -
190533 - [On 061020 cancer marker CA 15-3 rise with stable to
190534 - worse IBC rash may indicate pockets of resistance to
190535 - chemotherapy due to removing blood vessels with
190536 - mastectomy surgery; or effectivenss of current treatment
190537 - with Taxotere and capecitabine (Xeloda) may have begun
190538 - to decline. ref SDS 25 725L
190540 - ..
190541 - Slow recovery is cited in the letter to the doctor today,
190542 - per above, ref SDS 0 MG6F, was discussed in the record
190543 - meeting with the doctor on 060825 in relation to
190544 - expectations following mastectomy surgery that removed
190545 - blood vessels that normally delivery treatment and
190546 - nutrients to infectec tissue. ref SDS 18 G57I This has
190547 - been a pending issue for 2nd opinion review by UCSF, noted
190548 - on 060821. ref SDS 17 NN3H
190549 -
190550 - [On 061027 Millie asks about slow recovery from IBC
190551 - caused by mastectomy surgery removing blood vessels
190552 - needed to deliver treatment. ref SDS 26 MS3Y
190554 - ..
190555 - [On 061110 doctor reports IBC rash on left breast area
190556 - is "stable," ref SDS 28 ZL5W, indicating recovery is
190557 - very slow, because on 051021 blood vessels were removed
190558 - from the treatment area by mastectomy surgery, per
190559 - analysis of expectations on 050929. ref SDS 22 EH3F
190561 - ..
190562 - 4. Treatment in 2005 with AC was irregular, possibly causing
190563 - delayed response. After switching to Taxotere and Xeloda,
190564 - treatments were all given on schedule. Every 3 weeks
190565 - Kaiser treated the patient maintaining a steady level of
190566 - chemotherapy agent...
190567 - Days
190568 - 1st treatment.......... 050415, ref SDS 2 0001
190569 - 2nd treatment.......... 050506, ref SDS 4 0001 21
190570 - 3rd treatment.......... 050527, ref SDS 6 0001 21
190572 - ..
190573 - Treatment in 2006 so far has been delayed causing irregular
190574 - and diluted levels of chemotherapy drugs, as occurred with
190575 - AC in 2005, and shown as follows...
190576 - Days
190577 - 1st treatment.......... 060721, ref SDS 14 0001
190578 - 2nd treatment.......... 060814, ref SDS 16 0001 24
190579 - 3rd treatment.......... 060908, ref SDS 19 0001 25
190580 -
190581 - [...see below patient error taking 2 treatments
190582 - together, also, changes concentration of
190583 - chemotherapy drugs. ref SDS 0 024I
190585 - ..
190586 - Even though the rate of recovery seems less today than occurred in
190587 - 2005 for a comparable amount of treatment, ref SDS 0 LE48, Millie may
190588 - actually be doing as well or better. There is nothing in the record
190589 - to assess the impact of having received in 2005 4 cycles of AC, and
190590 - that treatment for first 2 cycles of Taxotere and capecitabine
190591 - (Xeloda) were 33% higher dose than given this year in 2006.
190592 - ref SDS 0 9E91 Irregular and delayed treatments in 2006, ref SDS 0
190593 - 5F5L, further diluted the amount of chemotherapy agent fighting
190594 - disease compared to treatment in 2005. Roughly, after the 3rd cycle
190595 - of Taxotere and capecitabine in 2005 that showed substantial recovery
190596 - from IBC, the patient had received 2 - 3 times more chemotherapy drug
190597 - than has been given at this stage in the current treatment regimin.
190599 - ..
190600 - After 3 cycles of treatment this year there is actually better
190601 - response than after 4 cycles of AC in 2005, when disease got much
190602 - worse, before starting to get better after 2 cycles of Taxotere and
190603 - capecitabine (Xeloda).
190605 - ..
190606 - Since IBC does not seem to be spreading, and there has been some
190607 - subsidence, continuing the current treatment and returning to regular
190608 - cycles seems supported by the record.
190609 -
190610 -
190611 -
190612 -
190613 -
1907 -
SUBJECTS
Fall Slipped Exiting BART Train Sprained Finger No Evident Effects L
2303 -
230401 - ..
230402 - Fall Slipped Exiting BART Train Sprained Finger No Evident Effects
230403 -
230404 -
230405 - Millie's letter to Kaiser continues...
230406 -
230407 - 3. About a week ago I fell getting off the BART train, and seem to
230408 - have sprained a finger catching myself. ref DIT 1 DX6H
230410 - ..
230411 - This occurred on Thursday, 060914, ref SDS 20 ZQ5I, about a week
230412 - after starting the 11th cycle of Taxotere and capecitabine (Xeloda)
230413 - treatment on 060908. ref SDS 19 0001
230414 -
230415 - [...see below lymphedema symptoms rise. ref SDS 0 034F
230416 -
230417 - [On 061016 finger healed very slowly; Millie went to
230418 - Kaiser for treatment; xrays showed her finger is
230419 - broken, and ligaments are torn. ref SDS 23 IP5I
230421 - ..
230422 - [On 061019 orthopedic doctor removed the cast, and
230423 - prescribed continued exercise to maintain range of motion;
230424 - prognosis is long slow healing process. ref SDS 24 087I
230425 -
230426 -
230427 -
230428 -
2305 -
SUBJECTS
Treatment Mistake Capecitabine Xeloda Chemotherapy Pills Taken Twice
2503 -
250401 - ..
250402 - Treatment Mistake Xeloda Taken Twice 1 Hour Apart No Evident Effects
250403 -
250404 -
250405 - Millie's letter to Kaiser continues...
250406 -
250407 - 4. This past Tuesday, I goofed and took two treatments of Xeloda
250408 - about an hour apart, so that would be 3 total pills of 500 MG.
250409 - The next morning, did not take pills. There were no noticable
250410 - side effects from this error, so just letting you know.
250411 - ref DIT 1 LX6L
250413 - ..
250414 - This is another factor that changes the concentration of treatment
250415 - that may impact the rate of recovery and effectiveness, per above.
250416 - ref SDS 0 GA4U
250417 -
250418 - [On 060929 pharmacist reviews prespription for capecitabine
250419 - (Xeloda), Kaiser's quality control to support the patient.
250420 - ref SDS 21 WK95
250421 -
250422 -
250423 -
250424 -
250425 -
2505 -
SUBJECTS
Lymphedema Rises Left Arm 1" Bigger Possibly Due to Fall or Cancer T
3003 -
300401 - ..
300402 - Lymphedema Rises Left Arm Possibly Due to Fall or Treament Error
300403 -
300404 -
300405 - Millie's letter to Kaiser continues...
300406 -
300407 - 5. Lymphadema on my left arm has suddenly increased. My foremam
300408 - and left hand are now noticably swollen. An indication is the
300409 - change in forearm which is about 1" bigger now than it has been
300410 - for a few months. Possibly this is a reaction to the fall, or
300411 - the extra pills. ref DIT 1 DY7I
300413 - ..
300414 - Seems like the fall Millie had the other day, per above, ref SDS 0
300415 - 0D4X, could have induced trauma that caused lymphedema to rise.
300417 - ..
300418 - The doctor responded in a letter saying that trauma to the left arm
300419 - from injuring her finger in the fall is an event that can trigger
300420 - complications of lymphedema, causing increased swelling.
300421 -
300422 - [On 061016 Millie had her finger examined at Kaiser to
300423 - assess slow healing from fall on 060914; xrays showed the
300424 - finger is broken, requiring a cast for a week to facilitate
300425 - healing. ref SDS 23 IP5I
300427 - ..
300428 - [On 061027 Millie hospitalized temperature 102.6,
300429 - ref SDS 27 HP52, major, severe red rash envelops left arm
300430 - and shoulder; diagnosis cellulitus complications of
300431 - lymphedema, reaction to tramua from fall and breaking
300432 - finger on 060914. ref SDS 27 V759
300433 -
300434 -
300435 -
300436 -
300437 -
300438 -
300439 -
3005 -
SUBJECTS
Vitals Blood Pressure 94 57 Falls Dangerously Low Possibly Due to Tr
3403 -
340401 - ..
340402 - Blood Pressure Falls Dangerously Low Possibly Due to Treatment Error
340403 -
340404 -
340405 - Millie's letter to Kaiser continues...
340406 -
340407 - 6. My blood pressure dropped yesterday to 94 57. It seems back to
340408 - normal today. ref DIT 1 ZY8F
340410 - ..
340411 - 7. Just a heads up for our meeting next week. ref DIT 1 UY8J
340412 -
340413 -
340414 -
340415 -
340416 -
340417 -
340418 -
340419 -
340420 -
340421 -
340422 -
3405 -