THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: April 28, 2003 09:54 AM Monday;
Rod Welch
Summons served on an action in SF superior court re GGC matter.
1...Summary/Objective
2...Statement of Complaint for Eviction Action by GGC
3...Limited Civil Jurisdiction Research on Court Procedures
4...Defenses Against Eviction Action
.....It is possible, but rare, for a losing tenant to convince the
5...Form of Response to Complaint for Unlawful Detainer
6......does this mean a similar format can be filed in the GGC case?
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
0201 - Golden Gatweay Center
020101 - Mr. Clay Tominaga; Manager
020102 - Tennant Administrattion, 440 Davis Court
SUBJECTS
Notice of Rent Default
Planning to Recover Account to Good Standing
Summons Case CUD-03-606080 Superior Court State of California San Fra
Welch cross complaint
0606 -
0606 - ..
0607 - Summary/Objective
0608 -
060801 - Follow up ref SDS 9 0000. ref SDS 8 0000.
060802 -
060803 - Received ref DRT 1 0001 from....
060804 -
060805 - Superior Court - State of California
060806 - 400 McAllister Street, Room 102
060807 - San Francisco, California 94102
060808 - Limited Civil Jurisdiction
060809 - County of San Francisco
060811 - ..
060812 - http://sfgov.org/site/courts_index.asp
060814 - ..
060815 - Response is due within five days from date of service. ref DRT 1 H36J
060816 -
060817 - [On 030502 EDC calculates that Monday, 020505, is the deadline
060818 - for default judgement. ref SDS 11 OA4O
060820 - ..
060821 - GGC's grounds for this action are in the complaint beginning at para
060822 - 4. ref SDS 0 XN4M
060824 - ..
060825 - Research on the Internet located the forms, ref SDS 0 6N5I, required
060826 - for filing, an answer to GGC's complaint, ref SDS 0 EH5V
060828 - ..
060829 - Prepared a defense, ref OF 3 0001, using similar format in the Belli
060830 - case that occurred in 1991. ref SDS 0 6N5I Had to restore code that
060831 - supports pleading paper.
060832 -
060833 - [On 030501 configured tools for legal briefs. ref SDS 10 0001
060835 - ..
060836 - Defense must state a dispute of fact or law. Could defend on grounds
060837 - that 3-day notice is defective, ref SDS 0 DF5H, and that GGC breached
060838 - contract by failing to perform required maintenance. ref OF 3 SS5J
060840 - ..
060841 - Having stated grounds for defense, present context that might lead the
060842 - court to encourage settelement that extends the period a few more
060843 - months to generate a revenue steam for maintaining residence.
060844 - ref OF 3 PS9H
060846 - ..
060847 - Called the Rent Stabalization & Arbitration Board at....
060848 -
060849 -
060850 - 415 554 9550
060851 -
060852 - ....which is listed in the 3-day notice to pay rent, dated 030415,
060853 - ref DRP 1 0F9O, received in the record on 030417, ref SDS 6 0001, and
060854 - represented by GGC in the 3-day notice as providing guidance for
060855 - seeking available protections.
060857 - ..
060858 - Got a message saying this number is no longer in service.
060860 - ..
060861 - Research indicates that failure to provide accurate information in
060862 - a 3-day notice, may be a substantial error that justifies vacating
060863 - the notice, since it denies to the defendant remedies which the
060864 - requirements are intended to grant to a tennant. ref SDS 0 EH5V
060866 - ..
060867 - Included this defense in the Answer. ref OF 3 LV8L
060868 -
060869 -
060871 - ..
060872 - Statement of Complaint for Eviction Action by GGC
060873 -
060874 - Plaintiff's counsel shown at top of pleadings. ref DRT 2 0000
060875 -
060876 - THOMAS P. WRIGHT JR., ESQ.
060877 - Law Offices of Thomas P. Wright Jr.
060878 - Post Office Box 2595
060879 - Redwood City, California 94064
060880 - Telephone: (550) 366-7447
060881 - State Bar #063245
060882 -
060884 - ..
060885 - Case number: CUD-03-606080, ref DRT 2 GK5F
060886 -
060887 - Complaint......
060888 -
060889 - COMPLAINT FOR
060890 - UNLAWFUL DETAINER
060892 - ..
060893 - DEMAND: $2,229.80
060894 - [California Rules of Court 501(e)(8)]
060896 - ..
060897 - Plaintiff: GOLDEN GATEWAY CENTER,
060899 - ..
060900 - Statement of complaint. ref DRT 2 NM6J
060901 -
060902 - 1. Plaintiff identifed GGC is a limited partnership.
060903 -
060904 - 2. Defendant sued under provisions CCP 1174.25 and 474.
060905 - ref DRT 2 TM7H
060907 - ..
060908 - 3. Plaintiff owns property at 440 Davis Court #1602 SF CA 94111,
060909 - ref DRT 2 137E
060911 - ..
060912 - 4. Defendant has had possession since 770926, 26 years.
060913 - ref DRT 2 1386
060915 - ..
060916 - 5. On 030415 plaintiff served notice requiring defendant to pay
060917 - rent or quit the premises, exhibit A. ref DRT 2 1T9N
060919 - ..
060920 - Exhibit is plaintiff's letter on 030415. ref DRP 1 0001
060922 - ..
060923 - 6. That defendant failed to comply with the requirements of the
060924 - notice within the time allowed by the notice and applicable
060925 - statutory law. Defendant continues in possession of the
060926 - premises without plaintiff's permission and plaintiff is
060927 - entitled to recover possession of the premises. ref DRT 2 FX4J
060929 - ..
060930 - 7. The premises are subject to the provisions of the San Francisco
060931 - Residential Rent Stabilization and Arbitration Ordinance passed
060932 - June 17, 1979, and as subsequently amended, and plaintiff has
060933 - complied with all of the provisions. ref DRT 2 KY5H
060935 - ..
060936 - 8. The reasonable rental value of said premises is $37.16 per day.
060937 - ref DRT 2 WY5N
060939 - ..
060940 - 9. The written rental agreement provides for an award of
060941 - reasonable attorney's fees in the event of litigation.
060942 - Plaintiff is entitled to recover reasonable attorney's fees.
060943 - ref DRT 2 6Z6F
060945 - ..
060946 - Prayer for relief....
060947 -
060948 - 1. For restitution and possession of the premises, and forfeiture
060949 - of the lease;
060950 -
060951 - 2. For rent in the amount of $2,229.80;
060953 - ..
060954 - 3. For damages at the rate of $37.16 from May 1, 2003, until the
060955 - date of entry of judgement.
060957 - ..
060958 - 4. For reasonable attorneys fees.
060960 - ..
060961 - 5. For costs of suit herein incurred; and
060963 - ..
060964 - 6. For such other and further relief as the Court deems proper.
060965 -
060967 - ..
060968 - Complaint is verified by Clay Tominaga. ref DRT 3 0001
060969 -
060970 -
060972 - ..
060973 - Limited Civil Jurisdiction Research on Court Procedures
060974 -
060975 - Responding to the complaint requires knowledge of procedures.
060976 - Research on the Internet located information for the Superior Court in
060977 - San Francisco.
060978 -
060979 - http://sfgov.org/site/uploadedfiles/courts/
060981 - ..
060982 - Got a PDF file with list of numbers for SF Superior Court.
060983 -
060984 - http://sfgov.org/site/uploadedfiles/courts/sftc-staff-pub.pdf
060986 - ..
060987 - Got suggestion to call Dennis Brady.....
060988 -
060989 - 415 551 4030
060991 - ..
060992 - Called and left message for Dennis.
060994 - ..
060995 - Called another listing for this jurisdiction....
060996 -
060997 - 415 551 4027
060999 - ..
061000 - Clerk advised that an "Answer" needs to be filed and forms can be
061001 - obtained from
061002 -
061003 - http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov
061005 - ..
061006 - An online service is at...
061007 -
061008 - http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/selfhelp
061009 -
061010 - [...below, seem to have found the correct form. ref SDS 0 UO5M
061012 - ..
061013 - Another source is at.....
061014 -
061015 - http://www.tenantsunion.org/directory/california.html
061017 - ..
061018 - The clerk at the court further suggested calling....
061019 -
061020 - Eviction Defense Collaborative
061021 - 433 South Van Ness
061022 - Between 15th - 16th streets near BART station
061023 -
061024 - 415 431 8831
061025 -
061026 - ...for assistance filing an answer to an evision notice.
061027 - Costs $35.
061028 -
061029 - http://www.hrcsf.org/tenant_info/evictions/evic_4cour.html
061031 - ..
061032 - Hours: 1000 - 1200 and 1300 - 1500
061034 - ..
061035 - Other numbers to call...
061036 -
061037 - 415 282 6622
061038 - 415 703 8644
061039 - 415 407 9203
061040 - 415 982 1300
061041 - 415 252 4600
061042 -
061043 -
061044 -
061046 - ..
061047 - Defenses Against Eviction Action
061048 -
061049 - Research on responding to the summons today, showed at....
061050 -
061051 - http://www.hrcsf.org/tenant_info/evictions/evic_3evic.html
061052 -
061053 - ..., says in part that....
061055 - ..
061056 - In units covered by the Rent Ordinance, this notice must state
061057 - both the grounds for eviction, and that advice is available
061058 - from the Rent Stabilization and Arbitration Board. An improper
061059 - notice can be used to defeat an eviction, but only if the
061060 - tenant responds to the notice. The legal process of eviction
061061 - begins with either a three-day or a thirty- or sixty-day notice
061062 - from the landlord.
061064 - ..
061065 - The notice must state the correct amount of rent owed, and your
061066 - landlord must accept the rent if you attempt to pay it.
061067 -
061068 -
061070 - ..
061071 - Housing Rights Committee of San Francisco
061072 -
061073 - Provides tenant counseling, organizing assistance, and
061074 - legislative advocacy. Address:
061075 -
061076 - 427 Van Ness Ave
061077 - San Francisco, CA 94102-4510
061078 - Phone: (415) 703-8644
061079 - http://www.hrcsf.org/
061080 - Email: info@hrcsf.org
061081 -
061083 - ..
061084 - HRC Internet information at....
061085 -
061086 - http://www.hrcsf.org/tenant_info/evictions/evic_4cour.html
061087 -
061088 - ...says in part....
061090 - ..
061091 - 1. When the Unlawful Detainer, or Summons and Complaint is served
061092 - to you, you have five (5) days (including the weekend but not
061093 - including court holidays) to file a response. To file your
061094 - response you should get legal assistance (go to the Eviction
061095 - Defense Collaborative, 433 South Van Ness/15th, 10am-12noon
061096 - and 1-3pm). If a response is not filed on time, your landlord
061097 - may obtain a default judgment, which moves the process along
061098 - more quickly.
061100 - ..
061101 - 2. After you respond, the Court will set the case for settlement
061102 - conference, at which time you and your landlord can present
061103 - your arguments and possibly come to an agreement. You do NOT
061104 - have to agree to a settlement at this conference--if you do
061105 - not, the case will go to jury trial.
061107 - ..
061108 - 3. Only after your landlord wins at trial can the court order you
061109 - to vacate the unit.
061110 -
061111 -
061113 - ..
061114 - California Department of Consumer Affairs has information on
061115 - procedures....
061116 -
061117 - http://www.dca.ca.gov/legal/landlordbook/
061119 - ..
061120 - Procedures related to eviction are at....
061121 -
061122 - http://www.dca.ca.gov/legal/landlordbook/evictions.htm
061124 - ..
061125 - An unlawful detainer lawsuit is a "summary" court procedure. This
061126 - means that the court action moves forward very quickly, and that
061127 - the time given the tenant to respond during the lawsuit is very
061128 - short. For example, in most cases, the tenant has only five days
061129 - to file a written response to the lawsuit after being served with
061130 - a copy of the landlord's complaint.171 Code of Civil Procedure
061131 - Section 1167.3. Normally, a judge will hear and decide the case
061132 - within 20 days after the tenant files an answer.172 Code of Civil
061133 - Procedure Section 1170.5(a).
061135 - ..
061136 - The court-administered eviction process assures the tenant of the
061137 - right to a court hearing if the tenant believes that the landlord
061138 - has no right to evict the tenant. The landlord must use this court
061139 - process to evict the tenant; the landlord cannot use self-help
061140 - measures to force the tenant to move. For example, the landlord
061141 - cannot physically remove or lock out the tenant, cut off utilities
061142 - such as water or electricity, remove outside windows or doors, or
061143 - seize (take) the tenant's belongings in order to carry out the
061144 - eviction. The landlord must use the court procedures.
061146 - ..
061147 - In an unlawful detainer lawsuit, the court holds a hearing at
061148 - which the parties can present their evidence and explain their
061149 - case. If the court finds that the tenant has a good defense, the
061150 - court will not evict the tenant. If the court decides in favor of
061151 - the tenant, the tenant will not have to move, and the landlord may
061152 - be ordered to pay court costs (for example, the tenant's filing
061153 - fees). The landlord also may have to pay the tenant's attorney's
061154 - fees, if the rental agreement or lease contains an attorney's fee
061155 - provision and the tenant was represented by an attorney.174
061157 - ..
061158 - If the court decides in favor of the landlord, the court will
061159 - issue a writ of possession. The writ of possession orders the
061160 - sheriff to remove the tenant from the rental unit, but gives the
061161 - tenant five days from the date that the writ is served to leave
061162 - voluntarily. If the tenant does not leave by the end of the
061163 - five-day period, the writ of possession authorizes the sheriff to
061164 - physically remove and lock the tenant out, and seize (take) the
061165 - tenant's belongings that have been left in the rental unit. The
061166 - landlord is not entitled to possession of the rental unit until
061167 - after the sheriff has removed the tenant.
061169 - ..
061170 - The court also may award the landlord any unpaid rent if the
061171 - eviction is based on the tenant's failure to pay rent. The court
061172 - also may award the landlord damages, court costs, and attorney's
061173 - fees (if the rental agreement or lease contains an attorney's fee
061174 - provision). If the court finds that the tenant acted maliciously
061175 - in not giving up the rental unit, the court also may award the
061176 - landlord up to $600 as a penalty.175 The judgment against the
061177 - tenant will be reported on the tenant's credit report for seven
061178 - years.176
061180 - ..
061181 - You usually have only five days to respond in writing to the
061182 - landlord's complaint. You must respond during this time by filing
061183 - the correct legal document with the Clerk of the court in which
061184 - the lawsuit was filed. If the fifth day falls on a weekend or
061185 - holiday, you can file your written response on the following
061186 - Monday or nonholiday.177
061188 - ..
061189 - Typically, a tenant responds to a landlord's complaint by filing a
061190 - written "answer." (You can get a copy of a form to use for filing
061191 - an answer from the Clerk of Court's office.)
061192 -
061193 - Need form from Clerk of Court's office.
061194 -
061195 - Got this from the Internet, per above. ref SDS 0 UO5M
061197 - ..
061198 - Depending on the facts of your case, there are other legal
061199 - responses to the landlord's complaint that you might file instead
061200 - of an answer. For example, if you believe that your landlord did
061201 - not properly serve the summons and the complaint, you might file a
061202 - Motion to Quash Service of Summons. If you believe that the
061203 - complaint has some technical defect or does not properly allege
061204 - the landlord's right to evict you, you might file a Demurrer. It
061205 - is important that you obtain advice from a lawyer before you
061206 - attempt to use these procedures.
061208 - ..
061209 - If you don't file a written response to the landlord's complaint
061210 - by the end of the fifth day, the court will enter a default
061211 - judgment in favor of the landlord. A default judgment allows the
061212 - landlord to obtain a writ of possession (see Writ of Possession),
061213 - and may also award the landlord unpaid rent, damages and court
061214 - costs.
061216 - ..
061217 - The Clerk of Court will ask you to pay a filing fee when you file
061218 - your written response. The filing fee typically is between $35 and
061219 - $85. However, if you can't afford to pay the filing fee, you can
061220 - request that the Clerk allow you to file your response without
061221 - paying the fee (that is, you can request a waiver of the fee). An
061222 - application form for a fee waiver, called an "Application for
061223 - Waiver of Court Fees and Costs," can be obtained from the Clerk of
061224 - Court.
061226 - ..
061227 - After you have filed your written answer to the landlord's
061228 - complaint, the Clerk of Court will mail to both you and the
061229 - landlord a notice of the time and place of the trial. If you don't
061230 - appear in court, a default judgment will be entered against you
061232 - ..
061233 - It is possible, but rare, for a losing tenant to convince the
061234 - court to allow the tenant to remain in the rental unit. This is
061235 - called...
061236 -
061237 - relief from forfeiture of the tenancy
061239 - ..
061240 - The tenant must convince the court of two things in order to
061241 - obtain relief from forfeiture: that the eviction would cause the
061242 - tenant or the tenant's family severe hardship, and that the tenant
061243 - is able to pay all of the rent that is due or that the tenant will
061244 - fully comply with the lease.179
061246 - ..
061247 - A tenant cannot obtain relief from forfeiture when the term of the
061248 - tenancy has already expired (for example, in a month-to-month
061249 - tenancy).180 Any petition for relief of forfeiture should be filed
061250 - immediately after the court issues its judgment.181
061251 -
061252 -
061253 -
061255 - ..
061256 - Form of Response to Complaint for Unlawful Detainer
061257 -
061258 - Think we can use the form for the answer to Belli's suit, per below.
061259 - ref SDS 0 6N5V
061260 -
061261 - Actually, am not real sure about this. It is beginning to look
061262 - like we need to visit with EDC. ref SDS 0 KD6N
061264 - ..
061265 - Per above, ref SDS 0 HD5N, found another possible resource at....
061266 -
061267 - http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/forms.cgi
061268 -
061269 - ...that shows Court forms listed numerically...
061270 -
061271 - Answer-Unlawful Detainer, revised 1997.......... 982.1(95)
061272 -
061273 - ...which is a PDF file....
061274 -
061275 - http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/forms/documents/982195s.pdf
061277 - ..
061278 - Summons Complain for unlawful
061279 - detainer - eviction, ref DRT 1 N95J
061280 - is idenfified....................................... 982(a)(11)
061281 -
061282 - This is the same form we received, and so this indicates we
061283 - have found the right form to file a reply to the complaint.
061285 - ..
061286 - Need to convert the pdf files into Word files for preparing
061287 - filings.
061288 -
061289 - Wound up printing the thing and handwriting the answer.
061290 -
061291 - [On 030502, EDC will prepare this form online to ensure
061292 - legibility. ref SDS 11 FH6O
061294 - ..
061295 - In the case of Belli v. Welch and the counter-suit, we filed an
061296 - ordinary pleading, rather than a form....
061297 -
061298 - This is account....
061299 -
061300 - 03 00051
061302 - ..
061303 - Welch cross-complaint
061304 -
061305 - 03 00051 02
061306 -
061308 - ..
061309 - Answer was prepared on 900828. ref SDS 1 0001
061310 -
061311 - ...does this mean a similar format can be filed in the GGC case?
061312 -
061313 - Looks like we prepare affirmative defense as an attachment 3 to
061314 - the Summons. ref OF 3 0001
061315 -
061316 - [On 030502 EDC will use this to prepare a filing to answer the
061317 - complaint. ref SDS 11 WD55
061318 -
061319 -
061320 -
061321 -
061322 -
061323 -
0614 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"