THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: April 5, 2001 11:03 AM Thursday;
Rod Welch
Jack Park OHS system needs explanation of vision.
1...Summary/Objective
2...Peer Review on KM in POIMS Paper
3...SourceForge Hosting OHS Open Source Project
4...SDS Tab in Jack's OHS Program Changed to PIM
5...Grove Engine Proposed for OHS Architecture
6...OHS Improves Daily Work Using Grove Engine
.....Data modeling language.
.....Graph Representation of property Values. ref DRT 2 01DT
.....Addressability supported by Groves uniqely describes the location
7...Suggestions for consideration to improve Nexist...
....a...Define knowledge, content and context to differentiate them
....b...Whole New Way of Thinking
....c...Use OHS tools to develop and refine OHS, since that is the only
8...Project Management - Grant Bowman, Eugene and Eric Can Contribute
9...Culture of Knowledge Critical to Advancing Beyond IT
10...Pilot Testing Key C Activity to Accomplish ABC Improvement
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
SUBJECTS
Peer Review on KM in POIMS, Jack Park, Doug Engelbart, Pat Lincoln
0903 -
0903 - ..
0904 - Summary/Objective
0905 -
090501 - Follow up ref SDS 49 0000, ref SDS 45 0000.
090502 -
090503 - Jack will try to do the peer review of POIMS. He is making progress
090504 - with his OHS project that he is calling Nexist. ref SDS 0 A13H Offered
090505 - ideas for project guidance. ref SDS 0 485N Grant Bowman is providing
090506 - project management for the Nexist project; discussed getting Eugene
090507 - Kim and Eric Armstrong to help. ref SDS 0 485F There wasn't enough
090508 - time during the meeting at SRI last week to discuss ABC improvement
090509 - that requires pilot testing. Jack will try to ask about this today.
090510 - ref SDS 0 5T3O
090511 -
090512 -
090513 -
090514 -
090516 - ..
0906 -
0907 -
0908 - Progress
090901 - ..
090902 - Peer Review on KM in POIMS Paper
090903 -
090904 - Follow up ref SDS 49 SH5O.
090905 -
090906 - Jack indicated he is very near to being able to provide peer review on
090907 - KM in POIMS, ref OF 1 1850, per our telecon on 010329, ref SDS 49
090908 - SH5O, confirmed by letter. ref DIP 3 0001
090909 -
090910 - [On 010411 received peer review from Jack. ref SDS 50 0001
090912 - ..
090913 - Also, need comments on the letter to Curt, ref DIP 1 0001 linked to
090914 - the meeting on 010122. ref SDS 34 0001 Does Jack see the proposition
090915 - that KM is a research project to discover how to overcome ignorance,
090916 - fear and denial that prevents people from using KM? ref SDS 34 PZ8M
090917 - ..
090918 - This latter point gives rise to the need for pilot testing, per
090919 - below.
090920 -
090921 -
090922 -
0910 -
SUBJECTS
OHS Architecture Screens Shown on Nexist Web Site Changed SDS to PIM
Nexist OHS Project, Jack Park
Grove Engine Proposed for OHS Architecture
Catagory Topics Classification Subjects Keywords Ontology Taxonomy Or
Anchors Addressability Add to Docs, 000609
Starter Technologies DKR/OHS, 000504
Groves Engine Data Modeling Language DML Graphical Representation Kno
Graphical Maps Organize Record Subjects Catagories
Topic Maps Graphical Maps Organize Record Subjects
Engine Map Topics Subjects
Addressability Granular, Links, Eugene Kim, 000504
6013 -
601401 - ..
601402 - SourceForge Hosting OHS Open Source Project
601403 - SDS Tab in Jack's OHS Program Changed to PIM
601404 -
601405 - Follow up ref SDS 49 A13H, ref SDS 42 TZ5H.
601406 -
601407 - Received ref DRT 1 0001 from Grant Bowman explaining screen layouts
601408 - shown on the Nexist web site hosted by Sourceforge, quoting a letter
601409 - from Jack on 010403. Implementation on Sourceforge accomplishes
601410 - planning on 010322. ref SDS 46 BX6N
601411 -
601412 - http://nexist.sourceforge.net
601413 -
601414 - ....and at....
601415 -
601416 - http://www.thinkalong.com/nex/Nexist.html
601418 - ..
601419 - This shows progresss resolving design problems reported on 010325.
601420 - ref SDS 48 0001
601422 - ..
601423 - Nexist calls for implementing Doug Engelbart's ideas about knowledge
601424 - management and bootstrapping, reviewed on 991222. ref SDS 5 3696
601426 - ..
601427 - SourceForge came into the record for the meeting at SRI on 000608 when
601428 - Eugene Kim planed to set up an open source project using SourceForge.
601429 - ref SDS 16 5985 Jack indicated in our telecon that he has formulated
601430 - an open source license, which was a requirement for SourceForge cited
601431 - during the meeting at SRI on 000622. ref SDS 17 5985
601433 - ..
601434 - Examination of Jack's web site shows he changed "SDS" to "PIM," as
601435 - suggested in the record on 010329, ref SDS 49 EP4L, which was
601436 - submitted to Jack by the letter, ref DIP 3 0001, discussing peer
601437 - review of KM in POIMS, per above.
601439 - ..
601440 - PIM is the opposite of the POIMS design for SDS that implements KM and
601441 - Com Metrics. ref OF 1 0001
601443 - ..
601444 - This morning we reviewed the benefit of using SDS to learn KM in order
601445 - to guide development of OHS, per the letter, ref DIP 3 PL8G, submitted
601446 - on 010329. ref SDS 49 VN7M
601448 - ..
601449 - Jack feels this could be helpful. He wants to resolve issues about
601450 - open source prior to using SDS in order to learn how to design KM
601451 - tools.
601452 -
601454 - ..
601455 - Grove Engine Proposed for OHS Architecture
601456 - OHS Improves Daily Work Using Grove Engine
601457 -
601458 - The Nexist web site has a diagram that shows a "client," "session
601459 - manager, and a Grove engine that processes documents.
601460 -
601461 - [On 010614 analysis shows SDS organic subject structure may
601462 - support KM better than an engine, until experience is gained that
601463 - enables an engine to be designed that supports the architecture
601464 - of human thought. ref SDS 51 HY6M
601466 - ..
601467 - [On 010618 Jack submitted updated code for evaluation and
601468 - comment. ref SDS 52 BP3K
601470 - ..
601471 - Received ref DRT 2 0001 from Eugene Kim submitting an excellent paper
601472 - explaining Grove, ref DRT 2 0002, and includes detailed references.
601473 - ref DRT 2 HS5N
601474 -
601475 - [On 020822 there is another technology with a similar sounding
601476 - name, Groove," that is aimed at "collaboration" by improving
601477 - email. ref SDS 54 H08J
601479 - ..
601480 - Grove's are explained in Eugene's paper as.....
601481 -
601482 - Data modeling language.
601483 -
601484 - Data modeling language seems to identify organic structure,
601485 - ref DRT 2 00GL, which is the purpose of the subject index in
601486 - SDS. ref DRT 2 00AM
601488 - ..
601489 - Eugene says...
601490 -
601491 - Consider, for example, an employee in a company. What are the
601492 - different ways we can represent an employee? We can start by
601493 - thinking about the characteristics an employee has, things like
601494 - a name, a salary, a starting date, a boss, and so on. We can
601495 - also think about employees as people, separating the
601496 - people-specific characteristics -- name, age, gender, etc. --
601497 - from the employee-specific ones -- salary, starting data, etc.
601498 - ref DRT 2 00AM
601500 - ..
601501 - Graph Representation of property Values. ref DRT 2 01DT
601502 -
601503 - Graphical representation of knowledge provides constructs for
601504 - describing directed graphs consisting of nodes, which have
601505 - properties, and arcs connecting the nodes for modeling
601506 - structured documents. ref DRT 2 QB3N
601508 - ..
601509 - Graphically, a node and its nodal properties are connected to
601510 - each other by an arc, with the direction of the arc pointing
601511 - towards the property. ref DRT 2 01BS
601513 - ..
601514 - Addressability supported by Groves uniqely describes the location
601515 - of a chunk of data. ref DRT 2 01HT
601516 -
601517 - [On 010916 Eugene developing dialog maps for organizing the
601518 - record that uses ontology inspection agents monitored by
601519 - ontologists. ref SDS 53 8M6K
601521 - ..
601522 - Jack's letter on 010403 cited in Grant's letter received today,
601523 - per above, ref SDS 0 A13H, explains that Nexist supports Topic
601524 - Maps. ref DRT 1 0001 Since the Nexist web site provides support
601525 - with a "grove engine," also, per above, ref SDS 0 485N, and since
601526 - Eugene's report explains grove technology generates graphical
601527 - representations of knowledge data structures, ref SDS 0 C19I, this
601528 - seems to associate Grove with Topic Maps, and with goals for an
601529 - "engine" to create graphical representations of knowledge proposed
601530 - in Jack's letter on 000623. ref SDS 18 2915 Topic Maps ISO/IEO
601531 - standards were cited by Roy Roebuck on 000125 to aid Colloquium
601532 - work building a Dynamic Knowledge Repository (DKR). ref SDS 7
601533 - TU4T At that time, Topic Maps were presented for supporting
601534 - hierarchial and associational data structures to graphically
601535 - organize and navigate growing information pools based on context
601536 - determined by situational awareness. ref SDS 7 9246
601537 -
601538 - [On 010916 Eric Armstrong anticipated an "engine" might run
601539 - around and perform useful tasks "mining" information to create
601540 - knowledge. ref SDS 53 8M6K
601542 - ..
601543 - On 001130 Jack discussed an engine for ontology to support
601544 - subjects and links. ref SDS 29 CC7K
601546 - ..
601547 - On 010223 engine for mining threads proposed; question on scope
601548 - still pending. ref SDS 40 3RKS
601549 - ..
601550 - On 940603 work at Stanford planned to develop mediators to
601551 - mine information for knowledge.
601552 -
601554 - ..
601555 - There is a list showing for the Nexist Website...
601556 -
601557 - Content
601558 - Context
601559 - Knowledge
601560 -
601562 - ..
601563 - Suggestions for consideration to improve Nexist...
601564 -
601565 - a. Define knowledge, content and context to differentiate them
601566 - from information, and from each other, as recommended to the
601567 - OHS/DKR team on 000120, ref SDS 6 5063, and again on 000407.
601568 - ref SDS 11 2805
601569 -
601570 - This is related to peer review of POIMS, above. ref SDS 0 SH5O
601572 - ..
601573 - Jack said in our call today that he will do this.
601575 - ..
601576 - b. Whole New Way of Thinking
601577 -
601578 - Explain how the OHS/Nexist system will provide a whole new way
601579 - of thinking about the way we work, learn, and live together,
601580 - called out in Doug's mission for Bootstrapping, reported on
601581 - 991222, ref SDS 5 3696, and which Nexist and OHS propose to
601582 - support,
601584 - ..
601585 - Provide scenarios showing how OHS will improve daily work, like
601586 - going to the doctor, fixing the car, digging a ditch, writing a
601587 - letter, reading a book, etc, per SDS typical day scenario.
601588 - ref OF 5 0001
601590 - ..
601591 - Jack said he will do this.
601593 - ..
601594 - c. Use OHS tools to develop and refine OHS, since that is the only
601595 - practical way of knowing the tools are usable 24 7 by anyone
601596 - else.
601597 -
601598 - Jack said he plans to do this.
601600 - ..
601601 - He advised that the tools he has created so far to develop the
601602 - OHS program are on his notebook computer, and it is too
601603 - difficult to transfer them to his office desktop computer, so
601604 - this presents a problem.
601605 -
601606 - A key need for any tool set is ease of moving the human
601607 - body to where it needs to go, and having knowledge tool
601608 - support available in an efficient, ergonomic setting.
601610 - ..
601611 - We reviewed the need for an effective "knowledge" technology to
601612 - do more than support so called "collaboration" by improving
601613 - email, as called out in POIMS. ref OF 1 CZ6K and ref OF 1 K84L
601614 - OHS tools must be used for creating OHS tools, for example
601615 - shown on 990530, ref SDS 3 0001, and for everything else.
601616 -
601617 -
601618 -
601619 -
601620 -
601621 -
6017 -
SUBJECTS
Bowman, Grant Project Manager for Nexist OHS Project
Open Source Engineers Empowered to Do What They Want, If Useful Syner
Project Management Help, Bowman, Grant on Nexist OHS, Jack Park
Nexist OHS Supporting Project, Jack Park
OHS Nexist Project Meeting Planned with Jack Park
KM Tools Provided for Project Team to Try
Nexist OHS Has Received Code Eric Created for an OHS, Jack Park
OHS Difficult Too Broad, Covers Too Much Ground
7410 -
741101 - ..
741102 - Project Management - Grant Bowman, Eugene and Eric Can Contribute
741103 -
741104 - Jack advised that Grant Bowman is helping with Project Management
741105 - support. On 001012 Grant explained ideas for managing open source
741106 - projects using empowerment. ref SDS 22 PT5M Howard is, also, helping
741107 - with the project. We discussed getting Eugene Kim to support the
741108 - project. Jack indicated that Eugene has a separate OHS project,
741109 - similar to Eric Armstrong. This aligns with Eugene's letter to the
741110 - OHS/DKR team on 010131 proposing use of Eugene's tools to learn KM.
741111 - ref SDS 35 XZ8G Jack is meeting with Eugene in the next few days, so
741112 - possibly some collaboration can be forged through SourceForge.
741114 - ..
741115 - Jack indicated he has received code that Eric is developing for an
741116 - OHS. On 001017 Eric reported progress on his project. ref SDS 23 0001
741117 - On 001122 he explained challenges in formulating a design. ref SDS 27
741118 - 0001 Working Jack and Eugene could expedite Eric's work.
741119 - ..
741120 - Doug Engelbart is aware that Jack is considering implementing
741121 - Augment in the Nexist OHS.
741123 - ..
741124 - Doug is explaining Augment at SRI weekly meetings.
741125 -
741126 -
741127 -
741128 -
741129 -
741130 -
741131 -
741132 -
7412 -
SUBJECTS
Pilot Test Experiment New Methods, Who Pays
Pilot Test Helps People Try New Tools
Pilot Test Overcomes Fear Change Leadership Broader Vision Helps Peop
ABC Improvement Requires C Activity to Pilot Test Better Improvements
Culture Knowledge Transitions Foraging on Information in Garden of Ed
8607 -
860801 - ..
860802 - Culture of Knowledge Critical to Advancing Beyond IT
860803 - Pilot Testing Key C Activity to Accomplish ABC Improvement
860804 -
860805 - Follow up ref SDS 49 5T3O, ref SDS 47 ZF6J.
860806 -
860807 - Jack said there wasn't enough time during the meeting at SRI on 010329
860808 - to ask about pilot testing to support Doug's ideas about ABC
860809 - improvement to save time and money, which we discussed on 010329.
860810 - ref SDS 49 5T3O
860812 - ..
860813 - This aligns with Doug's report on 000223 that limited bandwidth
860814 - prevents making progress using SDS for KM support. ref SDS 8 3774
860816 - ..
860817 - Limited bandwidth is a big problem that affects a lot of things.
860818 - ..
860819 - Jack will try to raise this at the meeting today.
860820 -
860821 -
860822 -
860823 -
860824 -
860825 -
860826 -
860827 -
8609 -