THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rod@welchco.com
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: July 16, 2000 11:11 AM Sunday;
Rod Welch
Received letter from Joe Ransdell about semiotics and SDS.
1...Summary/Objective
2...Does Semiotics Explain Benefits of SDS "Intelligence" Process??
3...Experience Foundation for Theoretical Thinking Scientific Method
4...Formal Logic Hard to Apply in Practice; Theory Requires Experience
5...Peirce's Semiotic Philosophy Explains Scientific Process of Inquiry
6...Scientific Conclusions Unbounded by Time
7...Time Critical to Human Reasoning in Daily Life
8...SDS Integration of Time and Information Provides Engine of Knowledge
9...Engine of Knowledge, SDS Lifts Capacity Think, Remember, Communicate
10...Science Applies Innate Mental Process of Growing Knowledge
11...Knowledge Management Provides Forum to Deploy Peirce's Semiotics
12...Academy Uses Knowledge Management for Special Application
13...Knowledge Helps Distinguish SDS Process from Information Management
.........................knowledge management
14...Products and Process Alternate Forms of Knowledge to Guide Action
15...Knowledge Management Dilemma Creates Tensions Between Disciplines
16...Knowledge Definition Product Development Not Derived from Philosophy
17...Scientific Method Process Intelligence Improve Management Productivity
18...Augment Intelligence Scientific Method Improve Management Productivity
19...Scientific Method Philosophy Semiotics Augments Intelligence Process
20...Semiotics Philosophy Scientific Method Augments Intelligence Process
21...Good Science Requires Good Procedures and Records, Aided by SDS
22...SDS Enables Consistent Use of Good Management Practice in All Fields
23...Understanding Critical in Communication, Target of Science
24...Communication Effectiveness Aided by Scientific Process
25...Semiotics Explain Logic of Signs formed by Sounds and Symbols
26...Speech and Alphabet Provide Signs to Construct Meaning and Inference
27...Meaning and Inference Derived from Logical Associations of Signs
28...Communication, Meaning, Inference Explained by Semiotics and SDS
29...17th Century Great Thinkers Overlooked Communication as Process
30...Ambitious Project Define Management Science
31...Management Science Founded in Communication and Cognition
32...Telecommunity Website to Promote Peirce's Philosophy
33...Joe Retired, Focusing on Development of Peirce Telecommunity
34...Retirees Effective Community for Evaluating Knowledge Management
35...Communication Metrics Needs Senior Executives for Pilot Testing
36...Executive Initiative Use Seniors to Pilot Test Communication Metrics
37...SDS Record Demonstrates POIMS, Com Metrics, and Knowledge Management
ACTION ITEMS..................
Click here to comment!
1...Additionally, or alternatively, Joe might consider thinking about
CONTACTS
0201 - Texas Tech University
020101 - Mr. Joseph M. Ransdell; Associate Professor
020103 - Department of Philosophy
SUBJECTS
Semiotic Theory Knowledge and Logic Derived from Experience
Semiotics = Communication + Meaning + Inference (Causation = Sequence
Semiotics Explained as Command & Control of the Record
Semotic Theory Knowledge and Logic Derived from Experience
Experience History Chronology Diary Causation
Peirce, Charles, S. 000515
1008 -
1008 - ..
1009 - Summary/Objective
1010 -
101001 - Follow up ref SDS 68 4078.
101002 -
101003 - Joe explains Peirce's work, and that semiotics treats logic and signs
101004 - which symbolize human thought. ref SDS 0 7216 Peirce focused on
101005 - experience, ref SDS 0 2200, and on science as a process of careful
101006 - inquiry, ref SDS 0 0785, which supports a core concept of SDS as an
101007 - engine of knowledge. ref SDS 0 0192 Joe cautions that "knowledge" and
101008 - "knowledge management" are "products" in the academic arena; he
101009 - suggests using something else for the "process" concept SDS supports.
101010 - ref SDS 0 2900 Tension between philosophers and scientists over these
101011 - differences might be bridged by the SDS design that integrates
101012 - products and process as alternate forms of knowledge. ref SDS 0 9240
101013 - Joe explains that science requires rigorous adherence to procedure
101014 - that establish accuracy and truth. SDS makes it faster, easier and
101015 - cheaper for everyone to use good practices for all knowledge work,
101016 - including formal science, which is otherwise impossible due to limited
101017 - span of attention. ref SDS 0 0785 Joe says the SDS process of
101018 - communication presents an ambitious theory of management that has
101019 - eluded discovery since the 17th century; he cautions to avoid getting
101020 - discouraged by resistance because culture takes time to absorb
101021 - improvements to the foundation of civilization. ref SDS 0 7838 Joe
101022 - retired from the university in May, and is now developing a
101023 - telecommunity to help more people discover and discuss Peirce's work.
101024 - ref SDS 0 5785 SDS can support this objective. SDS is difficult to
101025 - learn; however, Joe noticed that SDS records on the Internet provide a
101026 - self-reinforcing environment for learning about Knowledge Management
101027 - and Communication Metrics. ref SDS 0 0010 Joe should, also, consider
101028 - becoming involved in Doug Engelbart's DKR project which has similar
101029 - objectives. ref SDS 0 0660
101030 -
101031 - [On 000717 Joe reports progress learning about SDS, cautions
101032 - about resistance to business intelligence due to fear of
101033 - accountability. ref SDS 72 0001
101035 - ..
101036 - [On 000719 submitted response to Joe's letter. ref SDS 75 0001
101037 -
101039 - ..
1011 -
1012 -
1013 - Progress
1014 -
101401 - Does Semiotics Explain Benefits of SDS "Intelligence" Process??
101402 -
101403 - Received ref DRT 1 0001 from Joe dated 000715, and responding to my
101404 - letter, ref DIP 3 0001, sent on 000713, ref SDS 68 0616, asking Joe to
101405 - comment on SDS and Communication Metrics for implementing semiotics,
101406 - based on the concept of enhancing alphabet technology by integrating
101407 - time and information to provide Knowledge Management, ref DIP 3 8190,
101408 - and as shown in the record on 000713. ref SDS 68 4176
101410 - ..
101411 - My letter, also, sent a copy of the letter, ref DIP 1 9434, on 000624,
101412 - ref SDS 62 1534, asking about the role of "experience" for logical
101413 - thinking, based on the notion of chronology which gives meaning
101414 - through sequence that tends to establish cause and effect. This is
101415 - the advantage of "organization" that Bill DeHart identified in the
101416 - discussion on 000709. ref SDS 65 1784
101418 - ..
101419 - Joe does not seem to address the issue in this letter, but does so
101420 - somewhat in his second letter, per below. ref SDS 0 7216
101422 - ..
101423 - Joe does not directly discuss the opportunity for enhancing
101424 - alphabet technology. Below, he explains Peirce's semiotics
101425 - addressed human thought through signs, which seems like it might
101426 - relate to a notion of knowledge based in part on alphabet
101427 - technology, which in turn could be enhanced by integrating time.
101428 - ref SDS 0 7216
101430 - ..
101431 - Joe is interested in application of Peirce's ideas and might be able
101432 - to smooth the way on getting critical review of SDS to some extent,
101433 - which is requested in my letter to Joe. ref DIP 3 4402
101435 - ..
101436 - Joe will review the record to develop understanding of my objectives,
101437 - and respond today or by Monday, 000717. ref DRT 1 4757
101438 -
101439 - [On 000717 Joe submitted detailed analysis. ref SDS 72 0002
101441 - ..
101443 - ..
101444 - Joe also commends Mary Keeler's work. ref DRT 1 3348
101445 -
101446 - [On 000718 Mary recommends Joe for help on applying sound
101447 - fundamentals to develop knowledge management. ref SDS 74 0001
101448 -
101449 - [On 000719 notified Joe about Mary's suggestion that we work with
101450 - him on KM issues. ref SDS 75 1540
101451 -
101452 -
101454 - ..
101455 - Experience Foundation for Theoretical Thinking Scientific Method
101456 - Formal Logic Hard to Apply in Practice; Theory Requires Experience
101457 - Peirce's Semiotic Philosophy Explains Scientific Process of Inquiry
101458 -
101459 - Follow up ref SDS 51 0042.
101460 -
1015 -
1016 -
1017 - 2148
1019 - ..
101901 - Received ref DRT 2 0001 from Joe dated today, providing preliminary
101902 - comments on my letter to Joe. ref DIP 3 0001
101904 - ..
101905 - Joe says Peirce is primarily concerned with the nature of scientific
101906 - research. His work contributes to the logic of research. and with
101907 - making practical activity more intelligent generally. Joe further
101908 - notes that knowledge management requires -- perhaps IS -- a logic of
101909 - practice rather than a logic of research. ref DRT 2 9102
101911 - ..
101912 - Joe cautions against using logicians' methods for practical thinking.
101913 - Formal logical methodologies support purely theoretical reasoning, but
101914 - they rarely show any insight into the realities of practical reasoning
101915 - and its tasks. Joe says these methods tend toward fanaticism and
101916 - useless exaggeration. ref DRT 2 0081
101917 -
101918 - On 000212 IBIS logic methods proposed. ref SDS 32 9282
101920 - ..
101921 - On 000218 difficulties reported applying rigid rules applied using
101922 - IBIS. ref SDS 33 7050
101924 - ..
101925 - On 000614 DKR project proposes adopting formal logic processes
101926 - through IBIS. ref SDS 56 4939
101928 - ..
101929 - Peirce held that theoretical thinking must be grounded experientially,
101930 - while at the same time understanding that there is a real difference
101931 - between theoretical and practical thinking that must be respected or
101932 - else both theory and practice will suffer from corruption.
101934 - ..
101935 - Aligns with report on 991124 that Einstein held experience is the
101936 - basis of knowledge. ref SDS 24 3066
101938 - ..
101939 - Review on 000515 of Mary Keeler's paper seems to support Joe's
101940 - explanation of Peirce's reliance on experience as key indicator of
101941 - human reasoning. ref SDS 51 0042
101942 -
101944 - ..
101945 - Scientific Conclusions Unbounded by Time
101946 - Time Critical to Human Reasoning in Daily Life
101947 - SDS Integration of Time and Information Provides Engine of Knowledge
101948 -
101949 - Joe gives an example -- scientific research in its uncompromised
101950 - form has no deadlines which compel researchers to make a decision at a
101951 - given time about what to conclude. Acceptance either occurs or does
101952 - not occur of its own accord in virtue of experience or experientially
101953 - conditioned reflection on the subject matter in some way, directly or
101954 - indirectly. That is, the time must come when one just finds oneself
101955 - convinced enough that something which one thinks to be so or which is
101956 - claimed to be so really IS so to be willing to make use of that
101957 - conclusion as a premise or presupposition in one's own further
101958 - thinking about the subject-matter: it is the USE of that research
101959 - conclusion as a premise or presupposition that constitutes acceptance.
101960 - ref DRT 2 0663
101962 - ..
101963 - This scientific process basing conclusion on experience and only
101964 - after sufficient time for the weight of evidence becomes to
101965 - justify belief is reflected in the record on 000426 citing
101966 - experience indicating SDS is the only KM capability. ref SDS 44
101967 - 0480
101969 - ..
101970 - On 000106 people who lack availability of tools to track their
101971 - experience, feel disadvantaged, resulting in concerns that
101972 - conclusions are premature, and therefore reflect arrogance.
101973 - ref SDS 27 0877
101975 - ..
101976 - Joe notes that practical "conclusions" in daily life are based on
101977 - incomplete evidence because action must be taken in time to be
101978 - effective. Timeliness is a constant factor in daily life, whereas it
101979 - does not enter into the logic of research at all -- or it shouldn't --
101980 - ref DRT 2 2040
101982 - ..
101983 - Joe notes that efforts to augment human thinking strive to help make a
101984 - decision (arrive at a conclusion) in a timely way, which compromises
101985 - the assumption of truth; he cites the judicial process as an example.
101986 - This doesn't mean that truth is not important in practical affairs but
101987 - only that it factors into the process in a different way than it does
101988 - in research activity. ref DRT 2 0875
101989 -
101991 - ..
101992 - Engine of Knowledge, SDS Lifts Capacity Think, Remember, Communicate
101993 - Science Applies Innate Mental Process of Growing Knowledge
101994 - Knowledge Management Provides Forum to Deploy Peirce's Semiotics
101995 -
101996 - Joe is interested in SDS for analysis of Peirce's ideas for a logic of
101997 - practice. ref DRT 2 0936
101998 -
101999 - This is the central issue in my letter to Joe, requesting comment
102000 - on the earlier to Mary Keeler, which expressly proposes that better
102001 - command experience provides an opportunity for improving reasoning.
102002 - ref DIP 1 6018
102004 - ..
102005 - Joe notes that Peirce conceived the logic of research as essentially
102006 - connected to practice, so that it is not a matter of adopting a theory
102007 - that requires adding the relationship to practice, since working out
102008 - that relationship was one of his central concerns in almost all of his
102009 - work. ref DRT 2 5840
102011 - ..
102012 - We are not trying to build something, per se, based on Peirce's
102013 - ideas, a la a "Peirce Knowledge Machine"; but, rather we are
102014 - looking to discover the underlying strength of SDS based on
102015 - alignment with Peirce's work, and that of others, e.g., the folks
102016 - who developed alphabet technology.
102018 - ..
102019 - The goal of SDS set out in POIMS technology is to lift the innate
102020 - capacity to think, remember and communicate. Therefore, if SDS can
102021 - be improved based on aspects of Peirce's work, or anyone's work, it
102022 - needs to be identified and analysed.
102024 - ..
102025 - Joe explains Peirce used "pragmatism" to stress the practical import
102026 - of theoretical ideas. ref DRT 2 3968
102028 - ..
102029 - Joe says Peirce was process, rather than product oriented, and cites
102030 - parenthetically having observed disagreement I have with colleagues on
102031 - the DKR team about knowledge management. Joe suggests the differences
102032 - are apparently rooted in this difference between process and product.
102033 - Peirce did not think of science as a body of achieved knowledge, a
102034 - collection of results, but rather as a form of life to which a
102035 - scientific researcher is committed... ref DRT 2 7548
102037 - ..
102038 - Communication Metrics needs references from the record that
102039 - illustrate important points. SDS provides a means to uniquely
102040 - position information in Knowledge Space so that it is easy to
102041 - provide references to orient observations. It would expedite review
102042 - for Joe to provide references in the record that show differences
102043 - with Doug's DKR team about knowledge management, understanding and
102044 - response is easier.
102045 -
102046 - [On 000719 letter to Joe mentions need for references to
102047 - expedite review and correction. ref SDS 75 3835
102049 - ..
102050 - SDS is designed to facilitate the underlying process for generating
102051 - knowledge, which might be called an intelligence process of plan,
102052 - perform report, explained in POIMS. ref OF 2 6649
102054 - ..
102055 - This makes SDS is an "engine" of knowledge.
102057 - ..
102058 - Joe concurs with analysis in the letter, ref DIP 3 1620, describing
102059 - "knowledge management" as mostly marketing hype, ref DRT 2 4617, like
102060 - data mining, business intelligence, reviewed on 980226. ref SDS 14
102061 - 2716
102062 -
102063 - KM is a fad in mainstream technology because practitioners have not
102064 - taken the trouble to distinguish it from any past efforts for using
102065 - technology to aid management, or more generally knowledge work, as
102066 - shown on 980226. ref SDS 14 2716
102067 -
102068 -
102070 - ..
102071 - Academy Uses Knowledge Management for Special Application
102072 - Knowledge Helps Distinguish SDS Process from Information Management
102073 -
102074 - Joe suggests there should be a better descriptive label that doesn't
102075 - have the many misleading associations which "knowledge", "know", and
102076 - the other cognates of that term have... ref DRT 2 0384
102078 - ..
102079 - He indicates that universities sometimes use "knowledge" for referring
102080 - primarily to concern with expertise in the acquisition and sale of
102081 - intellectual property, at present patent rights but with a clear
102082 - movement in the direction of copyright as well. Joe draws attention
102083 - to how easily the idea of...
102085 - ..
102086 - knowledge management
102087 -
102088 -
102089 - ...can take on that meaning, where the management regards knowledge as
102090 - a commodity whose producers are to be managed in a profitable way --
102091 - hence the idea of the university as a knowledge factory -- not
102092 - knowledge management as an augmentation of intelligence, which is what
102093 - you are of course concerned with. ref DRT 2 4466
102095 - ..
102096 - There has been a lot of debate in the project about the meaning of
102097 - KM, from the first day of the Colloquium at Stanford, as later
102098 - reported on 000407. ref SDS 41 2805 KM seems to have been adopted
102099 - solely because it has name recognition among potential funding
102100 - sponsors, arising from commercial hype. On 000504 Doug Engelbart
102101 - related need to define knowledge; on 000518 this was taken up.
102102 - ref SDS 53 2808 Mary Keeler attended that meeting and provided
102103 - guidance. ref SDS 53 8439 On 000615 the team decided they did not
102104 - know enough about knowledge to create KM. ref SDS 57 6271
102105 -
102106 - [On 000718 DKR team at SRI submits proposal to NASA for KM
102107 - capability, despite having announced consensus they do not know
102108 - how to develop Knowledge Management. ref SDS 73 4410
102110 - ..
102111 - There is another parallel in KM work with respect to the open
102112 - source issue. A lot of attention has been focused on...
102113 -
102114 -
102115 - intellectual property
102116 -
102117 -
102118 - ...rights, for example see...
102119 -
102120 - 000201 notice of a conference. ref SDS 30 1708
102122 - ..
102123 - 000202 Paul Fernhout reviewed the issue. ref SDS 31 0001
102125 - ..
102126 - 000324 SRI concerned about property rights. ref SDS 38 3055
102128 - ..
102129 - 000422 Paul objects to draft of open source license.
102130 - ref SDS 42 3050
102131 -
102133 - ..
102134 - POIMS technology formulates a process of investing...
102135 -
102136 -
102137 - intellectual capital
102138 -
102139 -
102140 - ... ref OF 2 1101, rather than squandering it in constant meetings,
102141 - calls, email and other forms of grazing (also "foraging") on
102142 - information, explained on 960426. ref SDS 8 4404
102144 - ..
102145 - On the other hand, some people use "intellectual capital" to refer
102146 - to things like patents, copyrights, software code, song lyrics, a
102147 - manuscript, etc. Since usage in POIMS is effective for conveying a
102148 - role for "investing" and growing knowledge, other uses do not cause
102149 - a problem.
102150 -
102151 -
102152 -
1022 -
SUBJECTS
Knowledge Define Science = Inquiry Experience Static Results of Inqu
2603 -
260401 - ..
260402 - Products and Process Alternate Forms of Knowledge to Guide Action
260403 - Knowledge Management Dilemma Creates Tensions Between Disciplines
260404 -
260405 - Joe observes strong differences between philosophers of science and
260406 - scientists, due to the difference in orientation between creating a
260407 - product versus performing a process. ref DRT 2 4108
260408 -
260409 - Turf battles are endemic to the biology of the mind that constructs
260410 - common sense from its experience, and avers outsiders, especially
260411 - those who would interfere with common sense. This causes
260412 - differences between the engineer and the plumber, between the
260413 - biologist and a doctor, philosopher and scientist. It is all a
260414 - matter of scale. Philosophers work at a lower level of theory than
260415 - do scientists, scientists work at a lower level than engineers,
260416 - engineers work at a lower level of detail than craftsmen, craftsmen
260417 - like doctors and mechanics seem like geniuses to customers outside
260418 - their craft.
260420 - ..
260421 - Common sense, however, tells the scientist that the philosopher is
260422 - unnecessary, and that the engineer doesn't understand the science.
260423 - The engineer feels the science is unproven, and the mechanic didn't
260424 - follow the plans. The mechanic feels the plans are incomplete and
260425 - the customer is unreasonable. The customer feels the mechanic
260426 - isn't listening, and wants his money back.
260428 - ..
260429 - Joe points out that "knowledge" refers to static results of inquiry
260430 - whereas knowledge management entails a continuous process that
260431 - distinguishes between what is known and what is in question at a given
260432 - time, and, further, what is relevant but is not settled, with the
260433 - former providing the basis for continuity in the ongoing pursuit of
260434 - settlement of the latter. This is such a different perspective than
260435 - the one that regards knowledge as a product that you are bound to fail
260436 - in trying to come up with a definition of "knowledge" that satisfies
260437 - you because the word itself really belongs to a different paradigm
260438 - than you are trying to develop. ref DRT 2 4047
260440 - ..
260441 - On 000515 review of Peirce's work indicates definition of knowledge
260442 - relates to continual inquiry to refine accuracy of understanding
260443 - correlations between cause and effect. ref SDS 51 0042
260444 -
260445 - [On 040312 science poses "locality principle" exchange of
260446 - energy connecting cause and effect yields the power of
260447 - knowledge to control and predict the future. ref SDS 89 YH4G
260449 - ..
260450 - [On 050115 book review explains Peirce views on standard
260451 - philosophy definition of knowledge true justified belief.
260452 - ref SDS 92 9X94
260454 - ..
260455 - Merely because words and phrases are used differently according to
260456 - context, does not diminish the need for striving to set out clear,
260457 - functional definitions for specific applications. Here, the aim is
260458 - to identify action for deploying technology to improve human
260459 - cognition. Somebody is going to build something. Someone is going
260460 - to write some code. We need language that guides such conduct
260461 - toward a useful purpose. The language of cognition, including
260462 - data, information, knowledge, intelligence, span of attention,
260463 - wisdom, vision, et al, is essential to make progress, as set out in
260464 - NWO... ref OF 3 5024
260466 - ..
260467 - No KM project has come up with an explanation of what they are
260468 - trying to produce, as well Joe sets out in his letter today, per
260469 - above. ref SDS 0 446J
260471 - ..
260472 - On 000106 knowledge management dilemma undefined. ref SDS 27
260473 - 1025, ref SDS 44 0480
260475 - ..
260476 - On 000116, SDS only KM solution. ref SDS 28 0877
260478 - ..
260479 - On 000324 a number of KM projects have been funded, but none
260480 - have succeeded. ref SDS 38 4877
260482 - ..
260483 - On 000425 KM is a secret of SDS. ref SDS 44 0480
260485 - ..
260486 - On 000503 key software engineer on Doug's DKR project says
260487 - "knowledge" and KM not well enough defined. ref SDS 48 5033
260489 - ..
260490 - On 000517 KM defined, ref SDS 52 5073, based on functional
260491 - distinction between "knowledge" and "information" where
260492 - "intelligence" is a conversion process. ref SDS 52 0785
260494 - ..
260495 - On 000615 DKR project at SRI gave up trying to understand
260496 - Knowledge Management. ref SDS 57 6271
260498 - ..
260499 - SDS supports the scientific process of inquiry (Joe sets out below,
260500 - ref SDS 0 0785), by leveraging the innate mental process of plan,
260501 - perform, report using a unique design that integrates time and
260502 - information. For convenience the process is called "intelligence."
260503 - ref OF 2 5418 It converts information into a deliverable, which is
260504 - a form of "product" that comprises a web of connections showing
260505 - cause and effect relative to objectives, i.e., context. This
260506 - product can be called "knowledge," but, it is not static. Rather
260507 - knowledge is under constant scrutiny from continual learning that
260508 - forms new connections from daily life experience that modify by
260509 - some degree, large or small what is already "known."
260510 -
260511 - [On 000717 Joe reports SDS process of linking relevant context
260512 - aids understanding. ref SDS 72 3825
260514 - ..
260515 - [On 000721 Joe says again SDS improves understanding.
260516 - ref SDS 77 E2FY
260518 - ..
260519 - [On 000722 Joe explains scientific process flows from Socratic
260520 - practice of inquiry. ref SDS 78 5800
260522 - ..
260523 - This product, called "knowledge," leverages useful aspects of human
260524 - cognition, loosely called remembering, understanding, thinking and
260525 - reasoning. Note that each element, i.e., both process and product,
260526 - supports the other, providing an efficient engine of knowledge,
260527 - explained in POIMS,. ref OF 2 4662 So, we need both intelligence
260528 - (process) and knowledge (product), and this need is met every day
260529 - all day long by everyone on the planet, whether they want to or
260530 - not. Like breathing it is entirely involuntary. Also, like
260531 - breathing, it can be aided by technology.
260533 - ..
260534 - Action is the purpose of knowledge, i.e., guidance that sustains
260535 - life, so a key part of the SDS process is deciding what action to
260536 - take based on understanding what has transpired in relation to the
260537 - context of correlations and implications. This is supported by SDS
260538 - along a continuum of scale, so that it can enhance a broad range of
260539 - knowledge work, i.e., legal, medical, science, engineering, sales,
260540 - etc.
260542 - ..
260543 - This makes SDS is an engine of knowledge based on POIMS technology.
260544 -
260545 -
260547 - ..
260548 - Knowledge Definition Product Development Not Derived from Philosophy
260549 - Scientific Method Process Intelligence Improve Management Productivity
260550 -
260551 - Joe reviews the scientific model of the inquiry process. The working
260552 - scientist rarely has occasion to talk about what he or she knows or
260553 - about what is known other than in a context in which there is some
260554 - question about what is being taken for granted in a given inquiry.
260555 -
260556 - Com Metrics support for context discussed above. ref SDS 0 0192
260558 - ..
260559 - Anything taken for granted might be referred to as "known," but in
260560 - practice what that means is simply that it is presently taken for
260561 - granted and thus not worth much discussion, unless there is some
260562 - concrete reason for not taking it for granted. What is worth
260563 - discussing and thinking about is what is questionable. The inquirer
260564 - does not live in a world overtly structured by "knowledge", which
260565 - provides infrastructure for it but for that very reason is invisible,
260566 - as it were, but rather in a world which is overtly structured by
260567 - questions, ideas, things observed, and means or instruments of
260568 - observation.
260569 -
260570 - [On 020608 case study meaning of "knowledge" distinguished
260571 - from "information, cites philosophy perspective reviewed on
260572 - 050115, ref SDS 92 SF5K, for grounding practice of
260573 - "Knowledge Management" that correlates with cognitive
260574 - science, reviewed 960518, ref SDS 9 GS58, management
260575 - practices on 000307, ref SDS 35 767G, and physical science,
260576 - reviewed on 040312, ref SDS 89 YH4G, to explain the power
260577 - of knowledge for predicting and controlling the future.
260578 - ref SDS 85 CC6J
260580 - ..
260581 - [On 040312 debate between Einstein and others about theories of
260582 - quantum mechanics in relation to Newtonian explanation of locality
260583 - principle illustrates scientific process of continuing inquiry,
260584 - but also overlayed with prejudice and personality grounded in
260585 - popularity and faith. ref SDS 89 U86L
260587 - ..
260588 - [On 050115 knowledge defined in philosophy as justified true
260589 - belief, ref SDS 92 ZG6K, helps ground practice of Knowledge
260590 - Management. ref SDS 92 845K
260592 - ..
260593 - Joe advises that talk about "knowledge" is usually reserved for
260594 - attempts (often misguided) to communicate with outsiders who are
260595 - result-oriented rather than inquiry-oriented. Communication for the
260596 - scientist occurs in a world of problems commonly recognized in
260597 - understanding the subject-matter, of claims made or makeable (which
260598 - are regarded as preposterous, plausible, tenable, compelling, trivial,
260599 - important, pertinent, etc.) and of questions about their acceptance or
260600 - acceptability, and is governed by communicational norms which are
260601 - derived from the conditions which must be realized if the members of
260602 - the research community are going to stay in sufficient agreement with
260603 - one another as regards acceptance of claims made to continue as a
260604 - research community. ref DRT 2 0507
260605 -
260606 -
260607 -
260608 -
2607 -
SUBJECTS
Scientific Method Applied to Management Enterprise Enables Significa
3703 -
370401 - ..
370402 - Augment Intelligence Scientific Method Improve Management Productivity
370403 - Scientific Method Philosophy Semiotics Augments Intelligence Process
370404 - Semiotics Philosophy Scientific Method Augments Intelligence Process
370405 -
370406 - Joe poses a question of applying SDS to management of enterprise,
370407 - similar to the process of scientific research, described earlier, per
370408 - above, ref SDS 0 0785, and which leads to the prospect that management
370409 - can become more "intelligent" to increase productivity? ref DRT 2 3010
370410 - This would make Peirce's philosophical work on semiotics to formalize
370411 - the scientific research process, ref DRT 2 9102, a practical dimension
370412 - of daily management by augmenting intelligence. ref DRT 2 0875
370413 -
370414 - Joe's analysis of SDS aligns with review in the letter from Roy
370415 - Roebuck at DOD, received on 990225. (later reviewed on 020217,
370416 - ref SDS 84 1332)
370418 - ..
370419 - [On 021118 Francis Bacon is credited for noticing a "scientific
370420 - method" of plan, perform, report. ref SDS 86 N34U
370422 - ..
370423 - SDS supports the scientific process of inquiry, based on a
370424 - functional notion of knowledge derived from continual learning
370425 - through inquiry, as set out above, ref SDS 0 0192, and POIMS
370426 - directly correlates management with an "intelligence" process of
370427 - plan, perform, report similar to the scientific method. ref OF 2
370428 - 6649
370429 -
370430 - [On 000720 Joe explains Socrates developed a method of analysis
370431 - using controlled dialog that led to scientific inquiry; there
370432 - was worry that early applications of writing merely transcribed
370433 - speeches, undermined inquiry through feedback that occurs in
370434 - dialog. ref SDS 76 4576
370436 - ..
370437 - [On 000721 Joe comments that "communication" has not been
370438 - carefully studied in philosophy, ref SDS 77 8954, and he
370439 - commends SDS process that aids understanding. ref SDS 77 0002
370441 - ..
370442 - [On 000722 Joe explains scientific process of inquiry evolved
370443 - from Socrates' method of analytic controlled dialog for asking
370444 - questions. ref SDS 78 5800
370446 - ..
370447 - On 000713 semiotics that integrates communication, meaning and
370448 - inference aligns with SDS based on a management cycle, also called
370449 - an "intelligence" process. ref SDS 68 4176 See also semiotics
370450 - below. ref SDS 0 7216
370452 - ..
370453 - Thus, SDS not only aids the scientist, but also the farmer, the
370454 - politician, the manager and executive, the reporter, the software
370455 - programmer, the doctor, the patient, the mechanic, and all other
370456 - forms of knowledge work, because it enhances alphabet technology
370457 - that is the engine of civilization. Like the alphabet, SDS can be
370458 - applied along a continuum from very formal inquiry, like science,
370459 - to applied science in computer chip design, to the dynamic world of
370460 - daily management that requires useful knowledge minute by minute,
370461 - hour by hour, day by day, week by week, month by month, year by
370462 - year, decade by decade, etc., etc., etc...., as explained during
370463 - the meeting at Intel on 000517. ref SDS 52 5073
370464 -
370465 - [On 000720 concern about feedback time between orality and
370466 - literacy limits awareness that SDS can keep up with daily work.
370467 - ref SDS 76 2960
370468 -
370469 -
370471 - ..
370472 - Good Science Requires Good Procedures and Records, Aided by SDS
370473 - SDS Enables Consistent Use of Good Management Practice in All Fields
370474 -
370475 - Joe explains that commonly accepted norms are at their most obvious
370476 - and rigid in respect to professional publication, but in addition to
370477 - the norms governing formal publication -- which have a very special
370478 - status -- there are other and more flexible norms governing informal
370479 - communication of all sorts, ranging from those governing the
370480 - presentation of papers at conferences to the way people talk to one
370481 - another at the cafeteria or in the halls. But that only scratches the
370482 - surface; for there are norms commonly recognized in connection with
370483 - laboratory work and field observation, and so forth, that insure
370484 - proper records are kept so that all activity and interaction with the
370485 - subject-matter is integrated into the communicational relationship as
370486 - well. ref DRT 2 2754
370488 - ..
370489 - See review of Covey on 921205 on challenge of using good practices
370490 - consistently due to human biology. ref SDS 4 4803
370492 - ..
370493 - Human biology suffers "meaning drift" that makes "truth a moving
370494 - target," per Landauer reviewed on 960518, ref SDS 9 4488. This
370495 - makes "norms" for anything difficult to follow, unless a lot of
370496 - money is spent to check and double check procedures (see for
370497 - example the the Columbia Space Shuttle disaster reported 921021,
370498 - ref SDS 3 4499), because the human mind on its own is susceptible
370499 - to meaning drift (see illustration on 991101, ref SDS 22 0857), and
370500 - further, the human mind cannot follow any particular procedure,
370501 - consistently regardless of formal published requirements, due to
370502 - near term influences that cause deviations in the name of...
370503 -
370505 - ..
370506 - common sense
370507 -
370508 -
370509 - ..., explained in New World Order...,
370510 - and...
370511 -
370512 - expediting
370513 -
370514 -
370515 - ...(the "time" constraint Joe cites above, ref SDS 0 6960, which
370516 - always causes delay and extra cost, but seems correct at the
370517 - moment.
370519 - ..
370520 - Limitations following good scientific and professional practice,
370521 - which, also, occur in lay activity, are caused by limited span of
370522 - attention, which makes communication the biggest risk in
370523 - enterprise, especially in an environment of information overload.
370524 - If anyone's research is examined closely, flaws in procedure will
370525 - be found; it is only a matter of scale.
370527 - ..
370528 - SDS makes it possible to consistently implement good management
370529 - practices in any field, per above. ref SDS 0 0192, and explained in
370530 - POIMS. ref OF 2 6649
370531 -
370532 -
370534 - ..
370535 - Understanding Critical in Communication, Target of Science
370536 - Communication Effectiveness Aided by Scientific Process
370537 -
370538 - Joe says that if science is a process of inquiry then we can
370539 - understand it as essentially communicational in character, not in the
370540 - sense that scientists are doing nothing but writing up reports and
370541 - arguing with others about them -- which they are not -- but in the
370542 - sense that all inquiry activity, including observational and
370543 - experimental activity, is regulated by reference to what is required
370544 - in order to maintain communicational effectiveness. Now the archiving
370545 - of results in a way that is based on the aim of making clear their
370546 - functional significance in ongoing research is clearly desirable, but
370547 - it is only one of many factors that are to be understood in an
370548 - adequate and comprehensive understanding of the ongoing process of
370549 - scientific inquiry considered as a communicational process.
370550 - ref DRT 2 1350
370551 -
370552 - [On 040312 review Doctor Henry Folse, philosophical professor
370553 - at Loyala University, book on Neils Bohr presents philosophy of
370554 - complementarity as the foundation of quantum mechanics that
370555 - bridges the macro world of life experienced through sensory
370556 - perception, and the microscopic world where exponential change
370557 - in scale prevents common experience, ref SDS 90 Z29O, thus
370558 - presenting a problem of "communication," as Doctor Ransdell
370559 - explains today. ref SDS 0 0968
370561 - ..
370562 - Understanding is defined in NWO... ref OF 3 2247
370564 - ..
370565 - Communication needs a definition, see for example on 950327.
370566 - ref SDS 7 0001 and in NWO... ref OF 3 2732
370568 - ..
370569 - Seems unnecessary to stretch "communication" beyond the process of
370570 - building community, as a survival strategy, leaving open the
370571 - larger realm of personal reflection and analysis, that includes
370572 - communication, but encompasses all cognitive activity aimed at
370573 - sustaining existence (life) of the body, as discussed in the
370574 - letter, ref DIP 2 0001, to Bill Bearden on 000629. ref SDS 63 6934
370576 - ..
370577 - SDS supports Communication Metrics explained in the NWO... paper.
370578 - ref OF 3 0001 Specifically at ref OF 3 2864.
370579 -
370580 -
370581 -
3706 -
SUBJECTS
Ontology Structure of Knowledge
Semotic Theory Knowledge and Logic Derived from Experience
Epistomology Meaning Through Representation of Existential Relations
Ontology Definition
Leaning by Experience Generalizes Logic, Theory of Semotic
Semiotics Knowledge = Communication + Meaning + Inference (Causation)
Semiotics = Communication + Meaning + Inference
Semiotic Knowledge = Communication + Meaning + Inference (Causation =
Semiotics = Communication + Meaning + Inference (Causation = Sequence
5111 -
511201 - ..
511202 - Semiotics Explain Logic of Signs formed by Sounds and Symbols
511203 - Speech and Alphabet Provide Signs to Construct Meaning and Inference
511204 - Meaning and Inference Derived from Logical Associations of Signs
511205 - Communication, Meaning, Inference Explained by Semiotics and SDS
511206 -
511207 - Follow up ref SDS 68 4176.
511208 -
511209 - Joe explains today, that "semiotic" was Peirce's term for logic of
511210 - signs and symbols, shown on 000515 reviewing Mary Keeler's paper on
511211 - Peirce. ref SDS 51 0784
511213 - ..
511214 - Signs, for example, speech that uses arrangements of distinct sounds,
511215 - and the alphabet using various arrangements of pictures that represent
511216 - sounds, both comprise symbols which represent internal thoughts.
511217 - Meaning derives from the relation of signs to prior experience, which
511218 - gives rise to the need for "alignment." Thought becomes external,
511219 - i.e., public, when communicated through signs. Thus calling logic
511220 - "semiotic" was a kind of compact way of saying that thought is a
511221 - property of meaningful public entities, not a mysterious activity "in
511222 - the head" or even "in the nervous system". ref DRT 2 2014
511224 - ..
511225 - On 000713 review of Joe's paper indicates that semiotic is an
511226 - expression that combines or integrates communication, meaning and
511227 - inference. ref SDS 68 4176 Since inference is related to logic,
511228 - and since logic entails relationships that impart meaning, which
511229 - is part of communication, Joe's explanation today, seems to align
511230 - somewhat with the prior understanding set out in record on 000713.
511231 - ref DIP 3 0001
511233 - ..
511234 - Would like Joe's take on idea to enhance alphabet technology by
511235 - integrating time and information through the SDS record that
511236 - permits assembling information for specific subjects into
511237 - chronologies of cause and effect based on context, as shown in the
511238 - record on 000713. ref SDS 68 1092
511239 -
511240 - [On 000719 letter to Joe asks about this. ref SDS 75 7488
511242 - ..
511243 - Joe asks can semiotics he describes support management theory, using
511244 - doctrines about various kinds of meaning and interpretation? He
511245 - recommends this work is difficult and worthwhile. Joe offers to aid
511246 - the effort in any way that seems helpful, recognizing it is really
511247 - quite ambitious, which warrants caution against allowing the slowness
511248 - of development to discourage continued effort. ref DRT 2 5742
511249 -
511250 - Semiotics explained in Joe's paper reviewed on 000713, as covering
511251 - communication, meaning and inference, ref SDS 68 4176, provides a
511252 - useful and broader form of "integration" which technology can
511253 - implement to enable a process for adding "intelligence" to
511254 - management, which indeed is a major advance in management theory,
511255 - as explained in POIMS. ref OF 2 5820
511256 -
511257 - [On 000719 letter to Joe requests support for developing Com
511258 - Metrics infrastructure. ref SDS 75 6555
511259 -
511260 -
511261 -
511262 -
5113 -
SUBJECTS
Giving Up Computers Productivity Managers Reduced by Computers, Lost
Meaning Drift Biggest Risk of Mistakes
Ambitious SDS Com Metrics Intelligence Developing Management Science
Ambitious Undertaking Developing Management Science Com Metrics Elud
Intelligence Overwhelming Overkill Shocking Not Necessary for Succes
Fear SDS Records Can't Write Intelligence Amazed Overwhelmed Complex
Computers Not for Management Mainly Communication Talking Listening
Giving Up on Communication Improvement Cultural Resistance Communica
Integrated Schedule Diary Not Intuitive Diffiuclt to Understand to L
Ambitous Difficult Define Management Science, 000716
Ambitious Define Management Science Eluded Great Thinkers Since 17th
6513 -
651401 - ..
651402 - 17th Century Great Thinkers Overlooked Communication as Process
651403 - Ambitious Project Define Management Science
651404 - Management Science Founded in Communication and Cognition
651405 -
651406 - Professor Ransdell plans to follow development of Com Metrics theory
651407 - and practice, and mentions the prospect of contributing, because
651408 - Communication Metrics offers a coherent theory of management that has
651409 - eluded discovery by great thinkers since the 17th Century. He urges
651410 - that SDS is an ambitious effort that should not be discouraged by slow
651411 - acceptance. ref DRT 2 UZ3F POIMS defines a theory of management (Com
651412 - Metrics) based on an intelligence process for converting information
651413 - into knowledge, ref OF 2 1104 and ref OF 2 6649, that is implemented
651414 - by SDS. Joe says today that communication as a "process" has been
651415 - previously overlooked, ref DRT 2 PU5F
651416 -
651417 - [On 000717 Professor Ransdell follows up saying that the
651418 - methodology implemented by SDS is "...really onto
651419 - something..." that improves understanding communication by
651420 - providing links to context. ref SDS 72 4O61
651422 - ..
651423 - [On 040312 professor Schombert cites Thomas Khun
651424 - noting paradigms, belief, faith in existing ideas
651425 - block consideration of new ideas until people gain
651426 - experience to create grudging acceptance, then a new
651427 - paradigm forms. ref SDS 89 3D7F
651429 - ..
651430 - SDS augments intelligence to lift capacity to think, remember and
651431 - communicate that fits the model of a strategic inflection point,
651432 - described by Grove, reviewed on 980307. ref SDS 15 6148 and
651433 - ref SDS 15 SW70
651435 - ..
651436 - SDS enables a new way of thinking and working "intelligently" that
651437 - enables good management, explained in POIMS. ref OF 2 1X6G, and
651438 - ref OF 2 6649 On 991222 Doug Engelbart calls for technology to enable
651439 - a new way of thinking and learning. ref SDS 26 3696 A coherent theory
651440 - of human thought defined in POIMS, ref OF 1 0367, is the foundation
651441 - for a theory of management and communication based on chronology,
651442 - context, and connection. ref OF 2 1106
651444 - ..
651445 - Joe's caution that ambitious development encounters slow professional
651446 - and commercial acceptance was cited by Uncle Jim in his letter on
651447 - 970522 explaining why investigating better management is resisted.
651448 - ref SDS 11 PP6M Frustrations about slow acceptance were reviewed
651449 - again on 970611, indicating that people on the job only have time for
651450 - cursory review. ref SDS 12 0900 An example is review by Morris at
651451 - Intel on 990713. ref SDS 20 TG56
651453 - ..
651454 - [On 030413 Gary Johnson demonstrates using SDS, and notices
651455 - the SDS design augments intelligence. ref SDS 84 0001
651457 - ..
651458 - [On 040221 SRI CALO project proposes developing technology
651459 - that delivers the power of knowledge to empower people.
651460 - ref SDS 87 EC5F
651462 - ..
651463 - On 980307 Andy Grove describing difficulty improving work at Intel
651464 - described challenge that success blinds people to new realities; some
651465 - people just don't "get it." ref SDS 16 2648
651467 - ..
651468 - On 990305 letter from Max Wideman, ref SDS 17 0001, supported
651469 - Communication Metrics, and recalled that transformation to better
651470 - tools and practices for project management takes a long time to
651471 - overcome resistance to improvement. ref SDS 17 7611
651473 - ..
651474 - Joe's analysis aligns with review by NSF reported on 991213, which,
651475 - also, found Com Metrics ambitious; however, unlike Joe who recognizes
651476 - an important accomplishment, NSF held it is beyond reach. ref SDS 25
651477 - 4187
651479 - ..
651480 - Since communication is a big part of the cognitive process that
651481 - converts information into knowledge, Joe is on track in associating
651482 - failure to formulate a theory of management with failure to grasp
651483 - communication as a process. Drucker's report that people have given
651484 - up on improving communication because the complexity of the task is
651485 - too difficult, reviewed on 931130, ref SDS 6 3851, supports Joe's view
651486 - that Communication Metrics is ambitious. POIMS describes a core issue
651487 - as understanding the distinction between information and knowledge.
651488 - ref OF 2 SK7L and ref OF 2 0367
651490 - ..
651491 - Joe credits Doug Engelbart as a master visionary. ref DRT 2 5415 In
651492 - his 1962 proposal Doug credited Vannevar Bush for a grand vision in
651493 - 1945 to apply technology for augmenting intelligence, reviewed on
651494 - 991222. ref SDS 26 XS6N
651496 - ..
651497 - The SDS "intelligence" process of "plan, perform, report" was
651498 - developed in 1985. This design supports the scientific method to
651499 - strengthen management with Communication Metrics. Understanding and
651500 - follow up are key metrics that improve traditional efforts focusing
651501 - communication on persuasion. Timely, accurate understanding
651502 - background, correlations, implications and nuance help accomplish
651503 - objectives, requirements, and commitments in time to be effective
651504 - saving lives, time, and money.
651506 - ..
651507 - [On 000723 history of SDS and Communication Metrics.
651508 - ref SDS 79 5W6N
651510 - ..
651511 - [On 021118 Francis Bacon is attributed with noticing a
651512 - "scientific method" of plan, perform, report. ref SDS 86 N34U
651514 - ..
651515 - Joe feels Peirce may have grasped the idea of communication as a
651516 - process in work at the beginning of this century (reviewed on 000515
651517 - showing "experience" is the core of human intelligence, ref SDS 51
651518 - 0042), but for most people the computer at the end of the century has
651519 - provided an environment that aids recognition of underlying factors.
651520 - ref DRT 2 5415
651522 - ..
651523 - On 000503 computer experts, including AI, withdraw from efforts to
651524 - understand knowledge and intelligence. ref SDS 48 5033 On 000615
651525 - Doug's OHS/DR team meeting at SRI gave up on understanding knowledge.
651526 - ref SDS 57 6271 Except for Com Metrics, for example on 890523,
651527 - ref SDS 1 SQ5L, there is no evident record showing computers have
651528 - aided understanding of communication, nor formulating a theory of
651529 - management.
651530 -
651531 - [On 000718 Mary Keeler reticent to support KM, because people
651532 - will not address fundamentals; commends Joe's work. ref SDS 73
651533 - 0001
651535 - ..
651536 - [On 000721 Joe advises SDS aids understanding. ref SDS 71 0002
651538 - ..
651539 - [On 000727 Joe notes again that Com Metrics provides a theory
651540 - of communication that supports a core discipline that is needed
651541 - at the university level. ref SDS 78 1S4J
651543 - ..
651544 - [On 001117 cited Joe's point in a letter on a course offering
651545 - to present a theory of knowledge, because this is a predicate
651546 - to management. ref SDS 81 TH9F
651548 - ..
651549 - Advances in fundamentals that lift civilization, like fire,
651550 - language, farming, alphabet, wheel, math, etc., are often simple,
651551 - but require a range of factors to align in order to disclose the
651552 - process and permit sufficient experience to recognize a new path,
651553 - and then to take root in the wider culture. That makes change
651554 - slow as with biological evolution. It is entirely luck. But,
651555 - when we do luck onto a promising path, responsibility to those who
651556 - came before, requires some effort to move forward.
651558 - ..
651559 - Rather than communication as the end, the objective might be
651560 - stated simply as an "engine of knowledge," or "intelligence"
651561 - process, as set out in POIMS and the NWO..., describing a
651562 - management cycle of plan, perform and report, per above.
651563 - ref SDS 0 4641
651565 - ..
651566 - Alternatively, we could by convention expand communications to be
651567 - the process. The difficulty with this is that common use is for
651568 - communication to be viewed as a selling agent, talking people into
651569 - things, getting them to say yes.
651570 -
651571 -
651572 -
651573 -
6516 -
SUBJECTS
Telecommunity for Peirce, Website
Retired May, 000501
6704 -
670501 - ..
670502 - Telecommunity Website to Promote Peirce's Philosophy
670503 -
670504 - Joe is creating a Peirce telecommunity using the listserver-based
670505 - forum and a website as the initial basis for building such a
670506 - community. Telecommunities don't just come into existence, or at least
670507 - not yet, they have to be developed. Of course there has to be a real
670508 - basis for it in people's interests -- one can't create it out of
670509 - nothing -- but it is quite clear that the basis for a vigorous
670510 - telecommunity focused around an interest in Peirce's ideas is there.
670511 - What is lacking is the initial organization work required in order to
670512 - give it enough unity for it to become autonomous. ref DRT 2 2052
670514 - ..
670515 - Experience creating and using SDS the past 15+ years, indicates
670516 - that the best way to build a data base of useful knowledge, here
670517 - on Peirce's philosophy, per above, ref SDS 0 5785, is to regularly
670518 - explain, occasions and in what manner, such ideas relate to daily
670519 - life. So, for example, if you attend a meeting, buy a car, read a
670520 - book, hear a news report, commentary, or a poem, discuss with
670521 - colleagues this or that, setting out how it relates to various
670522 - aspects of Peirce's philosophy will quickly begin to deepen
670523 - understanding, and expand application.
670524 -
670525 - [On 010114 example of SDS providing practical information to
670526 - solve problems that saves time and money. ref SDS 82 0001
670528 - ..
670529 - SDS is the only way to do this at the present time in an efficient
670530 - manner. But, you might be able to get started with MS Word or
670531 - other tools that widely available.
670533 - ..
670534 - Doug Engelbart's team at SRI proposes to create what they call an
670535 - Open Hyper-document system. They initially discussed that this
670536 - capability would support a Dynamic Knowledge Repository, which
670537 - likely would have had some SDS features to support your objective.
670538 - Getting it done has proven difficult for many people, as reported
670539 - on 000324. ref SDS 38 4877 There is a conceptual hurdle that
670540 - seems to block awareness of a useful design. Some authorities
670541 - call it a "Knowledge Management Dilemma," discussed on 000106.
670542 - ref SDS 27 1025
670543 -
670544 - [On 000718 SRI submitted proposal to NASA for funding to
670545 - create an OHS. ref SDS 72 0001
670547 - ..
670548 - SDS is hard to learn, kind of like the alphabet, although it is a
670549 - lot easier to generate and manage knowledge than other methods,
670550 - again like the alphabet. The ability to explore the record on the
670551 - web may make it easier by imparting the objective of the process,
670552 - just not sure.
670553 -
670555 - ..
670556 - Joe Retired, Focusing on Development of Peirce Telecommunity
670557 - Retirees Effective Community for Evaluating Knowledge Management
670558 - Communication Metrics Needs Senior Executives for Pilot Testing
670559 - Executive Initiative Use Seniors to Pilot Test Communication Metrics
670560 -
670561 - Follow up ref SDS 37 0005.
670562 -
670563 - Joe retired from teaching at the end of May -- he still retains an
670564 - institutional base at the university as an emeritus professor -- and
670565 - now has, for the first time, enough free time to do the sort of
670566 - development work required. The department just hired a new chairman
670567 - who is coming in both with a computer of suitable power and a
670568 - full-time computer technician who will be employed directly by the
670569 - department. Joe expects these resources can maintain department
670570 - connections independent of the central academic computing people, who
670571 - have been so unreliable that Joe had to abandon some plans altogether
670572 - because he couldn't get an adequate technical base for it. The new
670573 - chairman seems sympathetic with Joe's plans.
670575 - ..
670576 - This is a powerful asset for development work, cited in the letter
670577 - to Doug's DKR team on 000317 for pilot testing KM capability, in
670578 - my case Com Metrics using SDS. ref SDS 37 0005
670580 - ..
670581 - Joe should have the opportunity to join Doug's DKR project, in a
670582 - similar role as Henry van Eyken, who is a senior person with
670583 - background in education, rather than technology. In Joe's case,
670584 - he brings direct expertise which the team needs, and is totally
670585 - missing, although individual team members do not yet fully
670586 - appreciate it, and so channeling Joe's contribution in a way that
670587 - is effective can be a challenge. Jack Park would likely be an
670588 - ideal compliment for integrating Joe's contribution into the
670589 - technical discussion, because Jack has a foot, or at least a few
670590 - toes outside technology, per se, as seen for example by his letter
670591 - on 000221 explaining the complexities of developing a useful
670592 - ontology. ref SDS 34 8044
670594 - ..
670595 - Additionally, or alternatively, Joe might consider thinking about
670596 - the SDS effort to establish a new management science of
670597 - Communication Metrics, based on POIMS technology. Joe's stature,
670598 - contacts and expertise to discuss in conferences and in writings
670599 - Welch ideas and tools, and correlation to traditional disciplines
670600 - and practices, e.g., Peirce, but others as well, can help grow
670601 - awareness of a new kind of capability: Knowledge Management.
670603 - ..
670604 - Joe wants to start this Fall to add interactive communicational
670605 - facilities to his website, and to integrate the listserver based
670606 - discussion forum with the website. Integration is intended to lay the
670607 - groundwork for a telecommunity bound together by a common relation to
670608 - the website as a resource. The binding of people and resources is
670609 - given in the fact that people using the resource will themselves be
670610 - functioning as part of the resources insofar as this involves mutual
670611 - communication with others who are using the resources, too. Indeed,
670612 - for some, the resources will probably consist wholly of the people
670613 - accessible there, rather than the documents, though the documents have
670614 - a grounding role to play, especially those by Peirce himself, which
670615 - provide his own rather special input into the ongoing intellectual
670616 - processes occurring there or in connection with it. ref DRT 2 2050
670618 - ..
670619 - Again, the only idea I have on building a web site that will
670620 - attract and hold people is to provide a means for people to
670621 - integrate what is on the web site with their daily lives, per
670622 - above. ref SDS 0 0660
670624 - ..
670625 - Any other situation will be short term.
670627 - ..
670628 - Joe can contact Doug Engelbart and the DKR team, who envision in
670629 - their expression of a Dynamic Knowledge Repository (DKR) something
670630 - along the lines that Joe wants to accomplish. Henry van Eyken
670631 - would be an excellent contact for Joe, another would be Jack Park.
670632 -
670633 -
670634 -
6707 -
SUBJECTS
SDS Record on Web Illustrates POIMS, Com Metrics, Ransdell
SDS on Web Illustrates Usefulness of SDS, Com Metrics, 000716
Proof of Concept, 000426
7005 -
700601 - ..
700602 - SDS Record Demonstrates POIMS, Com Metrics, and Knowledge Management
700603 -
700604 - Joe indicates his goal for a Peirce website might be accomplished
700605 - through a "Knowledge Space" environment using SDS. He may comment
700606 - further after more review of the SDS record on the Internet.
700607 -
700608 - [On 000717 Joe notes SDS aids understanding. ref SDS 71 0002
700610 - ..
700611 - Joe indicates the SDS records are helpful for understanding objectives
700612 - and processes of Knowledge Space, and that it illustrates development
700613 - of a Knowledge Management system, which I call Communication Metrics.
700614 - ref DRT 2 1600
700615 -
700616 - As noted, above, Joe's objective can be supported by SDS.
700617 - ref SDS 0 0660
700619 - ..
700620 - On 971021 SDS was ported to the Internet to demonstrate POIMS
700621 - technology, and demonstrate the practices of Communication Metrics
700622 - for adding "intelligence" to management. ref SDS 13 9999
700623 -
700624 -
700625 -
700626 -
700627 -
700628 -
700629 -
700630 -
700631 -
700632 -
700633 -
700634 -
7007 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"