CONTACTS 
0201 - Bootstrap Institute
020101 - Mr. Douglas C. Engelbart, Ph.D.
0202 - Sri International
020201 - Mr. Lee Iverson
0203 - Sri International
020301 - Mr. Pat Lincoln; 650 859 5454

SUBJECTS
OHS/DKR Meeting at SRI 000518

0403 -
0403 -    ..
0404 - Summary/Objective
0405 -
040501 - Follow up ref SDS 65 0000, ref SDS 61 0000.
040502 -
040503 -
040504 -     [On 000622 received notes of the meeting from Eugene Kim.
040505 -     ref SDS 69 0001
040506 -
040507 -     [...received 2nd letter from Eugene. ref SDS 69 3304
040509 -      ..
040510 -     [On 000623 letter from Jack Park on the meeting today. ref SDS 70
040511 -     0001
040512 -
040513 -
040514 -
040515 -
040516 -
0406 -

SUBJECTS
DKR Project Staff

0503 -
0504 - Discussion
050501 -  ..
050502 - Events, Introductions - Diverse Skills Focused on DKR Project
050503 -
050504 - Follow up ref SDS 65 2079, ref SDS 61 2079.
050505 -
050506 - Doug Engelbart
050507 -
050509 -  ..
050511 -  ..
050512 - Attendance of Meetings Open
050513 -
050514 -     Eugene will discuss policy of openness for meetings with Doug.
050515 -     ref DRP 13 4662
050516 -
050517 -        [On 000814 this became moot, because meetings discontinued.
050518 -
050519 -
050520 -
050521 -
050522 -
050523 -
0506 -

SUBJECTS
Project Management
Planning, Objectives, Schedule, Budget, Agenda Issues
SRI Organizational Platform, Project Management
Management and Governance
Iverson, Lee Assigned Full Time by SRI
Lincoln, Pat (SRI) Assisting on Sponsor Outreach for Funding

1708 -
170901 -  ..
170902 - Organizational Platform Sought; SRI Aids Funding Outreach
170903 - Project "Plan" to Attract Sponsors Must Show Ability to Perform
170904 -
170905 - Follow up ref SDS 65 0784, ref SDS 61 0784.
170906 -
170907 - No discussion of Millennium project for organizational platform
170908 - discussed on 000601. ref SDS 55 1624
170910 -  ..
170911 - Pat Lincoln and Lee Iverson supporting project under SRI participation
170912 - reported during the meeting on 000601. ref SDS 55 1760
170913 - ..
170914 - Nothing tasked today on developing a schedule, budget, staff
170915 - requirements and management manual per planning on 000324, ref SDS 13
170916 - 2640, to demonstrate ability to perform, reflecting reliance on SRI
170917 - and/or other agency for organizational platform, reviewed on 000601.
170918 - ref SDS 55 1575
170920 -  ..
170921 - No progress discussed today on activities for implementing Bootstrap
170922 - strategy reviewed by Eugene Kim on 000615. ref SDS 65 9622
170923 -
170924 -
170926 -  ..
170927 - Meeting Agendas Set by Doug Engelbart; Need Schedule for Priority
170928 -
170929 - Follow up ref SDS 65 4455, ref SDS 61 4455.
170930 -
170931 - On 000531 Eugene requested suggestions of agenda issues for weekly
170932 - meetings, and recalled today receiving ideas, ref SDS 53 0001,
170933 - following up Eric Armstrong's similar request on 000407. ref SDS 19
170934 - 6554
170936 -  ..
170937 - On 000615 agendas typically controlled by progress of the work, with
170938 - priority set by the schedule and pending action items to implement the
170939 - schedule, shown in the meeting on 000324, per above. ref SDS 65 4745
170941 -  ..
170942 - No report on disposition of pending issues.
170943 - ..
170944 - This record helps develop Guide to Running Nics, per below.
170945 - ref SDS 65 3995
170946 -
170947 -
170948 -
170949 -
170950 -
170951 -
1710 -

SUBJECTS
Remote Staff Participation
Video Conferencing
Video, Audio Broadcast SRI Meetings
Video Audio Broadcast Meetings at SRI

2106 -
210701 -  ..
210702 - Video Conferencing, Audio Broadcasting DKR Meetings at SRI
210703 - DKR Project Must Transition Toward Knowledge, Away from Pictures
210704 -
210705 - Follow up ref SDS 65 5094, ref SDS 61 5094.
210706 -
210707 - No discussion on audio conferencing weekly meetings at SRI,
210708 - ref DRP 13 2115, following up discussion of this subject during the
210709 - meeting on 000608, when the matter was tabled. ref SDS 61 4757
210710 -
210711 -
210712 -
210713 -
2108 -

SUBJECTS
Bootstrap Strategies, 000227
Open Source
Pilot Test Prototype Methods Using Project Record
Bootstrap Strategy Pilot Test Prototype KM with Project Record

2406 -
240701 -  ..
240702 - Bootstrap Development Strategy Requires Scheduling Tasks
240703 -
240704 - Follow up ref SDS 65 9622, ref SDS 47 3604.
240705 -
240706 - Bootstrap strategy from meeting on 000615 extended today for adding
240707 - "catagories" to Augment that produces OHS v0.1, per below. ref SDS 0
240708 - 6652
240710 -  ..
240711 - No discussion on developing XML schemes to generate html automatically
240712 - and build in the features Doug wants, reviewed on 000615. ref SDS 65
240713 - 8400
240715 -  ..
240716 - No report on progress using existing DTD Howard has found for
240717 - (meeting???) Minutes.
240718 -
240719 -
240720 -
240721 -
240722 -
2408 -

SUBJECTS
OHS Primary Objective, Doug, Marcello, 000601
Organizational Platform, Millennium, Doug
Management and Governance
Fellows Program, Doug
DKRs Build, Doug, Marcello, 000601
Organizational Platform, 000601
Fellows Program, Doug, Marcello, 000601
SRI Organizational Platform, Project Management, 000419
Vector Task Priorities, 000601
Millennium Project Organizational Platform, 000601

3612 -
361301 -  ..
361302 - Vector Sets OHS as Foundation of Project
361303 - Organization (Platform) Needed to Take Over Project Operations
361304 - Follows Program Invites Prominent People to Address SRI Team
361305 -
361306 - Follow up ref SDS 65 3855, ref SDS 61 3855.
361307 -
361308 - Progress on vectors set by Doug on 000601...
361309 -
361310 -    1.  OHS is foundation of the project effort so far, reported vector
361311 -        on 000601. ref SDS 55 3855
361313 -         ..
361314 -        Schedule, budget and staffing, see above, ref SDS 0 4745, and
361315 -        Bootstrap strategy that proposed on 000615 particular tasks to
361316 -        be performed. ref SDS 65 9622
361317 -        ..
361318 -        On 000615 Team decided to focus on OHS, and defer
361319 -        consideration of DKR. ref SDS 65 6271
361321 -         ..
361322 -        Architecture discussed today...
361324 -         ..
361325 -        Augment plus catagories proposed for OHS v0.1, needs review of
361326 -        CDS requirements v0.9 prepared by Eric, and adopted on 000615
361327 -        as OHS requirements, ref SDS 65 2808, no review today, no
361328 -        schedule for review, per below. ref SDS 0 2808
361330 -         ..
361331 -        Progress today on email enhancements, per below, ref SDS 0 2760
361332 -        continue work on use cases, ref SDS 65 4933, and begin pilot
361333 -        test Wiki for prototype DKR to improve collaboration.
361334 -        ref SDS 65 9000
361335 -        ..
361336 -        No progress reviewing starter technologies, per action
361337 -        items proposed on 000601, ref SDS 55 3855, from meeting on
361338 -        000525, see below, ref SDS 65 4084, except, major step forward
361339 -        on using Wiki for enhancing email collaboration, per below.
361340 -        ref SDS 65 9000
361341 -
361342 -        ..
361343 -    2.  Finding an organization that will take over operational
361344 -        support.
361346 -         ..
361347 -        No progress reported on this vector.
361348 -
361350 -         ..
361351 -    3.  Building the DKRs. ref SDS 55 2200
361352 -
361353 -        Discussion OHS architecture today, may lead to DKRs.
361355 -         ..
361356 -        Per decision on 000615 to concentrate on OHS, ref SDS 65 6271,
361357 -        no progress on Jack Parks recommendation on 000426 to explain
361358 -        scope and purpose of a DKR, ref SDS 30 2340, based on record of
361359 -        meeting on 000518 explaining "knowledge," ref SDS 48 3528, and
361360 -        Marcello Hoffman's suggestion on 000601 to identify a "hook" to
361361 -        attract funding sponsors. ref SDS 55 4080
361362 -        ..
361363 -        Progress on management issues to pilot test Wiki for
361364 -        prototype DKR to enhance email collaboration, per below.
361365 -        ref SDS 0 9000
361367 -         ..
361368 -    4.  Fellows program. ref SDS 55 5644
361369 -
361370 -        No discussion on this vector today.
361371 -
361372 -
361373 -
361374 -
3614 -

SUBJECTS
Sponsor/Stakeholder Planning
Hoffman, Marcello
Lincoln, Pat
Funding Trip to Washington, Need Support for Open Source
Finance Requires Proof of Concept, 000601
High Tech Tourism, Fear Blocks Funding, 000601
SDS Proof of Concept DKR Knowledge Space, Jack Park, 000426
Proof of Concept, 000426
SRI Spin-Off
DARPA; DOD; Sun Microsystems
Mozilla
Gnutella

5214 -
521501 -  ..
521502 - Sponsors Looking for Projects in Knowledge Management
521503 -
521504 - Follow up ref SDS 65 4877, ref SDS 61 4877.
521505 -
521506 - Doug Engelbart and Pat Lincoln did not attend the meeting today, as a
521507 - result of being in Washington or other locals presenting the DKR story
521508 - to gain sponsor support.
521509 -
521511 -     ..
521512 -    Mozilla Enthused About OHS
521513 -    Gnutella Presentation Can be Scheduled
521514 -
521515 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 4868, ref SDS 61 4868.
521516 -
521517 -    No follow up today on developing collaboration with Mozilla on OHS
521518 -    project.
521520 -     ..
521521 -    No report on scheduling A Gnutella presentation for one of our
521522 -    meetings, suggested at the meeting on 000615. ref SDS 65 4868
521523 -
521525 -     ..
521526 -    Doug/Pat Presentations for DARPA on Using Internet
521527 -    SPC Workshop for DARPA on Applying Internet; Doug/Pat to Present
521528 -
521529 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 1760, ref SDS 61 1760.
521530 -
521531 -    No report on Doug and Pat presenting last week at workshop in
521532 -    Washington D.C. for DARPA.
521534 -     ..
521535 -    No discussion on notifying DARPA about ability to use the Net for
521536 -    Knowledge Management that adds "intelligence" to daily meetings,
521537 -    calls and other tasks, that supports Enterprise Management model,
521538 -    commonly called a virtual or paperless office, submitted to the
521539 -    project team in a letter, ref DIP 3 0001, on 000606, ref SDS 60
521540 -    0001, applying ideas presented to the team on 000518. ref SDS 48
521541 -    3528
521542 -
521544 -     ..
521545 -    DOD Contacted Doug on DKR Opportunities
521546 -
521547 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 9702, ref SDS 61 9702.
521548 -
521549 -    No report on follow up about email Doug received from the Senior
521550 -    Advisor to the Secretary of Defense who is interested in scaling up
521551 -    the Department of Defense's improvement infrastructure. ref DRP 12
521552 -    1360
521553 -
521555 -     ..
521556 -    Sun Needs OHS Long Term, Wants Better Hardware Design Tools
521557 -
521558 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 0752, ref SDS 61 0752.
521559 -
521560 -    No report submitted on results of meeting Doug and Pat had with Sun
521561 -    to discuss how OHS can help solve problem of hardware design
521562 -    software.  Report on 000608 indicated Sun needs is better
521563 -    interaction between software and hardware design tools; and in the
521564 -    long term, Sun can use the OHS.
521566 -     ..
521567 -    How does the OHS need to be shaped to support Sun's objectives?
521568 -
521570 -     ..
521571 -    Demo Project Deliverable Aids Sponsor Outreach
521572 -    Funding Requires Initial Project Development
521573 -
521574 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 6821, ref SDS 61 6821.
521575 -
521576 -    Augment demo and proposed video to attract sponsor interest, no
521577 -    report on progress, per below. ref SDS 0 9626
521579 -     ..
521580 -    Wiki pilot test of prototype DKR provides beginning of mock up to
521581 -    demo project deliverables, per below. ref SDS 0 9000
521582 -
521584 -     ..
521585 -    Funding Requires Proof of Concept, Not High Tech "Tourism"
521586 -
521587 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 1007, ref SDS 61 1007.
521588 -
521589 -    No discussion today on developing prototype capability for
521590 -    demonstrating better software programming by providing multiple
521591 -    views, and email with addressability, per above, ref SDS 61 6821,
521592 -    recognizes Marcello's recommendation on 000601 that getting funded
521593 -    requires demonstrating useful tools rather than high-tech tourism.
521594 -    ref SDS 55 1007
521596 -     ..
521597 -    No discussion today on implementing Knowledge Management based on
521598 -    report by professor Mary Keeler at the meeting on 000518, showing a
521599 -    development path to transition from documents to Knowledge Space,
521600 -    ref SDS 48 2808, cited by Jack Park on 000426 that SDS provides
521601 -    proof of concept for aspects of a DKR.
521602 -    ..
521603 -    Pilot test of Wiki DKR provides beginning of prototype to
521604 -    demo project deliverables, per discussion on 000615. ref SDS 65
521605 -    3729 Below, progress reported on developing Wiki DKR. ref SDS 0
521606 -    9000
521608 -     ..
521609 -    OHS concept of integrating Augment and catagories provides new
521610 -    development path.  ref SDS 0 9626
521611 -
521612 -
521613 -
521614 -
521615 -
5217 -

SUBJECTS
Purpose DKR
Summary Project for Funding Presentation
Lincoln, Pat
Summary Project Support Government Funding, Pat, 000601
Government Agencies, Funding Outreach
Project Summary
Stringer, Warren

6009 -
601001 -     ..
601002 -    Summarize Project Support Funding Inquiries for DKR
601003 -
601004 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 0852, ref SDS 61 0852.
601005 -
601006 -    No submission by Pat Lincoln on project summaries prepared from
601007 -    member input for attracting sponsor funding, as planned during
601008 -    meeting at SRI on 000608. ref SDS 61 8528
601010 -     ..
601011 -    No correlation reported with KM developed on 000518, as engine of
601012 -    DKR project. ref SDS 55 2808
601014 -     ..
601015 -    No report on "hook" formulated to attract sponsor funding, cited by
601016 -    Marcello Hoffmann on 000601. ref SDS 55 4080
601017 -
601019 -     ..
601020 -    Audience for Sponsor Funding is Government Agencies
601021 -
601022 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 4896, ref SDS 61 4896.
601023 -
601024 -    No discussion on tailoring project summary for funding to audience
601025 -    of government agencies, per agreement at the meeting last week.
601026 -    ref SDS 55 4896
601027 -
601028 -
601029 -
6011 -

SUBJECTS
Software Programming Program Initial Product, 000406
Software Programming Multiple Views, Doug, 000601
Comments Only; Code Only - No Comments, 000608
Functions Only; Call Trees; Object Hierarchies, 000608
Collapsible Blocks; Context Highlighting; Change Logs, 000608
Improved Context Highlighting for Software Programming, 000608
Storyboard Design Features, 000608
Prototype Requested Software Programming Features, 000608
Software Programming Multiple Views, Doug, 000601
IP Protection Built into Architecture, Journaling, Lee Iverson, 000608
Prototype Software Programming Multiple Views, Doug, 000608

8313 -
831401 -  ..
831402 - Software Programming Multiple Views, Storyboard Features
831403 - Programmers Initial Target Community Supports Bootstrapping
831404 -
831405 - Follow up ref SDS 65 7238, ref SDS 61 7238.
831406 -
831407 - No report on storyboard work begun on 000608, and Doug's request for
831408 - schedule on prototype. ref SDS 61 7238 and ref SDS 61 4810
831410 -  ..
831411 - On 000608 team may have adopted priority to focus initially on email
831412 - to provide addressability. ref SDS 61 2760
831414 -  ..
831415 - No discussion of Eric Armstrong's letter on 000614 deferring work on
831416 - software programming improvements. ref SDS 64 5826
831417 -
831418 -
831419 -
831420 -
831421 -
831422 -
8315 -

SUBJECTS
Engelbart, Doug
Objective OHS Development Vector, Doug, 000405
Editor Development
Procedures and Tools Transcoding, IBM's WBI, 000324
Schedule for OHS Development Vector, Doug, 000405
Email Hyperdocuments Integrate
Email Improves with Links, Doug Sets for Team, 000405
Email XML Seed Team Use What is Available, 000302
Backlink Management, 000608

9811 -
981201 -  ..
981202 - Anchors Addressability Archived Record Demonstrate Capability
981203 - Backlink Management Developed by Doug's Colleague
981204 - Email Addressability Needed to Aid Project, Demonstrate Progress
981205 -
981206 - Follow up ref SDS 65 2760, ref SDS 61 2760.
981207 -
981208 - Progress today on enhancing email to supplement software tools as
981209 - "hooks" for attracting project sponsors, set as priority objective on
981210 - 000601. ref SDS 55 0852
981212 -  ..
981213 - Discussed adding anchors for addressability requested by Doug at the
981214 - meeting on 000601, ref SDS 55 2760, based on pilot test prototype DKR
981215 - using Wiki explained below. ref SDS 0 3729
981216 -
981217 -     [On 000623 received letter from Jack Park explaining planning to
981218 -     add anchors to documents. ref SDS 70 5475
981219 - ..
981220 - No progress reported on questions from 000608. ref SDS 61 5510
981222 -  ..
981223 - Doug may report at next meeting on a possible visit with Conklin about
981224 - backlink management, while in D.C. this week. ref SDS 61 4725
981225 -
981226 -
981227 -
981228 -
9813 -

SUBJECTS
Development Separate Forum from Objectives and Needs to Solve World P
Email Separate Forum for Development from Discussion World Problems
Email Forum Develop OHS DKR
SourceForge Server, Email Development, Eugene, 000608

A406 -
A40701 -  ..
A40702 - SourceForge Email List for OHS Development
A40703 - Separate Mailing List on Development of OHS, Possibly SourceForge
A40704 -
A40705 - Follow up ref SDS 65 5985, ref SDS 61 5985.
A40706 -
A40707 - Eugene explained one reason the project is not yet registered on
A40708 - SourceForge and do not have a separate mailing list for development,
A40709 - is that SourceForge requires an open source license.  Once that is
A40710 - accomplished, the DKR project can use SourceForge. Our target date for
A40711 - committing to a license 000706, reported on 000608. ref SDS 61 6150
A40712 - Eugene plans to submit information on licensing, this weekend, per his
A40713 - letter today. ref DRP 15 0001
A40714 -
A40715 -     [...in another record Eugene's letter received. ref SDS 69 3304
A40716 - ..
A40717 - Need to work out details coordinating email on SourceForge with
A40718 - Wiki set up by Lee on 000615, that generates a project record.
A40719 - ref SDS 65 3729
A40720 -
A40721 -     [On 010405 Jack Park's OHS project identified as Nexist hosted by
A40722 -     SourceForce under open source license. ref SDS 80 A13H
A40723 -
A40724 -
A40725 -
A40726 -
A40727 -
A40728 -
A40729 -
A408 -

SUBJECTS
Sun Microsystems Donated Server Space
Sponsor Outreach, Support, 000324
Web Site Server Vendor
Engelbart, Doug

AC06 -
AC0701 -  ..
AC0702 - Server Space for DKR Donated by Sun Microsystems
AC0703 -
AC0704 - Follow up ref SDS 65 5962, ref SDS 61 5962.
AC0705 -
AC0706 - No report of progress using server donated by Sun, per Eric's letter
AC0707 - on 00042, ref SDS 25 0001
AC0708 -
AC0709 -
AC0710 -
AC0711 -
AC0712 -
AC08 -

SUBJECTS
Property Rights in Knowledge Organization
Commercial Viability
Ownership Investment Risk
Development Investment Risk
Open Source Evaluation
SRI Not Convinced Open Source Best Strategy
Engelbart Convinced Open Source Best Strategy
Study Needed Demonstrate Open Source Best Strategy, 000601
Open Source Study Develop Facts on Viability, Doug
Open Source Other OHS/DKR Type Projects, 000601, Doug
Open Source Study Viability OHS/DKR, Engelbart, Doug, 000601
Management Cannot Make Assignments
Authority, Leadership, Project Management
Open Source Similar Empowerment, Not Authority, No Responsibility
Accountability Essential Needs Authority, Open Source, Empowerment, D

AT17 -
AT1801 -  ..
AT1802 - Legal Issues Arising from Open Source and Sponsor Support
AT1803 -
AT1804 - Follow up ref SDS 65 3055, ref SDS 61 3055.
AT1805 -
AT1806 - There was no discussion on getting a license or other standing
AT1807 - required to operate, noted at the meeting on 000330, ref SDS 16 3995,
AT1808 - possibly reflecting SRI will provide organizational platform, reported
AT1809 - 000420, ref SDS 24 6630, and Lee Iverson assigned full-time by SRI
AT1810 - 000504. ref SDS 37 7743
AT1812 -  ..
AT1813 - There was no discussion about licensing issues discussed on 000324,
AT1814 - ref SDS 13 3055, nor of submission on 000421, by Eric Armstrong of
AT1815 - license ideas ref SDS 25 3055, nor of Paul Fernhout's submission on
AT1816 - 000513 proposing new ideas on licensing. ref SDS 44 0001
AT1817 - ..
AT1818 - Eugene expects to submit this weekend a summary of issues for
AT1819 - consideration in reaching agreement on open source license by 000706,
AT1820 - per planning on 000608, ref SDS 61 6150, and reported in his letter.
AT1821 - ref DRP 15 0001
AT1822 -
AT1823 -     [...in another record received letter from Eugene on schedule for
AT1824 -     submitting open source license ideas. ref SDS 69 2016
AT1826 -      ..
AT1827 -     [On 000802 open source license proposal received. ref SDS 75 0001
AT1829 -     ..
AT1830 -    No other discussion today.
AT1831 -
AT1832 -
AT1834 -     ..
AT1835 -    Open Source Evidence Showing Viability of Development Strategy
AT1836 -    Study Cost Benefits of Open Source
AT1837 -    Management Assignments Difficult to Make under Open Source
AT1838 -
AT1839 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 1976, ref SDS 61 1976.
AT1840 -
AT1841 -    No progress on study requested by Doug Engelbart on 000601 to
AT1842 -    evaluate open source strategy for OHS/DKR. ref SDS 55 1976
AT1843 -
AT1844 -
AT1845 -
AT1846 -
AT1847 -
AT19 -

SUBJECTS
Knowledge Define, Distinguish Data, Information
Collective IQ
Lessons Learned, Case Studies Root Cause Analysis
Giving Up on Knowledge Management, 000615
OHS Uses CDS Requirements, 000615
DKR Difficult Architecture, Hard to Design, Not Understood
Dilemma Industry Doesn't Know How to Design KM

B309 -
B31001 -  ..
B31002 - DKR Project Knowledge Management Objective, Beginning with OHS
B31003 - OHS Same as CDS Requirements Prepared by Eric Armstrong
B31004 -
B31005 - Follow up ref SDS 65 2808, ref SDS 61 2808.
B31006 -
B31007 - No discussion on using CDS requirements v0.9 for OHS; however,
B31008 - progress on understanding knowledge management by adding catagories to
B31009 - Augment, per below. ref SDS 0 6652
B31011 -  ..
B31012 - This may solve concern cited during meeting on 000615. ref SDS 65 6271
B31013 -
B31014 -        [...in another record letter commends project team for solving
B31015 -        KM dilemma. ref SDS 69 3780
B31017 -     ..
B31018 -    Knowledge Management Definition
B31019 -
B31020 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 5555, ref SDS 61 5555.
B31021 -
B31022 -    There was no discussion of new information received at the meeting
B31023 -    on 000518 showing that Knowledge Management provides a unique path
B31024 -    to develop a DKR using an experiential record to improve human
B31025 -    memory that justifies funding, and that Doug's seed team may be
B31026 -    uniquely qualified to perform the work, responding to Marcello's
B31027 -    explanation on 000601 urging that the team avoid "high-tech
B31028 -    tourism." ref SDS 55 1007
B31030 -     ..
B31031 -    There was no discussion of Eric Armstrong's explanation on 000423
B31032 -    that the purpose of the DKR is to augment human intelligence,
B31033 -    reviewed recently on 000517. ref SDS 47 0585
B31034 -
B31035 -
B31036 -
B31037 -
B31038 -
B311 -

SUBJECTS
OHS Open Hyperdocument System
OHS Editor XML, Requirements, Specs
Engineering Management
Atomic Data Structures, 000423
Specification
Collaborative Document System Email Core Capability DKR, Eric, 000505
DKR Data Structures, 000423
OHS = Augment + Catagories, IBIS Supported, Eugene 000622
IBIS Catagories for Question, Answer, etc Tracked by OHS, Eugene 0006
Links Nodes Comprise OHS System, IBIS Supported, Eugene 000622
Structured Discussion IBIS Catatories, Eugene Kim, 000622
IBIS Conversation Linking on Nodes
Knowledge Representation, 000405
Structured Notes, 000504
Structured Notes, Discussion

BT17 -
BT1801 -     ..
BT1802 -    OHS Editor Based on XML Initial Project Deliverable
BT1803 -    Collaborative Document System and OHS Supported by Editor
BT1804 -    CDS Change to OHS; Requirements Need Review by Project Team
BT1805 -
BT1806 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 5880, ref SDS 61 5880.
BT1807 -
BT1808 -    No discussion of Eugene's proposal on 000615 to change the name of
BT1809 -    CDS to OHS. ref SDS 65 2808
BT1811 -     ..
BT1812 -    No record of project review for specs v0.6, ref DRP 6 0001, issued
BT1813 -    on 000508, ref SDS 39 0782, reviewed in depth on 000505.
BT1814 -    ref SDS 38 0782, and updated by Eric on 000605. ref SDS 59 0782
BT1815 -    ..
BT1816 -    Review will identify initial development scope, and support
BT1817 -    resolution of KM difficulties reported above. ref SDS 65 6271
BT1818 -
BT1819 -       Use case discussed below does not address Requirements.
BT1820 -       ref SDS 65 4933
BT1822 -     ..
BT1823 -    Augment + Catagories = OHS v0.1; IBIS Support Proposed
BT1824 -    OHS v0.1 = Augment + Catagories; Comprised of Links and Nodes
BT1825 -    Architecture Links and Nodes Comprise Core OHS System for DKR
BT1826 -
BT1827 -    Discussion today indicated the OHS system consists of two things:
BT1828 -    nodes and links. The difference between our system and the previous
BT1829 -    two revisions of Doug's work on Augment is that our system allows
BT1830 -    us to categorize nodes. Categorizing nodes is crucial, because it
BT1831 -    provides an additional semantic layer that is crucial for knowledge
BT1832 -    management.  Both the users of the system and the system itself can
BT1833 -    take advantage of this additional layer, per Eugene's letter on
BT1834 -    results of the meeting today. ref DRP 14 0001
BT1835 -
BT1836 -        [...Eugnee's letter received today. ref SDS 69 0001
BT1838 -         ..
BT1839 -        [...in another record letter commends project team for solving
BT1840 -        KM dilemma. ref SDS 69 3780
BT1842 -         ..
BT1843 -        [On 000711 SRI reports pre-proposal to NASA for 3 year project
BT1844 -        to develop OHS. ref SDS 72 0001
BT1846 -         ..
BT1847 -        [On 000718 pre-proposal to NASA does not cite catagories.
BT1848 -        ref SDS 73 2166
BT1850 -         ..
BT1851 -        [On 060129 Jeff Conklin developed IBIS; he introduced himself
BT1852 -        at an event for Doug Engelbart's 81st birthday at Stanford.
BT1853 -        ref SDS 82 7H7G
BT1855 -     ..
BT1856 -    This is a significant breakthrough, solving concern voiced during
BT1857 -    the meeting last week on 000615 that knowledge" and "knowledge
BT1858 -    management" were too difficult to understand. ref SDS 65 6271
BT1859 -
BT1860 -    "Document" and "node" were discussed without agreement, per Jack
BT1861 -    Park's letter on 000623. ref DRP 16 5934
BT1862 -
BT1863 -        [...in another record letter comments that "nodes" are not
BT1864 -        defined; information is more useful with structure. ref SDS 69
BT1865 -        5022
BT1867 -         ..
BT1868 -        [On 000623 Jack's letter received. ref SDS 70 5826
BT1870 -     ..
BT1871 -    To support IBIS-style discussions, OHS can have categories such as
BT1872 -    "question," "answer," and "alternatives."  This permits searching
BT1873 -    for all the questions pertaining to a particular topic of
BT1874 -    discussion.  Or, can write a system module that automatically
BT1875 -    compiles and presents an IBIS view based on the current question
BT1876 -    and answer nodes. ref DRP 14 3780
BT1877 -
BT1878 -        Aligns with Eric's letter on 000614 proposing reliance on IBIS
BT1879 -        system. ref SDS 64 4939
BT1881 -         ..
BT1882 -        [On 000630 Jack Park supports IBIS for using DKR to support
BT1883 -        scholarly argument for growing knowledge base. ref SDS 71 2040
BT1884 -
BT1886 -     ..
BT1887 -    Structured Discussion by Catagorizing Nodes
BT1888 -
BT1889 -    Categorizing nodes allows us to provide some structure to
BT1890 -    discussion, even if the discussion itself is unstructured.  For
BT1891 -    example, if we're trying to come up with a Use Cases document for a
BT1892 -    piece of software, five different Use Cases may be proposed in
BT1893 -    three different e-mails. However, if these nodes are properly
BT1894 -    categorized in each node, then a Use Cases view can be easily be
BT1895 -    called that shows all of the Use Cases in one view, regardless of
BT1896 -    when or where these were proposed. ref DRP 14 5120
BT1897 -
BT1898 -        This aligns with Eugene's planning for a DKR submitted on
BT1899 -        000504. ref SDS 36 6205
BT1900 -        ..
BT1901 -        On 000221 Jack Park related research showing that
BT1902 -        ontology, which is a kind of catagory system, entails a
BT1903 -        Pandora's Box of effort; may need review. ref SDS 10 7455
BT1905 -         ..
BT1906 -        [...in another record recommend presentation on developing
BT1907 -        useful catagories. ref SDS 69 4560
BT1909 -         ..
BT1910 -        [...in another record letter comments that "nodes" are not
BT1911 -        defined; information is more useful with structure. ref SDS 69
BT1912 -        5022
BT1914 -         ..
BT1915 -        [On 000623 Jack proposes concensus ontology. ref SDS 70 9900
BT1917 -     ..
BT1918 -    Are links categorizable?  This relates to some of Eric's previous
BT1919 -    questions regarding relationships on 000601 submitting v0.7 for CDS
BT1920 -    (OHS) specs. ref SDS 56 5933, particularly explaining "relations."
BT1921 -    ref SDS 56 0950  Eugene feels a link is the way you represent a
BT1922 -    relationship, and so a user should be able to specify categories
BT1923 -    for a link. ref DRP 14 6424
BT1925 -     ..
BT1926 -    Knoware, demonstrated by Gil Regev last week, ref SDS 65 6864,
BT1927 -    allows labeling relationships.  It should be fairly easy to give
BT1928 -    those labels meaning in the OHS, which is one of the things Gil
BT1929 -    said he planned on doing. ref DRP 14 3224
BT1930 -
BT1932 -     ..
BT1933 -    Atomic Data Structures Derive from Fundamental Information Unit
BT1934 -    Fundamental Information Unit Focuses DKR Design Effort
BT1935 -
BT1936 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 4004, ref SDS 61 4004.
BT1937 -
BT1938 -    No evident discussion today of Joe Williams comprehensive
BT1939 -    presentation on 000420 of DKR and OHS framework. ref SDS 24 4004
BT1941 -     ..
BT1942 -    No discussion of atomic data structures submitted by Eric on
BT1943 -    000423. ref SDS 28 4977
BT1945 -     ..
BT1946 -    No discussion of Paul Fernhout's submission on 000524 about
BT1947 -    Pointrel Data Repository based on Python. ref SDS 49 0783
BT1948 -    ..
BT1949 -    No discussion nor schedule to review data structures
BT1950 -    submitted by Eric Armstrong with v0.8 of Requirements, on 000605.
BT1951 -    ref SDS 59 6984
BT1952 -
BT1953 -
BT1954 -
BT1955 -
BT20 -

SUBJECTS
Use Case Method Define Requirement, 00000000
Software Programming Program, Use Case Analysis, 000406
Use Case Email Prototype, Eugene, 000608
Use Case Prototype Email Addressability, Eugene, 000608

C006 -
C00701 -     ..
C00702 -    Mind Maps, Concept Graphs Facilitate Use Case Analysis
C00703 -    Use Case Methods for Software Design and Email Addressability
C00704 -
C00705 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 4933, ref SDS 61 4933.
C00706 -
C00707 -    Discussion above, ref SDS 0 6652, follows up Eugene Kim's
C00708 -    comprehensive submission on 000504 suggesting the scope of OHS, and
C00709 -    detailing specific use cases that improve literacy, supported by
C00710 -    Jack Park. ref SDS 36 0784
C00712 -     ..
C00713 -    Last week the team planned for the meeting this week to go through
C00714 -    use cases and come up with targets for prototyping deliverables...
C00715 -             ..
C00716 -             Software multiple views, ref SDS 61 4933
C00718 -              ..
C00719 -             Email enhancement, per above. ref SDS 65 2760
C00721 -     ..
C00722 -    Today, Eugene noted that purpose of Use Cases is to describe from
C00723 -    very high level black box point of view. ref DRP 13 1178
C00724 -
C00725 -            [On 000623 report Eugene did a great job developing use
C00726 -            cases during meeting on 000622; no indication of reliance
C00727 -            on project record. ref SDS 70 5826
C00728 -    ..
C00729 -    No discussion of relying on a definition of "knowledge" that
C00730 -    is set out in the project record, nor example provided of intuitive
C00731 -    meaning of knowledge proposed during the meeting on 000615 for
C00732 -    developing KM use cases. ref SDS 65 0051
C00733 -
C00734 -
C00735 -
C00736 -
C00737 -
C008 -

SUBJECTS
Glossary, Engelbart, Doug, 000518

C403 -
C40401 -  ..
C40402 - Glossary Establishes DKR Culture, Supports Architecture for KM
C40403 -
C40404 - Follow up ref SDS 65 5783, ref SDS 61 5783.
C40405 -
C40406 - No review of ground rules proposed on 000615 for using and improving
C40407 - the glossary.
C40408 -
C40409 -
C40410 -
C40411 -
C40412 -
C405 -

SUBJECTS
Augment, Doug Engelbart's System at SRI Beginning in 1960s
Augment Human Capabilities
Engelbart, Doug
Augment Presentation, Engelbart, Iverson, Williams, Yee, 000420
Augment NLS Video Review, 000622
Augment/NLS, 000124
Armstrong, Eric Reviews Vidoe Tape Augment NLS

CE09 -
CE1001 -  ..
CE1002 - Augment Project at SRI in 1960s Sets Design Objectives
CE1003 -
CE1004 - Follow up ref SDS 65 5992, ref SDS 61 5992.
CE1005 -
CE1006 - Background...
CE1007 -
CE1008 -    On 000125 Eri's letter requested information on Augment for the DKR
CE1009 -    design. ref SDS 7 0738
CE1011 -     ..
CE1012 -    On 000601 Eric asked for a description of Augment data structures
CE1013 -    to expedite requirements for email system, ref SDS 55 5992, set
CE1014 -    above, as project top priority, ref SDS 61 2760, as a predicate or
CE1015 -    concurrent with prototype software multiple views. ref SDS 61 7238
CE1017 -     ..
CE1018 -    Augment can expedite developing work product for funding, per
CE1019 -    Marcello Hoffman's report on 000601, ref SDS 55 3824, and Doug's
CE1020 -    call for a prototype to demonstrate project objectives. ref SDS 61
CE1021 -    7238
CE1023 -     ..
CE1024 -    Earlier on 000330 Marcello reported that his research shows nobody
CE1025 -    has developed a Knowledge Management capability, and that Doug has
CE1026 -    a strong solution in Augment, which gives the DKR team an
CE1027 -    advantage. ref SDS 16 0713 and ref SDS 16 2075
CE1029 -     ..
CE1030 -    On 000426 Jack Park reported that Augment sets stage for DKR
CE1031 -    project, SDS on the Internet provides proof of concept for some
CE1032 -    aspects of a DKR. ref SDS 30 3315
CE1034 -     ..
CE1035 -    On 000608 Augment demonstrated. ref SDS 61 4180
CE1036 -
CE1037 -
CE1039 -  ..
CE1040 - Augment Shows OHS/DKR Objectives; Powerful, Difficult to Learn
CE1041 -
CE1042 - Follow up ref SDS 65 9626.
CE1043 -
CE1044 - No report on date for viewing Augment video, nor on preparing new
CE1045 - Augment video, since Doug is out of town.
CE1047 -  ..
CE1048 - Eric has a review dated today of Augment NLS video tape to develop OHS
CE1049 - requirements. ref DRT 1 0001  Doug demonstrated Augment NLS at SRI on
CE1050 - 000608. ref SDS 61 4180  Eric's review located at...
CE1051 -
CE1052 -        http://www.treelight.com/software/bootstrap/NLS_video.html
CE1053 -
CE1054 -          [On 040123 Gary Johnson submits correction to location of
CE1055 -          Eric's report. ref SDS 81 U58K
CE1056 -
CE1057 - ...comments....
CE1058 -
CE1059 -        This is a system that authors love, because it is abbreviated
CE1060 -        and powerful. They grew with the system, adding complexity
CE1061 -        little by little.  New users find it confusing and difficult to
CE1062 -        remember -- not to mention unreadable.  This limits the user
CE1063 -        base. ref DRT 1 2992
CE1065 -  ..
CE1066 - Augment is a prototype, like the first airplane, steam engine,
CE1067 - telephone and so on.
CE1068 -
CE1069 -     [On 000824 Eric reports on meeting held 000822 where Doug
CE1070 -     presented an architecture that puts Augment's view-control
CE1071 -     commands into a very central position in the OHS. ref SDS 76 546O
CE1073 -      ..
CE1074 -     [On 000825 Brian Lincoln explains some of the history of Augment
CE1075 -     NLS, and comments on planning for developing an OHS/DKR based on
CE1076 -     Augment NLS and Doug's ideas from the prior experience in the
CE1077 -     1960s. ref SDS 77 4T3N
CE1079 -      ..
CE1080 -     [On 001010 Sheldon developing lense application for mouse that
CE1081 -     accomplishes some Augment efficiencies. ref SDS 78 G8R3
CE1083 -      ..
CE1084 -     [On 001130 Eric comments on Augment again. ref SDS 79 0001  Paul
CE1085 -     Fernout feels Augment very advanced for when it was developed.
CE1086 -     ref SDS 79 5350  Paul says Doug is correct to promote productivity
CE1087 -     over ease of use. ref SDS 79 GY3R
CE1088 -
CE1089 -
CE1091 -  ..
CE1092 - Augment Needs Review for Data Structures Incorporate into OHS
CE1093 -
CE1094 - There was no discussion on Augment data structures requested by Eric
CE1095 - on 000601. ref SDS 55 0672
CE1096 -
CE1097 - Eugene will organize a viewing of the NLS video at SRI, probably on a
CE1098 - weekend day. ref DRP 13 9240
CE1100 -  ..
CE1101 - Team needs to decide about level of effort to invest on these action
CE1102 - items based on Eric's review. ref SDS 0 5720
CE1103 -
CE1104 -
CE1105 -
CE1106 -
CE1107 -
CE1108 -
CE12 -

SUBJECTS
CODIAK Intelligence Capabilities
Guide to Running Nics, 000427

CJ04 -
CJ0501 -  ..
CJ0502 - Guide to Running NICs Gathers Intelligence, Provides Feedback
CJ0503 - Communication Manager Proposed to Compliment Tools for DKR
CJ0504 -
CJ0505 - Follow up ref SDS 65 3995, ref SDS 61 3995.
CJ0506 -
CJ0507 - Nothing has been submitted responding to the request on 000428 for
CJ0508 - more information on the Guide to Running NICs, ref DRP 3 3000,
CJ0509 - proposed at the meeting on 000427. ref SDS 32 2867
CJ0510 - ..
CJ0511 - No record of work product showing contradictions and prodding of
CJ0512 - contributors to grow knowledge repository's capabilities as we use it,
CJ0513 - also proposed on 000427. ref SDS 32 2867
CJ0514 -
CJ0515 -
CJ0516 -
CJ0517 -
CJ0518 -
CJ0519 -
CJ0520 -
CJ06 -

SUBJECTS
WBI Transcoding Vector
WBI 3 Tier Server Architecture, 000427
DirectDom, JDOM Processors of XML DKR, 000427
WBI Vector Presentation, Engelbart, 000420
Iverson, Lee
Source Development System (SDS) Transcoding, 000511
SDS Source Development System Transcoding, 000511
Hitchiker's Guide To The Galaxy, DKR Example, 000615
Other DKR Projects Trying to Create OHS

CW11 -
CW1201 -  ..
CW1202 - Current Proposal for DKR Transcoding - Complex Process
CW1203 - Architecture - Three-Tier Server for WBI Implementation
CW1204 -
CW1205 - Follow up ref SDS 65 4674, ref SDS 61 4674.
CW1206 -
CW1208 -     ..
CW1209 -    Eugene and Rod Have DKR Systems
CW1210 -    Hitchiker's Guide To The Galaxy Good Example DKR
CW1211 -
CW1212 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 4194.
CW1213 -
CW1214 -    No planning to review prototype DKR systems reported on 000615.
CW1215 -
CW1217 -     ..
CW1218 -    Fundamental Issues of DKR Project Focused by DOM
CW1219 -    DOM (Document Object Model) Uses XML for Doc Management
CW1220 -
CW1221 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 3640, ref SDS 61 3640.
CW1222 -
CW1223 -    No discussion on DOM and DDOM issue; nor, of W3C being ineffective
CW1224 -    for data base; Python and Java supporting DOM for data base,
CW1225 -    reported on 000504. ref SDS 37 3994
CW1226 -
CW1228 -     ..
CW1229 -    Augment Data can be Transcoded
CW1230 -
CW1231 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 4558, ref SDS 61 4558.
CW1232 -
CW1233 -    Transcoding may have been shown in demonstration of Augment on
CW1234 -    000608, ref SDS 61 4180
CW1235 -
CW1236 -
CW1237 -
CW1238 -
CW13 -

SUBJECTS
Technology Review, Lee, 000525
Starter Technologies Using Develops Experience to Create KM

CY04 -
CY0501 -     ..
CY0502 -    Evaluate Starter Technologies, Volunteers
CY0503 -
CY0504 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 4084, ref SDS 61 4084.
CY0505 -
CY0506 -    No discussion of evaluations for starter technologies from action
CY0507 -    action item set by Lee Iverson at meeting on 000525. ref SDS 50
CY0508 -    4084
CY0509 -
CY0510 -
CY0511 -
CY0512 -
CY0513 -
CY06 -

SUBJECTS
ZWiki-style Collaborative Document System, 000427
Existing Capability, Start with What is Available, 000302
Pilot Test New Capabilities, 000227
Pilot Test Email for Organizing and Thought Tracking, 000428
DKR Starter Technologies, Email, Begin Using a System, 000504

DB07 -
DB0801 -     ..
DB0802 -    Pilot Test Wiki for DKR Collaboration
DB0803 -    Starter Technology Pilot Testing Wiki for Better Collaboration
DB0804 -    Wiki Addressable Email Enhances Project Collaboration
DB0805 -
DB0806 -    Follow up ref SDS 65 9000, ref SDS 62 0001.
DB0807 -
DB0808 -    Team continuing to develop Wiki DKR prototype environment, per
DB0809 -    discussion on 000615. ref SDS 65 3729
DB0811 -     ..
DB0812 -    Team needs experience integrating information on Wiki DKR with
DB0813 -    daily working information explained in Doug's 1972 paper, reviewed
DB0814 -    on 000327. ref SDS 15 3971
DB0815 -
DB0816 -        [On 000727 team discouraged about progress with Wiki.
DB0817 -        ref SDS 74 9000
DB0818 -
DB0819 -
DB0820 -
DB0821 -
DB0822 -
DB09 -